[DEBATE] Killer Bee(Kifflom) vs Kisame (YounqDebater)

TRE MERCER

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
May 13, 2014
Messages
13,251
Reaction score
487
[DEBATE] - Killer Bee (Kifflom) vs Kisame (YounqDebater)

Starting Distance: 40m
Location: Destroyed Konoha
Intel: Full
Intent: To Kill
Mindset: IC
Restrictions: None

--YounqDebater (Original Debater) will make the first post
--Each poster will get to post 2 times
--We need 3 judges

Judge 1: Titanium
Judge 2:Apex
Judge 3:Kidgamer65
 
Last edited:

Joker

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jun 25, 2013
Messages
29,426
Reaction score
1,559
I'll judge, if there's a debate. Too many debates get started but never finish.
 

Joker

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jun 25, 2013
Messages
29,426
Reaction score
1,559
Yes judge and this debate will only end when we have a verdict.

Then limit the replies to three each, opening, counter argument, closing. Should keep it organized.
 

ARGUS

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 14, 2014
Messages
6,324
Reaction score
319
I'll judge, if there's a debate. Too many debates get started but never finish.

This debate only has 2 posts per user
It won't be long at all.
As long as we have a verdict
 

ARGUS

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 14, 2014
Messages
6,324
Reaction score
319
Then limit the replies to three each, opening, counter argument, closing. Should keep it organized.

And no.
We are doing our opening in post 1
And countering and conclusions are done in post 2
 

Lord of Akatsuki

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Apr 7, 2014
Messages
712
Reaction score
45
If you guys are aware of how judging works then sure

I mostly know, a judge in this thread has to chose which debater has in their opinion the better augment. Am I right?

Edit, I don't favour either Kisame or Bee, so I shouldn't be bias.
 
Last edited:

UzumakiWade

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Veteran
Joined
Apr 18, 2014
Messages
2,487
Reaction score
121
If you guys are aware of how judging works then sure

Yes i am quite familiar with judging, I've read enough of these type of debates to at least be qualified. Basically once either of you have made your posts we as judges read both debaters post and point out the flaws and also decide which post was better. We also must not be biased towards a character (i don't favour either character of which you both are debating about so don't worry.) or like one debater more than another. The winner is decided when more of the judges likes one debaters arguments which is why the amount of judges is an odd number. Im sorry if it seems like im being arrogant or thinking of myself as flawless, obviously everyone has their flaws but im quite excited to be a judge.Also i apologize if my English isn't that good since I'm from Malaysia and we speak Malay most of the time.
 

TRE MERCER

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
May 13, 2014
Messages
13,251
Reaction score
487
Going to start this off by saying my opening won't be long because im just going to cut straight into this and save the finishing blows my second post.




You must be registered for see images

Countering Killer Bee in close combat.




Countering Killer Bee in full Hachibi mode.


So once Killer Bee goes full Hachibi mode Kisame does . This will give Kisame the room and space he needs from Hachibi. Note- I already know this won't be much of an advantage for Kisame because Hachibi is a good swimmer plus he can breath underwater. Hachibi durability isn't much honestly his tentacle's has been cut by multiple things , ,Hell even the side of Hachibi's hand(which isn't sharp at all) . Also for those who think his body durability is so superior to it's tentacles this scan says These which are nothing but long giant size Kunai pierced Hachibi's actual With that being stated 1000 feedings sharks combo-ed by GSB should deal Hachibi enough damage to where he has to turn back into Killer bee.


You must be registered for see images
Countering Hachibi's Bijuudama/Bijuudama barrages.


Great water shark bullet is the perfect counter for Bijuudama's except for those on Juubi level. GSB is a hude water shark that absorbs chakra to get bigger and stronger. Bijuudama's are small in size before they With it's more than capable to swallow those Bijuudama's some might say GSB has a limit which might be true but i believe it's limit is based on size. The more chakra it absorbs from the Bijuudama barrage the bigger and stronger it gets.

Trying to stop GSB with a Bijuudama barrage would be like trying to put a fire out with gasoline. Because Gasoline(Bijuudama's) would only feed the fire(Great water shark bullet) and make it wilder and bigger to cause more damage and increase it's output. By the time it gets to Hachibi the power a force behide it will be enough to one shot it.


