Alright, here's a proper theme suggestion beside the potential Murder Mystery/Crime Fiction one that me and Pete have been cooking. It's more so a layout than a theme and this is just the basics of the idea:
Plane Crash on a Deserted Island (Using tv series Lost as inspiration)
Your plane has crashed somewhere over the Pacific Oceans in the middle of nowhere. Somehow, some way, you and 5 other survivors have managed to get a lifeboat going as you reach the shore of a deserted island. What happens next?
...
You could potentially flesh this out Dan if you'd like with your own version of it, maybe give us an idea of who the 5 other characters are and what the first thing we do as we come ashore is, maybe include a list of what the survivors need to do or go through, or keep it entirely open. This idea hit me while at work totally by random, so thought I would toss it out there to see what people think. Reason I think this is cool is because everyone would have the same basis/premise for place and characters, but people could go off in total different directions as to what genre it is. Is it a Romance? Horror story? Or something else?
PS: It doesn't have to be 1st person or you yourself as main character. That's just part of the example.
@The Pervy Sage
@Gutsy
@Omega
@Alice in Noodleland
@Michelle