Chakra Scalpel or Gentle Fist?

Reraru · May 31, 2017

Sagebee said:
Femme is back!ekoms2:ekoms2:ekoms2:

No. The account was hacked. It isn't her.

Sagebee · May 31, 2017

KidGamer65 said:
A mastered chakra scalpel is clearly better. Kabuto bisected Itachi with that and Chakra Scalpel can cut and damage muscles and tendons with just a touch. Gentle Fist does that part better, but the fact chakra scalpel has a little bit of that + it being a blade makes it better overall.

Though that's just Gentle Fist itself, not the entire fighting style and techs that branch off from it.

You must be registered for see links

You must be registered for see links

"An ordinary person would not be able to move at all"

You must be registered for see links

It'd be a little hard to kill with a touch since you'd need to go for the neck, but like I said, in Part 2 Kabuto can use it as a blade.

Whats the use of a chakra scalpel with deactivated chakra?

Sagebee · May 31, 2017

Naruko uzumaki said:
No. The account was hacked. It isn't her.

Ahhh

Amenotejikara · May 31, 2017

CS is better.

Shruikan · May 31, 2017

Naruko uzumaki said:
No. The account was hacked. It isn't her.

How do you know?

KidGamer65 · May 31, 2017

Sagebee said:
Whats the use of a chakra scalpel with deactivated chakra?

Irrelevant to the discussion.

Sagebee · May 31, 2017

KidGamer65 said:
Irrelevant to the discussion.

What do you mean the gentle fist would just deactivate the Chakra points

KidGamer65 · May 31, 2017

Sagebee said:
What do you mean the gentle fist would just deactivate the Chakra points

That doesn't make Gentle Fist better than Chakra Scalpel. If Sasuke got hit by Gentle Fist he'd be unable to use PS. Does that mean Gentle Fist>PS? No, though I won't be surprised if I see that claim from someone soon.

Sagebee · May 31, 2017

KidGamer65 said:
That doesn't make Gentle Fist better than Chakra Scalpel. If Sasuke got hit by Gentle Fist he'd be unable to use PS. Does that mean Gentle Fist>PS? No, though I won't be surprised if I see that claim from someone soon.

If gentle fist makes your fighting style useless than yes it is

DrProof · May 31, 2017

KidGamer65 said:
That doesn't make Gentle Fist better than Chakra Scalpel. If Sasuke got hit by Gentle Fist he'd be unable to use PS. Does that mean Gentle Fist>PS? No, though I won't be surprised if I see that claim from someone soon.

Rofl.

The Necromancer · May 31, 2017

Sagebee said:
If gentle fist makes your fighting style useless than yes it is

This isn't a vs. thread.

Sagebee · May 31, 2017

The Necromancer said:
This isn't a vs. thread.

Isn't this thread asking which is better Chakra scalpel or gentle fist?

Than I'm making a valid point, also Chakra scalpel can only be used close range, while the gentle fist can be used mid to close range.

KidGamer65 · May 31, 2017

Sagebee said:
If gentle fist makes your fighting style useless than yes it is

Just when I think I've seen it all.

Gentle Fist can potentially make the fighting styles of the strongest Ninja useless, yet Gentle Fist users are nowhere near the top when it comes to rankings. Your trash ass logic is equivalent to me saying that since a Kunai has the potential to kill Madara or Hashirama, a Kunai>Their arsenal. Or "Neji>Hashirama because Gentle Fist can block his chakra" even though Hashirama would never a day in his life be caught by Gentle Fist. Same goes for Madara.

Now, let's actually use logic. Sure, if they can land their hits they can make a chakra scalpel useless, but you've given us nothing to make us believe that this will happen.

Then we have the fact that this isn't a vs. thread. You compare which tech is better by seeing how they affect different things, not just each other. :lol

Sagebee · May 31, 2017

KidGamer65 said:
Just when I think I've seen it all.

Gentle Fist can potentially make the fighting styles of the strongest Ninja useless, yet Gentle Fist users are nowhere near the top when it comes to rankings. Your trash ass logic is equivalent to me saying that since a Kunai has the potential to kill Madara or Hashirama, a Kunai>Their arsenal. Or "Neji>Hashirama because Gentle Fist can block his chakra" even though Hashirama would never a day in his life be caught by Gentle Fist. Same goes for Madara.

Now, let's actually use logic. Sure, if they can land their hits they can make a chakra scalpel useless, but you've given us nothing to make us believe that this will happen.

Then we have the fact that this isn't a vs. thread. You compare which tech is better by seeing how they affect different things, not just each other. :lol

Well the gentle fist relys on the byakugan giving it the vision necessary to dodge and hit the target

Also Chakra scalpel is only used in close range while the gentle fist can be used anywhere from mid to close range attacks

So a Chakra scalpel would only be useful in close range attacks and only real exceptional ninja would land hits

While the gentle fist doesn't have these limitations:lol

KidGamer65 · May 31, 2017

Sagebee said:
Well the gentle fist relys on the byakugan giving it the vision necessary to dodge and hit the target

Also Chakra scalpel is only used in close range while the gentle fist can be used anywhere from mid to close range attacks

So a Chakra scalpel would only be useful in close range attacks and only real exceptional ninja would land hits

While the gentle fist doesn't have these limitations:lol

No, Gentle Fist on it's own is hand to hand combat. The only way it can be extended to mid range is if they are in a scenario like Neji vs. Kidomaru. So that isn't any noticeable advantage. Whether or not chakra scalpel or Gentle Fist would land has to do with the shinobi who is utilizing these jutsu and that is irrelevant to this discussion.

Detonator99 · May 31, 2017

Obviously gentle fist lol, chakra scapel just means you will be turning your fingers in to a tiny knife, meanwhile gentle fist has hole diferent ways of use.

Sagebee · May 31, 2017

KidGamer65 said:
No, Gentle Fist on it's own is hand to hand combat. The only way it can be extended to mid range is if they are in a scenario like Neji vs. Kidomaru. So that isn't any noticeable advantage. Whether or not chakra scalpel or Gentle Fist would land has to do with the shinobi who is utilizing these jutsu and that is irrelevant to this discussion.

I'm pretty sure the byakugan would give automatic advantage in landing hit, and isn't the gentle fist a category of hyuga techniques?

KidGamer65 · May 31, 2017

Sagebee said:
I'm pretty sure the byakugan would give automatic advantage in landing hit, and isn't the gentle fist a category of hyuga techniques?

Doesn't matter because at the end of the day it depends on who is using it. That doesn't have anything to do with what jutsu is better either. Yes, Gentle Fist is a Hyuga technique. So?

Sagebee · May 31, 2017

KidGamer65 said:
Doesn't matter because at the end of the day it depends on who is using it. That doesn't have anything to do with what jutsu is better either. Yes, Gentle Fist is a Hyuga technique. So?

So things like air palm and rotation are mid range techs

KidGamer65 · May 31, 2017

Sagebee said:
So things like air palm and rotation are mid range techs

That's not Gentle Fist. :lol

Chakra Scalpel or Gentle Fist?

Active member

Awards

Active member

Awards

Active member

Awards

Active member

Active member

Active member

Awards

Active member

Awards

Active member

Awards

Active member

Awards

Active member

Awards

Active member

Active member

Awards

Active member

Awards

Active member

Awards

Active member

Awards

Active member

Active member

Awards

Active member

Awards

Active member

Awards

Active member

Awards