 
Last edited:

Unorthodox

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Feb 11, 2012
Messages
16,325
Reaction score
693
damn reading OD post gave me a headache
 
Last edited:

ARGUS

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 14, 2014
Messages
6,324
Reaction score
319
Sorry for the late reply, i just didnt get my hands on a computer

Summary of how Killer bee wins

--Now that killer bee isnt affected by Sabu and Racoon, he can use his full power (i.e the hachibi) and take down kisame rather easily, through his sheer magnitude of firepower

--he can use the 8-tails whirlwind which is the perfect counter to GSB and can blow away kisame along with it,

--he can use which would completely nuke kisame off the planet, and inb4, ''GSB absorbs it, and gets bigger'', thats pure wrong since GSB would still take some time absorbing a TBB,and the constant barrage effect therefore counters the GSB due to the TBB collision causing an explosion with a magnitude that will kill kisame

--his hachibi form also enabless him to reform any of the fallen tentacles and also enables him to counter water dome by swimming perfectly in it,

-- is even more beneficial for Killer bee, seeing how it canonically , as doing this would also take away well over a half of kisames arsenal, and put him at a major disdvantage, as killer bee can also use it, to absorb kisames chakra as well

--kisame simply has nothing at all on killer bees firepower, and with which has a higher durability than kisame, as well as hachibi possessing the whirlwind, means that killer bee possessing the non-chakra oriented ninjutsu methods to take out kisame, thus ensuring his win



Countering Killer Bee in close combat.[/CENTER]

For starters Kisame already gave a decent counter for Killer bee in close combat in the manga chapters Killer bee's throwing utensils isn't really much since Kisame already at close range and he didn't even see it coming.
Agreed with all but the bold,
, if you notice the bottom right panel,

Same goes for Killer bee's speed Kisame who was in a grudge match with still managed to all while his back was turned.
Thats fine and all, but that was base bee, when killer bee transformed to his V2, , and he even admits it that killer bee got him, it was only right towards the end of this encounter that kisame managed to suck some chakra off, however the fact that killer bee landed a lethal blow on him clearly means that kisame is much slower than him, as he couldnt prevent himself properly without samehada returning the chakra that was absorbed prior to that encounter


Also Kisame can absorb Killer bee's chakra without even making any real contact shown
This is wrong again, which has raiton infused in it to increase its penetrative power, as , as to how the blade failed to pierce him and how kisame absorbed killer bees chakra,

Kisame proving he can fight on par with Killer bee while in his 7tailed chakra Here Kisame proving he can react to Killer bee's speed doesn't matter which version of chakra modes
Already debunked this claim,
Kisame didnt react to V2 lariat in that encounter at all,
killer bee perfectly landed the blow on kIsame, as the latter needed the

Even though Kisame takes heavy damage It's pretty useless because Kisame has Samehada to heal any of the he receive during the course of the battle. With all this being stated Killer bee has no way of winning this without going into full Hachibi mode.
Agreed,

Countering Killer Bee in full Hachibi mode.

So once Killer Bee goes full Hachibi mode Kisame does . This will give Kisame the room and space he needs from Hachibi. Note- I already know this won't be much of an advantage for Kisame because Hachibi is a good swimmer plus he can breath underwater.
--This is a terrible decision for Kisame, as the longer the distance gets, not only would kisame be unable to absorb killer bees chakra properly but this would literally allow Killer BEe to attack him through TBB barrages that would nuke kisame off the planet, or he can also use his 8-tails whirlwind which perfectly counter the samehadas absorption abilities,
therefore increasing the distance means suicide for kisame, especially against someone of hachibis firepower

--your note further emphasises how hachibi can counter the water based attacks quite well, the fact that the 5-tails was knocked over and sent flying back through just one-punch means that kisame is sufferring a much worse fate,
not to mention that unlike the V1/V2 chakra shrouds, hachibi form is pure flesh meaning that this time, kisame isnt absorbing chakra effectively before he gets knocked out and then blown away by TBB

Hachibi durability isn't much honestly his tentacle's has been cut by multiple things , ,Hell even the side of Hachibi's hand(which isn't sharp at all) .
Hachibi can reform its tentacles, so that isnt in issue here, not to mention that the fact that something thats magnitude is much higher than anything kisame could dish out, clearly tells us that its durability is just as high as most the other bijuu (bar kurama),


