Comparing A and Minato

Rayder

Active member
Elite
Joined
Dec 22, 2011
Messages
9,569
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
I'm not doing this to get anyone mad I'm just looking at the differences between them in different areas. Then I will just rate them out of 10 in that certain area. I will explain for each one except for ones which are obvious .

Taijutsu

Minato:Minato is pretty good at Taijutsu but his pure physical strength is nothing extraordinary. He is pretty good with his Kunai's and mixes different Kunai attacks with Rasengans and FTG. 7/10

A: A is incredibly good at Taijutsu and his sheer power behind attacks are fantastic. His use of Lightning Armour makes his Taijutsu skills even stronger. The mix of a ninjutsu used to strengthen a Taijutsu is called Nin-Taijutsu, A's personal type of Taijutsu. 9/10


Ninjutsu

Minato:Minato has not shown many ninjutsu since we have not seen a lot of him compared to others but he created the Rasengan which he even taught to his master,Jiraiya. He must know some other ninjutsu's though since he was chosen as Hokage for a reason. Also his creation of FTG and customizing it to fit his Kunai. 5.5/10

A: Lightning Armour is a great ninjutsu providing increased speed,defence and reflexes. He also mixes this with Taijutsu. 5.5/10

Genjustu

Neither of them have shown any genjutsu skills so I can't rate them on that.

Summoning

Minato: Minato has a contract with frogs and has shown that he is able to summon Gamabunta and Gerotora(the scroll toad). He also used Gamabunta for the food cart destroyer technique. He is not as adapt as Jiraiya with summoning though. 8/10

A: A has not shown any Summons.

Strength

Minato: Minato is pretty good sheer power able to knock out cloud chuunin when he was saving Kushina at a young age. He does not rely on Pure strength a lot so we have not seen a lot of this.5/10

A: A has incredible physical strength and with Lightning Armour it is greatly improved and his raw muscle show in his body. 9/10

Intelligence

Minato: Minato was called a genius by everyone who knew him. He was also a master strategist and devised a way to beat Tobi's intangibility. 9/10

A: A was never the thinker type but is no dummy. His intelligence is drastically lowered when he is bloodlusted and he gets extremely reckless. He stops caring about personal safety and just concentrates on doing whatever he can to kill the opponent, even if it costs him his limbs or his life. 5/10

Speed

Minato: 10/10

A: 9.89/10

Sealing

Minato: Minato has shown a variety of sealing jutsu's and his wife is a sealing jutsu expert. 9/10

A: A has not shown any Sealing Jutsu.

Endurance

Minato:6.5/10

A: A was able to endure having his arm engulfed in Ameterasu for about 10 minutes and amputated without even flinching. 9/10

Chakra Levels

Minato: Minato has great chakra levels able to FTG numerous times, fight off Tobi,use a Summoning, use a space/time jutsu and use lots of different sealing jutsu's. 7/10

A: A has bijuu level chakra. The only non-jinchuuriki who is even near the same chakra level is probably Kisame.10/10

That is the end of my evaluation on A and Minato's abilities.
Any areas which I have forgotten please remind me. (I would not mind getting rep for this great evaluation;);))
 
Last edited:

Zoro..

Active member
Elite
Joined
Nov 19, 2011
Messages
9,661
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
I disagree with a few parts on this.
Chakra levels Minato has a ridiculous amount because he can use S/T techs so much and also for endurance we havent seen Minato and for strength and taijutsu we havent seen him either
You cant really make an evaluation without enough knowledge...
 

Minator93

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Oct 14, 2011
Messages
14,301
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Ninjutsu 5.5 :eek:

Its 8.7 for Minato and 0.13 for A....A's lost his ability to perform Handseals...so no Ninjutsu unless he knows Haku's special Jutsu but that's not possible because it was a KKG

Sealing Minato 7 WTH then please tell me who is above that and again its 0 for A because of no hand-seals...unless he manages to get hold of Itachi's Double MS and obtains Totsuka.

The comparison is flawed in many ways...I was going to ignore it completely but had to mention at-least the above two.
 

