Chojis clan = yang style users

[iSpeak]

I would still say their ability is more yang then yin. Yin is like susano which is why different users have different susano's yin is imagination and spiritual

Yin governs imagination. Anything that seams abnormal in narutoverse logic would more than likely be Yin release.
Yang release has nothing to do with increasing your size.

 

[Zavage10]

Yin governs imagination. Anything that seams abnormal in narutoverse logic would more than likely be Yin release.
Yang release has nothing to do with increasing your size.

No yin is mental genjutsu

 

[The Hidden Shinobi]

Yin governs imagination. Anything that seams abnormal in narutoverse logic would more than likely be Yin release.
Yang release has nothing to do with increasing your size.

Yin is spiritual susano you can tell when something is spiritual and involves powerful chakra.

Yang is physical, when choji turns big that is physical not spiritual

 

[iSpeak]

No yin is mental genjutsu

No.. genjutsu is just one type of Yin release jutsu. There are other types aswel...

 

[The Hidden Shinobi]

No yin is mental genjutsu

Not just genjutsu, susano and other things aswell.

 

[iSpeak]

Yin is spiritual susano you can tell when something is spiritual and involves powerful chakra.

Yang is physical, when choji turns big that is physical not spiritual

No. Don't get Yin and Yang mixed up with Yin Release and Yang Release. Putting life into things isn't physical... Yang Release is based on vitality. Yang release breathes life into form. Healing is Yang release. What the 1st hokage and Naruto does is Yang release. Yin Release is about creating form. What Choji does is Yin release.

 

[Zavage10]

Yin is spiritual susano you can tell when something is spiritual and involves powerful chakra.

Yang is physical, when choji turns big that is physical not spiritual

Yea you see the same way I do

 

[Titania Erza]

Fodder? I think not! Look at Choji and Choja taking on the Gedo Mazo:

You must be registered for see images

Physically speaking, Choji is the strongest of the Konoha 11.

Naruto is still part of konoha 11 XD and hell no that choji is stronger then Naruto

 

[Zavage10]

In my mind the whole calorie control thing is all physical energy

Imagination plays no part in it it's yang

 

[The Hidden Shinobi]

No. Don't get Yin and Yang mixed up with Yin Release and Yang Release. Putting life into things isn't physical... Yang Release is based on vitality. Yang release breathes life into form. Healing is Yang release. What the 1st hokage and Naruto does is Yang release. Yin Release is about creating form. What Choji does is Yin release.

Yes but the form around him is not spiritual like a susano it is physical. To get that big seems like a little bit of yin but to be physical in that form I believe is yang. But lets not forget:

You must be registered for see images

In yang there is yin and in yin there is yang. So it involving a little of yin and more of yang may be possible. But I think it is mostly yang physical.

 

[iSpeak]

Yes but the form around him is not spiritual like a susano it is physical. To get that big seems like a little bit of yin but to be physical in that form I believe is yang. But lets not forget:

You must be registered for see images

In yang there is yin and in yin there is yang. So it involving a little of yin and more of yang may be possible. But I think it is mostly yang physical.

Susanoo is physical. It materializes the users chakra...
Being physical or not has nothing to do with Yin Release and Yang Release. Like I said, don't get the two mixed up with the Spritual energy and Physical energy used to form chakra.

 

[The Hidden Shinobi]

Susanoo is physical. It materializes the users chakra...
Being physical or not has nothing to do with Yin Release and Yang Release. Like I said, don't get the two mixed up with the Spritual energy and Physical energy used to form chakra.

Susano starts off with imagination and spiritually and the users powerful chakra materialises. Being physical and physical energy is all yang. I will give you an example of another spiritual thing:

You must be registered for see images

In the second to last panel the things coming out there mouth is spiritual. You can tell when something is spiritual.

You must be registered for see images

Shikamaru even says it here in the second to last panel they are mental energy and require stability and are starving for physical energy.
------------------------------------------------------

It is sooo obvious when something is spiritual and when something is physical choji going big is physical not spiritual.

 

[iSpeak]

Susano starts off with imagination and spiritually and the users powerful chakra materialises. Being physical and physical energy is all yang. I will give you an example of another spiritual thing:

You must be registered for see images

In the second to last panel the things coming out there mouth is spiritual. You can tell when something is spiritual.

You must be registered for see images

Shikamaru even says it here in the second to last panel they are mental energy and require stability and are starving for physical energy.
------------------------------------------------------

It is sooo obvious when something is spiritual and when something is physical choji going big is physical not spiritual.

Susanoo is chakra materialised. Chakra is Physical energy + Spiritual energy. Susanoo is both spritual and physical... how else do you think it can block objects?
Like I said, there is a difference between Yin and Yin Release.
Yang deals with vitality which is giving life to objects or healing.
Yin deals with creating form (becoming big/small) and imagination (genjutsu) etc. Shikamaru's multi shadow possession is a Yin technique aswell. Is that physical or spiritual? No.
Like I said, Healing and giving life to objects inst physical yet it is a yang ability. That already puts a hole in what you are saying.

 

[The Hidden Shinobi]

Susanoo is chakra materialised. Chakra is Physical energy + Spiritual energy. Susanoo is both spritual and physical... how else do you think it can block objects?
Like I said, there is a difference between Yin and Yin Release.
Yang deals with vitality which is giving life to objects or healing.
Yin deals with creating form (becoming big/small) and imagination (genjutsu) etc. Shikamaru's multi shadow possession is a Yin technique aswell. Is that physical or spiritual? No.
Like I said, Healing and giving life to objects inst physical yet it is a yang ability. That already puts a hole in what you are saying.

Like I said there is a bit of yang in yin and a bit of yin in yang, yes I know Shikamaru's multi shadow possession is a Yin technique aswell that is obvious. But what I am saying is choji becoming big is not creating form or imagination. It is simply expanding (growing) and is a physical process, so I say it belongs in the yang category. Healing is giving life but we was told vitality and physical energy is part of yang so we know this is yin as well.

Susano is yin with a little bit of yang, it involves imagination and spiritual energy more than vitality and physical energy so I say it belongs in the yin category. Yes it materialises but not completely you can see the spiritual aura around it. But anyway yh altogether it is yin.

Looks like the only thing we don't agree on is choji but I think it is more of a physical process than a process spiritual