Also for those who think his body durability is so superior to it's tentacles this scan says
Implying that kisames physical attacks are as strong as the 5-tails, thats pure BS if you think thats the case, kisame attempting to land a blow from samehada to hachibs body, , the only difference is that unlike the 5-tails kisame isnt as durable, and would suffer a much worse fate,

These which are nothing but long giant size Kunai pierced Hachibi's actual With that being stated 1000 feedings sharks combo-ed by GSB should deal Hachibi enough damage to where he has to turn back into Killer bee.
Wrong again, killer bee was restrained by the chains here which bind the bijuus chakra,
they are not mere ''long sized kunai''
furthermore you are talking like killer bee woud just stand there and let kisame use GSB and feeding sharks,
once he sees GSB coming, killer bee uses the and sends kisame flying back, seeing how its magnitude is huge and which clearly triumphed over GSB
and took down kisame,

as for the giant feeding sharks, , something thats no where near a TBB
all killer bee needs is one TBB and they are done for, let alone a Super TBB or a TBB barrage which would destroy kisame along with all of his jutsus well,

Countering Hachibi's Bijuudama/Bijuudama barrages.

Great water shark bullet is the perfect counter for Bijuudama's except for those on Juubi level. GSB is a hude water shark that absorbs chakra to get bigger and stronger. Bijuudama's are small in size before they With it's more than capable to swallow those Bijuudama's some might say GSB has a limit which might be true but i believe it's limit is based on size. The more chakra it absorbs from the Bijuudama barrage the bigger and stronger it gets.
Firstly, a TBB doesnt need to be severely large in size to take out GSB and Kisame,
secondly, on top of the fact that you are basing your GSB on pure no-limits fallacy,

secondly, its not just size, but GSB is not absorbing TBB barrages simply becuase not only would it take far too long to absorb one TBB but, once the other TBB collides with the previous one, then GSB is getting taken out, as well as kisame along with it,, and like i said, 8-tails whirlwind is also a perfect counter to GSB,


Trying to stop GSB with a Bijuudama barrage would be like trying to put a fire out with gasoline. Because Gasoline(Bijuudama's) would only feed the fire(Great water shark bullet) and make it wilder and bigger to cause more damage and increase it's output. By the time it gets to Hachibi the power a force behide it will be enough to one shot it.
Again wrong,
TBB barrages would collide before GSB takes its time to absorb the TBB,
its not absorbing TBB that quickly, and its absorption rate at most is in the same league as preta, which would take fairly long to absorb a TBB,
with that being said, Killer Bee can fire off more TBBs, that will explode before GSB absorbs the TBB,
and lastly, claiming that GSB magically absorbs constant TBB instantly is pure BS, and no limits fallacy

 
Last edited:

ARGUS

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 14, 2014
Messages
6,324
Reaction score
319
Remember, that we both have only one post left,
 

TRE MERCER

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
May 13, 2014
Messages
13,251
Reaction score
487


You must be registered for see images

Difference between Preata and GSB.

Preta works slightly different than GSB. Preta path absorbs chakra yes but it doesn't increase it's absorbing size and radius the more chakra it absorbs also it can easily be overwhelm if taken by multiple huge chakra based attacks. I say this because the larger the target the longer it takes to absorb. Take a look here Preta and Samehada absorbing the same thing.(I know GSB doesn't involve Samehada but there absorbing properties are pretty similar). ( )-( ). Both arsorb Bee's chakra but the difference is Preta took a longer time while Kisame absorbing techs just took it all at once even though it didn't absorb the full chakra unlike Preta path. Now imagine if Samehada was like GSB it would not only have took it all at once but instantly since it doesn't take time absorbing chakra it would have got huge thus increase it's size and absorbing power. This is not a pure specalation either Samehada got bigger and grew a mouth for better absorbing ability. Also Samehada first time getting so large because it's opponent have an huge chakra pool.( ).

