Chapter 619 confirms Minato doesn't have knowledge from chakra he put in Naruto?

[AaaaNinja]

Last week people were trying to predict whether or not Edo Tensei Minato would have the same knowledge as the piece of chakra had that he put in Naruto.

When he told Kushina that he would put their chakra in him so that they would get to meet Naruto grown up, maybe that was just for the purpose of telling him important things that he would need to know later. I mean, things like Identity is a real issue in the world for kids who grow up adopted or orphaned. For Naruto, putting their chakra in him to meet with him later would have helped him a whole lot. Minato was smart to do that.

But anyways, there was a page where Minato introduces himself to Hashirama, and Hashirama wanted to know about the village. Minato said that he didn't know because he was sealed before the Third. Also, Orochimaru, not Minato, told Hashirama who the Fifth is. This last one alone isn't proof, it could just mean that Orochimaru answered quicker. But the part where Minato said that he doesn't know about the village because he was sealed before the third tells me that he probably doesn't know anything after that.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Is that proof or is the possibility still open that he might have some memories from his chakra-self?

 

[Snape Uchiha]

You're right. I don't think he remembers talking to Naruto.

 

[CurseSealofEarth]

Well the last time we saw him Konoha was a crater, so I'm going to say no.

 

[Sarutobi Sasuke]

Well the last time we saw him Konoha was a crater, so I'm going to say no.

This^

 

[GwemBaba]

Wrong.

Nice try, but you forget that last time Minato saw Konoha, Pain just demolished the place.

How could he know?

 

[ridvan1923]

I was thinking the same thing. He would not remember he talked to Naruto with his chakra body. Probably he will not remember anything.

 

[WhistleBlower]

But explain this then.

Why did Minato when talking to Naruto back when in the Pein arc, say he knows about Jiraiya's death?

Regardless, i believe he has knowledge from his chakra self because otherwise it would be a drag if he didn't and to be honest sad to Naruto haha.

 

[Hori]

But explain this then.

Why did Minato when talking to Naruto back when in the Pein arc, say he knows about Jiraiya's death?

Its my guess actually I think that was only the memory of the chakra he putted on Naruto which one can say it was a clone which dissapeared and had no original to come back to.

 

[Baka Sennin]

when minato's chakra disappeared from naruto, pain had just levelled the village and killed of most of it's shinobi you know. that said, it's not impossible that et minato doesn't possess that knowledge i suppose, although it's proven that minato's chakra could see everything that naruto could.

 

[ReeseKage]

Maybe he does…maybe he doesn't

 

[TimBone]

Doesn't confirm anything. Only until we witness him actively state the fact or he has an encounter with Naruto will we know the answer.

Having no knowledge on the matter seems a bit counter intuitive to the narrative imo.

So he probably does know.

 

[MaYne1]

I got to take it to consideration that the village is just rebuilding the hokage barely woke from a coma and now the leaf is in the middle of a war so that comment could go to ways since the village isnt destroyed yet its been better. So i feel its still not enough proof to support either end of the argument i think one more chapter of dead hokages milking air time will help us know for sure. Now im not saying anyones wrong or hating anyones opinion( except Dr. Proof i hate that guy) im just stating there really isnt enough evidence.

 

[NarutoKage2]

What this chapter showed is not conclusive. Well have to wait and see to find out.

 

[Sunstorm]

He meant that he doesn't think the village is "alright" since he died before the third. This was a respond to Hashirama's surprise of there being a fourth hokage already. Hope you get it.