Illyasviel

Active member
Elite
Joined
Dec 7, 2011
Messages
6,694
Kin
4💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Ninjutsu 5.5 :eek:

Its 8.7 for Minato and 0.13 for A....A's lost his ability to perform Handseals...so no Ninjutsu unless he knows Haku's special Jutsu but that's not possible because it was a KKG

Sealing Minato 7 WTH then please tell me who is above that and again its 0 for A because of no hand-seals...unless he manages to get hold of Itachi's Double MS and obtains Totsuka.

The comparison is flawed in many ways...I was going to ignore it completely but had to mention at-least the above two.
And this also
 

Miztik

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Oct 12, 2011
Messages
2,659
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
---------Minato----A

Ninjutsu - 9.5 ----- 6
Taijutsu - 7 ------- 9
Speed --- 10 ----- 9
Strength - 5 ----- 10
Endurance- 7 ----- 9
Chakra --- 8.5 ---- 9.5
Intelligence- 9 ----- 8
 
Last edited:

Rayder

Active member
Elite
Joined
Dec 22, 2011
Messages
9,569
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
Ninjutsu 5.5 :eek:

Its 8.7 for Minato and 0.13 for A....A's lost his ability to perform Handseals...so no Ninjutsu unless he knows Haku's special Jutsu but that's not possible because it was a KKG

Sealing Minato 7 WTH then please tell me who is above that and again its 0 for A because of no hand-seals...unless he manages to get hold of Itachi's Double MS and obtains Totsuka.

The comparison is flawed in many ways...I was going to ignore it completely but had to mention at-least the above two.
The only ninjutsu we have seen from Minato is rasengan so I don't think that that that is enough to give him a 8.7. If it is then Konohamaru should also be a 8.7. Lightning Armour is a ninjutsu just because it is instantaneous does that mean its not classed as a ninjutsu. Why should A be 0.13 and Minato 8.7 when both of them have showed just 1 ninjutsu.

I admit I was a bit deep on the score for sealing I will have to edit it.
 

-Vegeta-

Active member
Elite
Joined
Jun 8, 2011
Messages
9,385
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I really don't see the point of this thread and I see no reason to compare their abilities.

They're 2 completely different shinobi. Minato relies on skill, intelligence, and speed. A relies on speed and brute force.

Also A has already admitted inferiority to Minato.
 

natssuu

Active member
Elite
Joined
Jun 18, 2011
Messages
9,133
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
The only ninjutsu we have seen from Minato is rasengan so I don't think that that that is enough to give him a 8.7. If it is then Konohamaru should also be a 8.7. Lightning Armour is a ninjutsu just because it is instantaneous does that mean its not classed as a ninjutsu. Why should A be 0.13 and Minato 8.7 when both of them have showed just 1 ninjutsu.

I admit I was a bit deep on the score for sealing I will have to edit it.
Minato is good at shape manipulation, his rasengan against Tobi was quite huge and he created it with ease.

FTG is one of the most useful techniques in Narutoverse and Minato developed it himself.

Summons are also ninjutsu, so that increases his ninjutsu skills even more.

But he hasn't shown any elemental technique, so I would give him 8/10.
 

sdam

Member
Joined
Feb 12, 2012
Messages
418
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I'm not doing this to get anyone mad I'm just looking at the differences between them in different areas. Then I will just rate them out of 10 in that certain area. I will explain for each one except for ones which are obvious .

Taijutsu

Minato:Minato is pretty good at Taijutsu but his pure physical strength is nothing extraordinary. He is pretty good with his Kunai's and mixes different Kunai attacks with Rasengans and FTG. 7/10

A: A is incredibly good at Taijutsu and his sheer power behind attacks are fantastic. His use of Lightning Armour makes his Taijutsu skills even stronger. The mix of a ninjutsu used to strengthen a Taijutsu is called Nin-Taijutsu, A's personal type of Taijutsu. 9/10


Ninjutsu

Minato:Minato has not shown many ninjutsu since we have not seen a lot of him compared to others but he created the Rasengan which he even taught to his master,Jiraiya. He must know some other ninjutsu's though since he was chosen as Hokage for a reason. Also his creation of FTG and customizing it to fit his Kunai. 5.5/10

A: Lightning Armour is a great ninjutsu providing increased speed,defence and reflexes. He also mixes this with Taijutsu. 5.5/10

Genjustu

Neither of them have shown any genjutsu skills so I can't rate them on that.