With all this being stated it means that GSB would absorb the Bijuudama's while there in there smaller form almost instantly and increasing it's size with size comes more absorbtion ability as i've explained above. Also Bijuudama's exploding is non-likly but lets say it does. There explosion is nothing but chakra confirmed when Juubito TSB's took no damage from 4 Juubidama's.( ). Ill show even more evidence that Tailed beast balls are nothing but raw chakra in the explosion. Juubito's TSB tanked that Juubidama but yet some of them shatted when they were hit by a Susanoo arrow in an uncharged Bijuudama.( ). Unless you think that that attack magnitude> A Juubidama's. So basically even if they go off there still nothing but GSB steroids.



Sorry for the late reply, i just didnt get my hands on a computer

Summary of how Killer bee wins

--Now that killer bee isnt affected by Sabu and Racoon, he can use his full power (i.e the hachibi) and take down kisame rather easily, through his sheer magnitude of firepower

--he can use the 8-tails whirlwind which is the perfect counter to GSB and can blow away kisame along with it,

--he can use which would completely nuke kisame off the planet, and inb4, ''GSB absorbs it, and gets bigger'', thats pure wrong since GSB would still take some time absorbing a TBB,and the constant barrage effect therefore counters the GSB due to the TBB collision causing an explosion with a magnitude that will kill kisame

--his hachibi form also enabless him to reform any of the fallen tentacles and also enables him to counter water dome by swimming perfectly in it,

-- is even more beneficial for Killer bee, seeing how it canonically , as doing this would also take away well over a half of kisames arsenal, and put him at a major disdvantage, as killer bee can also use it, to absorb kisames chakra as well

--kisame simply has nothing at all on killer bees firepower, and with which has a higher durability than kisame, as well as hachibi possessing the whirlwind, means that killer bee possessing the non-chakra oriented ninjutsu methods to take out kisame, thus ensuring his win

Pretty good summary but i shitted on most of the points you made in my opener not to mention my GSB and Preta opener for this as well.


Agreed with all but the bold,
, if you notice the bottom right panel,


Thats fine and all, but that was base bee, when killer bee transformed to his V2, , and he even admits it that killer bee got him, it was only right towards the end of this encounter that kisame managed to suck some chakra off, however the fact that killer bee landed a lethal blow on him clearly means that kisame is much slower than him, as he couldnt prevent himself properly without samehada returning the chakra that was absorbed prior to that encounter.

Yea your right he did notice it but it was late notice and he still managed to duck it. Actually Kisame absorbed his chakra multiple times.( )-( ). Kisame did react to Killer bee he just didn't know that punch had enough force in it to pierce Samahada and put a giant gash in his body.( ). If you look closely you can see the hole in Samehada.( ).


This is wrong again, which has raiton infused in it to increase its penetrative power, as , as to how the blade failed to pierce him and how kisame absorbed killer bees chakra,


Already debunked this claim,
Kisame didnt react to V2 lariat in that encounter at all,
killer bee perfectly landed the blow on kIsame, as the latter needed the

Actually they didn't make contact Sabu confirms that Kisame blade can absorb chakra before any contact is made.( ). Countered the rest of this post above.


Agreed,


--This is a terrible decision for Kisame, as the longer the distance gets, not only would kisame be unable to absorb killer bees chakra properly but this would literally allow Killer BEe to attack him through TBB barrages that would nuke kisame off the planet, or he can also use his 8-tails whirlwind which perfectly counter the samehadas absorption abilities,
therefore increasing the distance means suicide for kisame, especially against someone of hachibis firepower

--your note further emphasises how hachibi can counter the water based attacks quite well, the fact that the 5-tails was knocked over and sent flying back through just one-punch means that kisame is sufferring a much worse fate,
not to mention that unlike the V1/V2 chakra shrouds, hachibi form is pure flesh meaning that this time, kisame isnt absorbing chakra effectively before he gets knocked out and then blown away by TBB.

Actually long range would benefit Kisame. Tbb barrages are useless because Kisame can travel underground via Subterranean Voyage A technique that transforms the earth surrounding the user into a fluid, allowing them to close in on the enemy with high speed by swimming underground. Since being under the ground is a blind spot, the target has no warning; allowing the user to launch a surprise attack. By using this technique in conjunction with a weapon, it also gains great effect as an "assault ninjutsu". Hachibi's speed is poor since it can't even walk so landing a direct blow on Kisame is not happening. When Kisame gets out of Hachibi's line of sight via Subterranean Voyage he does GCW to give him the natural advantage.


