Chakra Rods alone did not stop Amaterasu.

[Exaar]

no proof?

Then who used preta path to absorb amatersu arrow?

Why did kishi show amatersu arrow being absorbed then showed a screen shot of madara looking satsifyed?

Who said preta path was used at all?

I didn't see it get absorbed, All i saw was the arrow and the rods clashing and that was that.

He certainly didn't shoot the chakra rods out with Bansho Tenin to use Preta-Path through them. It's just that the Rinnegan's powerful chakra runs through the rods and thus, the flames chakra was destabilized when coming near to them.

^This is a far better explanation.

 

[abiolaa1]

Banshō Ten'in attracts objects, it does not repel it or send it.

Pain has the ability to also repel any kind of attack, when kashi and the leaf ninjas attacked him, he repelled every attack, also when naruto send raseshuriken, he repelled it, so what are talking about!

 

[Uchicha Macho]

My silly NBers did you not really see what happened here or are you guys simply ready to bash Sasuke any chance you get.

Madara sent the chakra rods using bansho tenin. He then used preta path to absorb the technique.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Chakra rods alone cannot stop Amaterasu. We know that chakra rods are used as receivers, so Madara simply did what Nagato does with his Paths.

I believe The rod deflected the arrow and the impact causes the amaterasu molded arrow to turn to flame form of amaterasu.This is similar to Naruto using Odama resengan shirken on Sasuke amaterasu arrow

 

[Smd]

That was not absorption, this is absorption:

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

The rods did NOT do this.

in your opionion

Who said preta path was used at all?

I didn't see it get absorbed, All i saw was the arrow and the rods clashing and that was that.



^This is a far better explanation.

dante and from the looks of it the manga.

All we know is that nagato used the same techinque with the paths.

Never seen nagato use a charka rod to absorb any attack.

It really comes down to ones opionion at this point, because it isnt really clear.

But my decision still stands since it sounds more like then rods destabilizing amatersu

 

[Dantee]

That was an impact, it wasnt absorption which is drawn differenty in the manga. Unless you can prove that absorption looks like that in another example then how can you even be sure that its possible?

My theory holds more credibility where amaterasu cant burn raw chakra.

Pictures aren't that reliable. To me it looked like amaterasu disappeared instantly and chakra rods aren't made of chakra so that theory is moot.

Shinra Tensei would have been more logical. Banshō Ten'in's ability is the exact opposite of what you want it to do.

In any case the rods are used as chakra transmitters, they can't use the Paths' abilities.

Chakra transmitters can also exert chakra which gave the Paths their abilities in the 1st place.

The rods only receive chakra, They cannot use the paths.
Preta path covers the user, Not other objects like weapons and so on.

Your just asumming the paths were used in that scan, with no real proof at all.

Well you have no proof. I can say that Nagato transfered his soul into those rods the same way minato and kushina did with naruto, but it's still wrong. There's little to nothing confirming what you believe.

How can you say that? Pein used the rods almost the same way Madara used them here.How else did the rods just suddenly make Amerastsu disappear without asorbing it?

 

[The Necromancer]

Pictures aren't that reliable. To me it looked like amaterasu disappeared instantly and chakra rods aren't made of chakra so that theory is moot.



Chakra transmitters can also exert chakra which gave the Paths their abilities in the 1st place.


Then why didn't Nagato just steal Naruto's soul while he removed Yahiko's rods?

How can you say that? Pein used the rods almost the same way Madara used them here.How else did the rods just suddenly make Amerastsu disappear without asorbing it?

By blocking it the same way anything can be blocked. It's not that hard to comprehend. I don't understand your great need for unnecessary speculation.

 

[Dantee]

By blocking it the same way anything can be blocked. It's not that hard to comprehend. I don't understand your great need for unnecessary speculation.

Your explanation is that the rods just stop Amaterasu without providing proof. My explanation as least as a thesis. Understand now?

 

[The Necromancer]

Your explanation is that the rods just stop Amaterasu without providing proof. My explanation as least as a thesis. Understand now?

Watching rods block amaterasu clearly in a scan, and speculating that madara channeled 2 techniques, (1 of which he's never used or shown any sign of being able to use) are two completely different trains of thought. I'm done. I'll just leave you to your theory.

 

[saw2097]

It was just the rods, absorption looks different.

 

[Dantee]

Watching rods block amaterasu clearly in a scan, and speculating that madara channeled 2 techniques, (1 of which he's never used or shown any sign of being able to use) are two completely different trains of thought. I'm done. I'll just leave you to your theory.

It's funny because no one can give a clear reason as to why that happened lol.
He has said in a previous chapter he knew all the techniques of the Rinnegan.

 

[Exaar]

How can you say that? Pein used the rods almost the same way Madara used them here.How else did the rods just suddenly make Amerastsu disappear without asorbing it?

As strict said, The black rods have powerful chakra running through them, Enough to make your chakra to crazy/out of controll them you come into contact/Pierced by them.
Amaterasu arrows hitting the rods could've quite easily disrupted the chakra inside the arrow thus nullifying it.

If the rods themselves could use the Sages paths then Madara wouldn't of needed to shoot some at the arrow, he could of just wated and use preta path/shinra tensei on the rods already sticking out of obito.

 

[Retsu]

The chakra receivers have NEVER been shown to use the paths, much less independently from a users body, I disagree and think they just clashed with the arrow and caused it to lose momentum

 

[Dantee]

As strict said, The black rods have powerful chakra running through them, Enough to make your chakra to crazy/out of controll them you come into contact/Pierced by them.
Amaterasu arrows hitting the rods could've quite easily disrupted the chakra inside the arrow thus nullifying it.

If the rods themselves could use the Sages paths then Madara wouldn't of needed to shoot some at the arrow, he could of just wated and use preta path/shinra tensei on the rods already sticking out of obito.

Thats not actually a bad theory, but I've never seen a technique pushed back simply because someones chakra nullified it.
The rods had to be sent because he was busy making Obito perform Rinne Tensei.

 

[Draphsin]

Pictures aren't that reliable. To me it looked like amaterasu disappeared instantly and chakra rods aren't made of chakra so that theory is moot.

How is my theory moot? I have proof of amaterasu not burning chakra, do you have proof of the rods using the paths (besides the scan in question)?

 

[Dantee]

How is my theory moot? I have proof of amaterasu not burning chakra, do you have proof of the rods using the paths (besides the scan in question)?

Moot meaning debatable.
The proof you are referring to is it the...... chakra strings that were not even attacked by flames or the focus of the story?

 

[fastrthnwind]

Thats not actually a bad theory, but I've never seen a technique pushed back simply because someones chakra nullified it.
The rods had to be sent because he was busy making Obito perform Rinne Tensei.

You've never heard of rotation before have you? That's exactly what it does.

 

[Draphsin]

You mean chakra strings that were not even attacked by flames or the focus of the story?

Enton covered susanoo, & gaara's sand that didnt burn.

Dont count out those strings either, they didnt burn when they should've.

 

[FlemSmack]

It was just the rods. There is nothing indicating otherwise.

 

[Flawž]

Very unlikley,

The logical explanation is that amaterasu cannot burn through raw chakra.

 

[SIR HERDERP PRESIDERP SDO]

Amaterasu burns only with the heat of plot Lol