I agree!.. They do have different insight but the Byaku has the better insight by a tad bit IMO.. Copying is a form of insight/mimicking my man, Sasuke did the same as Neji (Copy,Mimick) but they used 2 different means of copyi/mimick insight to get their results..
Neji's x-ray vision is a mimick insight because he got the same answers as the person he mimicked copied while as you said in Sasuke's sharingan case he wouldn't get the same exact numbers or words with just his copying insight so it's not an exact mimick like Neji which further proves that the Byaku had the better insight..
It's only by a tad bit that the Byaku has an advantage but that doesn't mean it will win all the time.. It's the wielder that is in debate not the eye itself..
not by the comparing the precog stuff since it has never been done (as in no manga panel gives a in depth discussion on what byakugan's precog stuff is) before so that is conjecture
you didn't mention insight but even you know the answer to that one via Kishi's gathered info
trying to bridge gaps doesn't mean we need to make up things to satisfy a uptight fanbase, especially if we easily slaughter them in their own deluded mindsets
byakugan has precog HyuugaHeir
what that precog is, is unknown
having it face against a sharingan precog has never happened
"In its penetrating percpetive ability..The Byakugan surpasses the Sharingan competely"! meaning watever penetrative feat dispalyed by the Sharingan is inferior by default in canon.
You must be registered for see images
The question is , does the Byakugan provide sharper perception than the Sharingan? which is the ability to see things quickly and understand its meaning which is something Itachi regarded about Kakashi.
You must be registered for see images
Neji actiavted Byakugan in order to perceive Lee w/5 Gates opened similar to Kakshi.
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
Kakashi who was praised for his visual perception by Itachi was himself visibly shocked at Neji's and emphasized how accurately Neji's eyes can percieve tiny fast moving targets , which is something unexpected even with both eyes having the ability to see them regardless.
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
Which eye has the Sharper perception , its a highly fun subject and i hope it gets mentioned in canon in the future. But i do think the Sharingan logically has sharper perception due to its ability to copy and attempt to count things like a vortex created by countless microscopic wind blades in the form of Rasenshuriken.
By comparison the Byakugan does have feats in this area just not as impresive , like kid Neji intanstly catching and percieving countless blades coming at him at once then somehow make space between the blades for evasion.
You must be registered for see images
Since Byakugan can be trained i see no reason why the eye as a whole could have sharper percpetion when used two equally experienced wielders , but onto the topic of Byakugan having precog.
You must be registered for see images
Tenten on the right already fully explains to the reader the Byakugan's ability to give its user a circular perceptive view around himself , but she then goes on to say "and with that same Byakugan , he can anticipate all attacks". This means that its an added ability different from 360 degree vision which was addressed TWICE on the same page before mention was made of the eyes ability to anticpate.
So i guess it does have some form of precog , but clearly no comparsions can be made since we have no idea how it works nor should it give Chakra-sight images like the Sharingan. The Byakugan was never shown to have the mental connection the sharingan gives to its user which is a minds-eye type of percpetion unlike the Byakugan.
It's only by a tad bit that the Byaku has an advantage but that doesn't mean it will win all the time.. It's the wielder that is in debate not the eye itself..
Hell idk if the OP is a Uchiha fan or not. But Hyuga fans are getting mad for what reason tho? Like we already know Sharingan > Byakugan or Sharingan precog > Byakugan. And they also know that Byakugan ability to see chakra network > Sharingan's.
It is by just a bit depending on the skill of the user.. It's not just 1 sided all the time but the x-ray is a hella advantage..
You must be registered for see images
The Byaku doesn't see like this per-say but it does have the slow motion effect without the mirror images of the sharingan..
It's a form of precog as long as x-ray vision is active, being able to see muscle change an trajectory is precog..
Well you know how when Sasuke activated his 3rd tomoe he seen Naruto in an almost slow-mo type of view!?..
The Byaku's X-ray vision is somewhat of the same but without the mirror effect because as you know x-ray give you the ability to pears through ones body/objects, being able to see muscle movement & change in any sudden movement as far as trajectory so it's a precog type of deal..
(It's as though it's a slow-mo effect but it really isn't a slow-mo it's along the line of advance sensing an awareness)
Insight!..