Hachibi can reform its tentacles, so that isnt in issue here, not to mention that the fact that something thats magnitude is much higher than anything kisame could dish out, clearly tells us that its durability is just as high as most the other bijuu (bar kurama),



Implying that kisames physical attacks are as strong as the 5-tails, thats pure BS if you think thats the case, kisame attempting to land a blow from samehada to hachibs body, , the only difference is that unlike the 5-tails kisame isnt as durable, and would suffer a much worse fate,

Hachibi tanking it's own Bijuudama means nothing to Kisame because most of his attacks are cutting force which is Hachibi's weakness. Cutting/Pierceing force>Blunt/Trauma force. Gai EE which is very devastating could pierce Juubi Jin Madara's body but Sasuke regular blade did.( ). Which is more proof that cutting force>Blunt. Yes i believe Kisame can do what the 5tails did because unlike blunt force cutting force doesn't have to have a strong output for a good input.


Wrong again, killer bee was restrained by the chains here which bind the bijuus chakra,
they are not mere ''long sized kunai''
furthermore you are talking like killer bee woud just stand there and let kisame use GSB and feeding sharks,
once he sees GSB coming, killer bee uses the and sends kisame flying back, seeing how its magnitude is huge and which clearly triumphed over GSB
and took down kisame,

as for the giant feeding sharks, , something thats no where near a TBB
all killer bee needs is one TBB and they are done for, let alone a Super TBB or a TBB barrage which would destroy kisame along with all of his jutsus well,

Just because the chains restrain there chakra does not mean there tougher than the average Kunai. Actually Kisame can go underground and hit him with a surprise GSB to the back. Hirudora is pure blunt force that's why. 8tails whirlwind is not getting rid of GSB it would probably tumble it over and throw it around but i doubt that would stop the attack since it took a giant Hirodora straight through it mouth. Morning Peacock is fire and when fire meets water they completely match each other out that's why i said the 1000k feeding sharks combo-ed by GSB would do the trick.


Firstly, a TBB doesnt need to be severely large in size to take out GSB and Kisame,
secondly, on top of the fact that you are basing your GSB on pure no-limits fallacy,

secondly, its not just size, but GSB is not absorbing TBB barrages simply becuase not only would it take far too long to absorb one TBB but, once the other TBB collides with the previous one, then GSB is getting taken out, as well as kisame along with it,, and like i said, 8-tails whirlwind is also a perfect counter to GSB,



Again wrong,
TBB barrages would collide before GSB takes its time to absorb the TBB,
its not absorbing TBB that quickly, and its absorption rate at most is in the same league as preta, which would take fairly long to absorb a TBB,
with that being said, Killer Bee can fire off more TBBs, that will explode before GSB absorbs the TBB,
and lastly, claiming that GSB magically absorbs constant TBB instantly is pure BS, and no limits fallacy
Actually they do tbb's are small if there uncharge especially if there in ball form.( ). The size these things are GSB would suck them dry before they even had time to explode. Actually it's not a no limit fallacy because GSB gets bigger the more chakra it absorbs unlike Preta which takes a considerable amount of time to absorb things that has no where near the chakra of a tbb. I already explained this trying to stop GSB is like trying to drown a fire in gasoline expecting it to put it out. What stomps Kisame from making clones and using multiple GSB's? His water clones may only carry 10% of his chakra but that's still alot since His chakra is compared to Kurama/Naruto.( ).
 

ARGUS

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 14, 2014
Messages
6,324
Reaction score
319
Counters to GSB

I feel the need to address this, since you seem to think that GSB is nigh invincible and its nothing but wrong

--8-tails whirlwind is the perfect counter for GSB here and with Killer Bee having full intel here, he would immediately resort to thiis technique due to him knowing of GSB absorption abilities,
, not only that but the , and the attack not possessing any chakra oriented ninjutsu properties clearly means that GSB is never absorbing this,
and inb4, ''GSB tanks it'' no, thats wrong again,
and magnitude are comparable to , and took down kisame completely,
with that being said, 8-tails whirlwind does exactly the same as what hirudora did to GSB and takes down kisame

