alice and elmage have a special relationship, and it looks as though she's slipping TMI on his alignment being town, because she's 100% on the defence with that post and countering his points that he didn't even make yet. (which is just generically wolfy, even bringing in night kills? cmon.)
but the point being that it looks as though she doesn't have her mind made up yet at all / there's no progression on his alignment even though almost a half of the thread opened up saying he was a wolf.
and then Elmage voting for Alice should've really riled her up imo and glean into his alignment somehow, but she's in full defence mode already and is appealing to him. it's woalfy because obv no progression on Elmage (and isn't even trying to "Oh Elmage, I thought you knew how to...") and she's bringing in her relationship with elmage in play where the only way she can move him off her is by defending herself (at least in her eyes)
hope this makes a bit of sense. there's basically no progression in her head on Elmage (that you can gleam from her TOAN) and her tone seems to be placed in an exact w/v scenario against her and Elmage. i reckon this one's harder to make sense of, you'd really need to have seen their dynamic previously.