Categorizing Ninja Strength rather than Overall?

[Mellanoma]

After reading all the different post about who is stronger than who. I realize its really difficult and only leads to pointless arguments when comparing different ninjas to one another on a general bases. I just made this post to see if it was at all possible to grade ninjas based on categories instead of throwing them into typed out battle situations which end in constant flames. Here are some of the categories i propose:

Power: How Strong there jutsu was considering massive destruction or general damage.
Strength: Physical Strength
Stamina/Charkra: How long they could last in battle and there chakra levels
Intelligence: Analytical Skills, how smart they were, and there ability to counter or learn.
Types of jutsu they use: Self-Explanatory

I figure the more categories created the more accurate we could get with making a ranking chart. Also this is not ranking based on who would win but rather who is overall a better ninja. Certain ninja are better than others but that doesn't mean they would always win.

Im going to compare 1st hokage and 4th Hokage

Power: (+1 1st Hokage) On a destruction level no other jutsu can shift a battlefield and cause mass destruction like wood element while still making it look pretty

Strength: (+1 1st Hokage) His physical strength was in-human considering he wielded massive weapons.

Stamina/Chakra: (+1 1st Hokage) He was senju enough said

Intelligence: (+1 4th Hokage) The kid was a genius in every since of the word and as far as developing counter attacks he was the perfect person.

Types of Jutsu they use: (+1 4th Hokage) in just about every situation FTG triumphs over 1st hokage jutsu EXCEPT for solving a tailed beast issue

So based on these categories i would haft to say:

1st hokage : 3 points
4th hokage : 2 points

Overall better ninja would be 1st hokage. ONCE AGAIN THIS IS NOT BATTLE SIMULATION only overall calculations.

 

[A Random Chunnin]

This is a good idea, maybe when i figure out how to post new threads, i'll use this system, provided i have your consent to use it

 

[NarutoKage2]

Despite the FACT that i'll get flamed for saying this, in my opinion the 4th> the 1st Hokage.

Not because of the 1st 3 points, but honestly his will of fire, which is basically the whole point of Naruto said again and again as being the real determinant of true strength, not the number or variety of jutsu, is unbeatable by all save for his son.

EDIT: but yeah with the kind of threads here ppl don't look at this stuff and only see OMFG he made a forest etc and ignore the whole message and meaning of this story.

 

[Exaar]

You Forgot about Speed.

 

[Urda]

Somewhat of a good idea, but that is why they have "Naruto Data Book." Though that want help, people would still believe or have an opinion about a certain characters status in "Vs. Threads."

 

[Kakashii]

Despite the FACT that i'll get flamed for saying this, in my opinion the 4th> the 1st Hokage.

Not because of the 1st 3 points, but honestly his will of fire, which is basically the whole point of Naruto said again and again as being the real determinant of true strength, not the number or variety of jutsu, is unbeatable by all save for his son.

EDIT: but yeah with the kind of threads here ppl don't look at this stuff and only see OMFG he made a forest etc and ignore the whole message and meaning of this story.

LOLOLOL hashirama is the creator of that ideology you moron!
so if we use logic on this hashirama's will of fire is stronger than anyone else.
edit: idk if you actually know how to use the signals "<" and ">" :|

 

[blazekev90]

based of your list Orochimaru have a 3 IMO

 

[Kakashii]

based of your list Orochimaru have a 3 IMO

who the fck was talking about that gay lord?!

 

[Ginn Uchiha]

I like this idea. I think you should maybe include speed though.. And durability maybe unless you just consider it part of their physical strength

 

[Kakashii]

I like this idea. I think you should maybe include speed though.. And durability maybe unless you just consider it part of their physical strength

well we can say that stamina is the same as durability dont you think >.>

 

[NarutoKage2]

LOLOLOL hashirama is the creator of that ideology you moron!
so if we use logic on this hashirama's will of fire is stronger than anyone else.
edit: idk if you actually know how to use the signals "<" and ">" :|

*facepalm*

thanks for proving my point, ******!
and its also said the younger generation surpasses the older, hahah so so much for your BS logic.

And no u dumb fck he is'nt the creator there were a million senjus before him just not in konoha.

Retarded fanboys like u dodge all sense of perception and reality when it comes to Hashirama.

 

[blazekev90]

who the fck was talking about that gay lord?!

i am obviously, i mentioned him right? ok den.

 

[Ryuu..]

Despite the FACT that i'll get flamed for saying this, in my opinion the 4th> the 1st Hokage.

Not because of the 1st 3 points, but honestly his will of fire, which is basically the whole point of Naruto said again and again as being the real determinant of true strength, not the number or variety of jutsu, is unbeatable by all save for his son.

EDIT: but yeah with the kind of threads here ppl don't look at this stuff and only see OMFG he made a forest etc and ignore the whole message and meaning of this story.

This is what I call 'tactical' trolling.

 

[blackbird31468]

I like this idea. I think you should maybe include speed though.. And durability maybe unless you just consider it part of their physical strength

yes, i think you should also include speed in this.

 

[NarutoKage2]

This is what I call 'tactical' trolling.

I'd use expletives if i were trolling.

See, the trouble is the average IQ of most people here does'nt allow them to think anything outside of what is immediately in front of them, i.e these days Hashirama/Madara being shown as boss. Were the tables to turn and kishi pull a fast one, you'd all look pretty retarded over your your current stance.

 

[Kakashii]

*facepalm*

thanks for proving my point, ******!
and its also said the younger generation surpasses the older, hahah so so much for your BS logic.

And no u dumb fck he is'nt the creator there were a million senjus before him just not in konoha.

Retarded fanboys like u dodge all sense of perception and reality when it comes to Hashirama.

...hashirama was senju clan's leader.
...im not a fanboy cuz if you actually look at my name and my avatar you can see who's my favorite character.
...finally shall i say...learn how to use the signals "<" and ">" as i said in the edit of the quote. you lost your reason by calling me unnecessary things so that means you are either a kid or just mentally retarded.
edit: yes you can say that im hypocrite because i did call you a moron.

 

[Ginn Uchiha]

well we can say that stamina is the same as durability dont you think >.>

I think that would work as well guy-bert

 

[Ryuu..]

I'd use expletives if i were trolling.

See, the trouble is the average IQ of most people here does'nt allow them to think anything outside of what is immediately in front of them, i.e these days Hashirama/Madara being shown as boss. Were the tables to turn and kishi pull a fast one, you'd all look pretty retarded over your your current stance.

And people also look stupid when they write lines and lines of BS when the real answer was pretty obvious.

Occam's razor.

 

[NarutoKage2]

...hashirama was senju clan's leader.
...im not a fanboy cuz if you actually look at my name and my avatar you can see who's my favorite character.
...finally shall i say...learn how to use the signals "<" and ">" as i said in the edit of the quote. you lost your reason by calling me unnecessary things so that means you are either a kid or just mentally retarded.
edit: yes you can say that im hypocrite because i did call you a moron.

well i never said he was an uchiha clan leader did I?

Now your just crying because i flamed your ass.

You can dish it out but you can't take it ,eh?

 

[NarutoKage2]

And people also look stupid when they write lines and lines of BS when the real answer was pretty obvious.

Occam's razor.

I agree. Minato would win. It is obvious.