--GSB barely has any absorbing feats at all, despite of kisames statement, which yu are pretty much relying on throughout this debate, which is apparrent due to ur lack of scans,
Firstly, (if you notice the bottom right panel), as absorbing something as large as TBB (in terms of chakra) is not only time consuming but also leaves kisame as a sitting duck, as that will explode, , therefore bee can do the same here,
since GSB clearly wont be able to absorb the TBBs before they explode,
since not only do TBB travel extremely fast, but as shown the barrages of TBB would result in a collision of TBB thus resulting in a larger aftermath which eradicate GSB along with kisame,

--GSB is also not absorbing the , as Bee doesnt havee to aim right towards GSB, he can aim at a further location, andd Kisame would still be affected due their vast AOE, moreover the TBB explosions are not chakra oriented, they are simply the aftermath/shock of the explosion that are caused due to the TBB landing in contact with an object,

--So in summary bee has several ways to counter the GSB, they are as follows:

1. He can use the 8-tails whirlwind which is the first method bee would use, and would be able to get rid of GSB
it is also the best method, which you really have stated no methods for

2. He can use the barrages of TBB that would not only explode before GSB absorbs them, but would also kill kisame along with them

3. He doesnt have to aim the TBB right at GSB, as Killer Bee can aim them at a further location and Kisame is bound to be severely hurt by them, due to their vast AOE,

4. GSB still has a rate of absorption as shown, and with GSB taking a long time to absorb something as big as only one TBB, it is not absorbing the barrages of TBB since the TBB would not only travel faster than GSB's absorption rate but would also result in a larger explosion that would kill kisame



Difference between Preata and GSB.
Preta works slightly different than GSB. Preta path absorbs chakra yes but it doesn't increase it's absorbing size and radius the more chakra it absorbs also it can easily be overwhelm if taken by multiple huge chakra based attacks. I say this because the larger the target the longer it takes to absorb. Take a look here Preta and Samehada absorbing the same thing.(I know GSB doesn't involve Samehada but there absorbing properties are pretty similar). ( )-( ).
@Bold - you have just stated that Preta and Samehada have similar absorption abilities, yet you are trying to explain GSB here, when both the jutsus are completely different, and GSB barely has any feats of absorption

you admitting to the fact that GSB and Samehada share similar absorption abilities simply means that GSB is not absorbing more than 6 tails worth of V1 chakra shroud,
, as Kisame himself stated that
TBB by ur way of understanding would be well out of GSB's limits,
not to mention that GSB also has an absorption rate, which is clearly slower than the distance that the TBB would travel and

furthermore preta and Samehada are not the same, preta shits on samehada in terms of absorption and versatility
preta is a
which is why the preta along with the caster are pretty much unfazed by the jutsus effect,

samehada on the other hand is a physical being, which is why it was
as the flames were still there but simply repelled away from bee and naruto

however , and the flames were not apparrent at all,
not to mention that as opposed to samehada that not only failed to absorb the entire chakra but their impact

with that being said,
Pretas feats of absorption and versatility is on a much higher level than samehada


Both arsorb Bee's chakra but the difference is Preta took a longer time while Kisame absorbing techs just took it all at once even though it didn't absorb the full chakra unlike Preta path. Now imagine if Samehada was like GSB it would not only have took it all at once but instantly since it doesn't take time absorbing chakra it would have got huge thus increase it's size and absorbing power. This is not a pure specalation either Samehada got bigger and grew a mouth for better absorbing ability. Also Samehada first time getting so large because it's opponent have an huge chakra pool.( ).With all this being stated it means that GSB would absorb the Bijuudama's while there in there smaller form almost instantly and increasing it's size with size comes more absorbtion ability as i've explained above.
This post is pure speculation and misinterpretation of the manga,
1. , whereas
so ur calculation of rate of absorption is nothing but wrong and inaccurate, since the amount of chakra absorbed is clearly different

2. Samehada is not GSB, you state that GSB=/=Samehada when it comes to samehadas limits of V1 6-tails, but then you are claiming that ''GSB is like samehada'' but can absorb a TBB, Lol this is nothing but pure speculation since you have no scans regarding GSB at all, let alone absorbing something as large as TBB,
all you are relying on is a mere statement by kisame, which is clearly not backed up by any feats,