Summoning

Minato: Minato has a contract with frogs and has shown that he is able to summon Gamabunta and Gerotora(the scroll toad). He also used Gamabunta for the food cart destroyer technique. He is not as adapt as Jiraiya with summoning though. 8/10

A: A has not shown any Summons.

Strength

Minato: Minato is pretty good sheer power able to knock out cloud chuunin when he was saving Kushina at a young age. He does not rely on Pure strength a lot so we have not seen a lot of this.5/10

A: A has incredible physical strength and with Lightning Armour it is greatly improved and his raw muscle show in his body. 9/10

Intelligence

Minato: Minato was called a genius by everyone who knew him. He was also a master strategist and devised a way to beat Tobi's intangibility. 9/10

A: A was never the thinker type but is no dummy. His intelligence is drastically lowered when he is bloodlusted and he gets extremely reckless. He stops caring about personal safety and just concentrates on doing whatever he can to kill the opponent, even if it costs him his limbs or his life. 5/10

Speed

Minato: 10/10

A: 9.89/10

Sealing

Minato: Minato has shown a variety of sealing jutsu's and his wife is a sealing jutsu expert. 9/10

A: A has not shown any Sealing Jutsu.

Endurance

Minato:6.5/10

A: A was able to endure having his arm engulfed in Ameterasu for about 10 minutes and amputated without even flinching. 9/10

Chakra Levels

Minato: Minato has great chakra levels able to FTG numerous times, fight off Tobi,use a Summoning, use a space/time jutsu and use lots of different sealing jutsu's. 7/10

A: A has bijuu level chakra. The only non-jinchuuriki who is even near the same chakra level is probably Kisame.10/10

That is the end of my evaluation on A and Minato's abilities.
Any areas which I have forgotten please remind me. (I would not mind getting rep for this great evaluation;);))


The thing about minato's strengt, It was a anime filler, never happened in manga.
 

MasterofSenjutsu

Active member
Regular
Joined
Sep 1, 2011
Messages
1,709
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
The only ninjutsu we have seen from Minato is rasengan so I don't think that that that is enough to give him a 8.7. If it is then Konohamaru should also be a 8.7. Lightning Armour is a ninjutsu just because it is instantaneous does that mean its not classed as a ninjutsu. Why should A be 0.13 and Minato 8.7 when both of them have showed just 1 ninjutsu.

I admit I was a bit deep on the score for sealing I will have to edit it.
I think 8.7 would be valid for chakra. I'm not sure, but I heard that Rasengan requires a lot of chakra to use.
 

aashish1996

Active member
Regular
Joined
Oct 30, 2011
Messages
962
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
The only ninjutsu we have seen from Minato is rasengan so I don't think that that that is enough to give him a 8.7. If it is then Konohamaru should also be a 8.7. Lightning Armour is a ninjutsu just because it is instantaneous does that mean its not classed as a ninjutsu. Why should A be 0.13 and Minato 8.7 when both of them have showed just 1 ninjutsu.

I admit I was a bit deep on the score for sealing I will have to edit it.
Ur kidding right? Isn't a sealing technique ninjutsu, isn't FTG a Ninjutsu, isn't summoning a ninjutsu? Didn't that technique he used during the Kakashi Gaiden where he found out the enemy like the 2nd hokage a ninjutsu? U seriously are kidding us and yourself right??? :confused::confused::confused::confused::confused::confused::confused:
 

Rayder

Active member
Elite
Joined
Dec 22, 2011
Messages
9,569
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
Ur kidding right? Isn't a sealing technique ninjutsu, isn't FTG a Ninjutsu, isn't summoning a ninjutsu? Didn't that technique he used during the Kakashi Gaiden where he found out the enemy like the 2nd hokage a ninjutsu? U seriously are kidding us and yourself right??? :confused::confused::confused::confused::confused::confused::confused:
Summoning is in its own category and so is sealing and he got high scores in both of them so I don't know what your talking about.:rofl::rofl:
 
Top