I think he meant "Is it against the rules?" if that's not what he meant, well i'm also curious if it's against the rules.
@OP if it's not against the rules, i'd enjoy you doing such a thread and i'd take part
It is against the rules, if you read them you would know.
Rules:
Follow the Global Rules, so no spamming/flaming etc.
Only post VS threads about Naruto characters/attacks/clans etc., do not post threads like Grimmjow vs Goku. This is after all a Naruto section.
Do not post VS threads between Naruto characters and non-Naruto characters like Naruto vs Ichigo. You can't compare them with each other like that, they're from two different manga's and it nearly always results in spam and flame threads.
The threads still need to maintain a certain lvl of seriousness, seriously no Tenten vs Tonton threads anymore -.-
Use the search button to find whether the fight you want to discuss already exists or not. In the case it does exist check when the last post was made as a thread that hasn't been active for a month is considered dead and it's against the rules to revive old threads. In that case you can make the thread again.