3. GSB clearly has an absorption rate as i have stated above, as nothing in kisames arsenal can absorb something as large as TBB instantly that pure BS, not to mention that you claiming that GSB is like Samehada makes ur post even funnier,


Also Bijuudama's exploding is non-likly but lets say it does. There explosion is nothing but chakra confirmed when Juubito TSB's took no damage from 4 Juubidama's.( ). Ill show even more evidence that Tailed beast balls are nothing but raw chakra in the explosion. Juubito's TSB tanked that Juubidama but yet some of them shatted when they were hit by a Susanoo arrow in an uncharged Bijuudama.( ). Unless you think that that attack magnitude> A Juubidama's. So basically even if they go off there still nothing but GSB steroids.
This doesnt prove anything, and again its wrong, especially since TSB =/= Samehada and GSB
, therefore his TSB negated the TBB not the explosion, meaning that yu havnt proven anything at all ,
and i dont see why you are bringing up juubito here, its completely irrelevant and its obvious that juubito >>>>>>>>>>>>>> kisame


Pretty good summary but i shitted on most of the points you made in my opener not to mention my GSB and Preta opener for this as well.
@Bold - honeslty thats all u needed to say, ur points are purely based on speculation and are mostly wrong,
to a point where i had to make an opener specifically based on how killer bee counters GSB, wins the match, and why the "no-limits-fallacy'' is used to a ridiculous extent,


Yea your right he did notice it but it was late notice and he still managed to duck it.
Late notice or not, killer bee still landed lethal blows on him despite his chakra getting absorbed, despite him having no intel at all, despite him being nerfed to not using the hachibi, and despite him being limited due to the company of sabu and the racoon

Actually they didn't make contact Sabu confirms that Kisame blade can absorb chakra before any contact is made.( ). Countered the rest of this post above.
No, , meaning that the sword prevented kisame from getting pierced,
samehadas charka absorption rate is extremely limited to the distance, and is not absorbing chakra of an entity more than 5 metres away


Actually long range would benefit Kisame. Tbb barrages are useless because Kisame can travel underground via Subterranean Voyage A technique that transforms the earth surrounding the user into a fluid, allowing them to close in on the enemy with high speed by swimming underground. Since being under the ground is a blind spot, the target has no warning; allowing the user to launch a surprise attack. By using this technique in conjunction with a weapon, it also gains great effect as an "assault ninjutsu". Hachibi's speed is poor since it can't even walk so landing a direct blow on Kisame is not happening. When Kisame gets out of Hachibi's line of sight via Subterranean Voyage he does GCW to give him the natural advantage.
Thats good and all,
but these attacks are still meaningless against hachibi,
the fact that kisame still has to appear out of underground in-order to attack allows hachibi to fire off the TBB and finish him right there,
Hachibi also doesnt need to be able to walk, since its , as kisame is sufferring a much worst fate here, not to mention that one blow would then allow the hachibi to fire off the TBB and finish kisame off,

GCW is utmost non factor since not only can hachibi swim perfectly under water, but it is also just a suiton, and still doesnt prevent kisame from TBB once he comes out of underground meaning that at a long range distance he is done for, especially when the hachibi can form these barrrages quite fast

seeing how it didnt want to cut base bees chakra,
full hachibis chakra would make it turn against kisame rather quickly

Hachibi tanking it's own Bijuudama means nothing to Kisame because most of his attacks are cutting force which is Hachibi's weakness. Cutting/Pierceing force>Blunt/Trauma force. Gai EE which is very devastating could pierce Juubi Jin Madara's body but Sasuke regular blade did.( ). Which is more proof that cutting force>Blunt. Yes i believe Kisame can do what the 5tails did because unlike blunt force cutting force doesn't have to have a strong output for a good input.
Then prove to me if you think that samehadas cutting blows are as strong as the 5-tails horns,
i am well aware that cutting force =/= explosive damage,
however the TBB was in referrence to hachibis BODY durability, which you still consider weak
he can simply reform his tentacles whenver he needs to and his tails, span more than enough distance to hit kisame at least once, as the latter is clearly not renowned for his speed,
and the hachibi managed to cover his body from amaterasu through his tentacles,


Just because the chains restrain there chakra does not mean there tougher than the average Kunai. Actually Kisame can go underground and hit him with a surprise GSB to the back. Hirudora is pure blunt force that's why. 8tails whirlwind is not getting rid of GSB it would probably tumble it over and throw it around but i doubt that would stop the attack since it took a giant Hirodora straight through it mouth.
The chains completely bind the bijuus chakra and leave them immobilised,
which was mainly how
a kunai is no where near as strong, you should read the manga proprely if you think that kunais are as strong as the mazos chains

8-tails whirlwind is just as strong as hirudora, i have shown u several scans as to why thats the case, and the whirlwind is also similar to hirudora in terms of effect,
GSB wont tumble or throw over,, the jutsu is succumbed and kisame is dying thats all thats happening
moreover GSB didnt take hirudora, the latter completely triumphed over it, thus causing kisame to get taken out

Morning Peacock is fire and when fire meets water they completely match each other out that's why i said the 1000k feeding sharks combo-ed by GSB would do the trick.
Lol no, When water meets fire, the fire gets extinguished, its simple
a suiton would always emerge victorious when stacked against it, unless a katon is S-class, and a suiton is D-rank,


Actually they do tbb's are small if there uncharge especially if there in ball form.( ). The size these things are GSB would suck them dry before they even had time to explode. Actually it's not a no limit fallacy because GSB gets bigger the more chakra it absorbs unlike Preta which takes a considerable amount of time to absorb things that has no where near the chakra of a tbb. I already explained this trying to stop GSB is like trying to drown a fire in gasoline expecting it to put it out.What stomps Kisame from making clones and using multiple GSB's? His water clones may only carry 10% of his chakra but that's still alot since His chakra is compared to Kurama/Naruto.( ).
Actually it doesnt matter if TBB's are small, GSB is not absorbing them instantly and thats that, meaning that the other 4 or so TBB would collide with each other before GSB is finished with even absorbing one, and the collision would result in kisame dying its as simple as that,

and yes it is a no-limits fallacy, since not only does GSB lacks the feats to be able to absorb something as large as TBB but its also logically impossible, not to mention that killer bee doesnt have to aim them riight towards GSB and can aim them slightly away as kisame woould still get affected by their large AOE,
moreover claiming that GSB absorbs something as large as chakra dense as TBB instantly is also severely wrong, and the fact that GSB barely has any feats makes this very tough for kisame to win
 
Last edited:

ARGUS

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 14, 2014
Messages
6,324
Reaction score
319
the debate is finished,
you may judge
 

Joker

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jun 25, 2013
Messages
29,426
Reaction score
1,559
I apologize for the late judgement, I had other obligations I didn't forsee. Now moving onto the debate itself, you each provided arguments, backed up with scans. In the beginning, I felt as if YounqDebater's opening was really weak, he could've provided more to force his approach, and make his side more believeable. While Kiff, he came in, saw the opening, and just went at it. The way he ripped through after each paragraph made me wonder if he was the one representing Kisame, definately had shark teeth there. Then Younq picked himself up from his previous slip, came in and told it how it was -- I liked that, but what got me, was when Younq said the chain's probably aren't stronger than the average kunai, that was his downfall (along with the font choice, u_u). Kiff quickly exploited Younq's mistakes and turned it against him, such as his water versus fire argument, and the Hachibi's whirlwind.

In my opinion, the debate goes to Kifflom
 

ARGUS

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 14, 2014
Messages
6,324
Reaction score
319
I apologize for the late judgement, I had other obligations I didn't forsee. Now moving onto the debate itself, you each provided arguments, backed up with scans. In the beginning, I felt as if YounqDebater's opening was really weak, he could've provided more to force his approach, and make his side more believeable. While Kiff, he came in, saw the opening, and just went at it. The way he ripped through after each paragraph made me wonder if he was the one representing Kisame, definately had shark teeth there. Then Younq picked himself up from his previous slip, came in and told it how it was -- I liked that, but what got me, was when Younq said the chain's probably aren't stronger than the average kunai, that was his downfall (along with the font choice, u_u). Kiff quickly exploited Younq's mistakes and turned it against him, such as his water versus fire argument, and the Hachibi's whirlwind.

In my opinion, the debate goes to Kifflom
Thanks man, i appreciate it :)
 
Top