Boruto Manga is Canon

[Akiretsu]

Yeah. "boruto new manga' has the same status as canon as CDZ Omega or DBGT.
This shit isn't written or drawn by Kishi.

Kishi said he is "supervised" but in reality he will not give any shit to this.

The only thing Canon here is the 700 chapters serialization done by Kishi and the 10 chapter from the Gaiden and Boruto the Movie who was the only movie heavily supervisioned by Kishi.

All the Novels after chapter 699, The Last and now this new series aren't canon.

This is just more money to Kishi and Jump milking while Naruto is profitable.

If Kishi resolves to continue Naruto one day he will ignore all these shits.

Like He ignored all these novels and the Last events in the Gaiden and in Boruto the Movie.

Major Canon:
-700 chapters
-Gaiden
-Boruto Movie (He didn't just supervise, he wrote the story and everything)
-Naruto Hokage Ignog.
-The first couple pages of Road to Boruto
-The Last (Yes, this is, Kishi was the script supervisor, did script rewrites, character designs and gave them the story and acknowledges it as Canon + The pictures in Boruto's room is a direct reference to it)
-The Mitsuki One Shot in spring

Secondary Canon:
-Road to Ninja Feats and such

As far as the new series goes, It being canon is subjective. Many people believe it to be so, some don't. Everyone has their reasons, it's whatever, no point in arguing with people who made up their minds.

 

[Endles Waltz]

Highly doubt they did. Plus it's against the law. In everything Kishi has been stated to be a supervisor on or anything along those lines, he's in much more involved then you are implying.

Sure, but my point about 'canon' and what I and many others consider it to be still stands. This series does not stand on the same ground as the NARUTO manga serialization by Masashi Kishimoto. Not in the slightest.

 

[lndra]

We as fan's of Kishimoto's Naruto, will be able to tell the differences immediately from Kishimoto playing a part in the story, and not.

Either way, we can't decide if it's canon or not unless Kishimoto states that it isn't. But, since Kishimoto isn't directly working with this. It makes this all very troubling because they may very well shit on are characters and change everything.

I'm honestly not happy :lol

 

[Akiretsu]

Sure, but my point about 'canon' and what I and many others consider it to be still stands. This series does not stand on the same ground as the NARUTO manga serialization by Masashi Kishimoto. Not in the slightest.

Well of course. But If Kishi acknowledges it as part of his story then...well, it doesn't matter what people think then. Canon will be:

Chapter 1-699 > The Last > Naruto's Inaguration > Chapter 700 > Gaiden > Boruto Movie > Mitsuki One Shot > Boruto Manga

Now, where you rank everything in terms of canon is up to you. You do you, but at the end of the day, It will still be canon as long as Kishi acknowledges it as such and Being the script supervisor, giving tips and personally drawing a one shot that will connect them together does just that.

 

[Natsu Shazneel]

Well of course. But If Kishi acknowledges it as part of his story then...well, it doesn't matter what people think then. Canon will be:

Chapter 1-699 > The Last > Naruto's Inaguration > Chapter 700 > Gaiden > Boruto Movie > Mitsuki One Shot > Boruto Manga

Now, where you rank everything in terms of canon is up to you. You do you, but at the end of the day, It will still be canon as long as Kishi acknowledges it as such and Being the script supervisor, giving tips and personally drawing a one shot that will connect them together does just that.

So far only you acknowledge it as canon.

 

[Akiretsu]

We as fan's of Kishimoto's Naruto, will be able to tell the differences immediately from Kishimoto playing a part in the story, and not.

Either way, we can't decide if it's canon or not unless Kishimoto states that it isn't. But, since Kishimoto isn't directly working with this. It makes this all very troubling because they may very well shit on are characters and change everything.

I'm honestly not happy :lol

I feels you brah.

 

[Endles Waltz]

Well of course. But If Kishi acknowledges it as part of his story then...well, it doesn't matter what people think then. Canon will be:

Chapter 1-699 > The Last > Naruto's Inaguration > Chapter 700 > Gaiden > Boruto Movie > Mitsuki One Shot > Boruto Manga

Now, where you rank everything in terms of canon is up to you. You do you, but at the end of the day, It will still be canon as long as Kishi acknowledges it as such and Being the script supervisor, giving tips and personally drawing a one shot that will connect them together does just that.

Not at all, it will be canon to you, and like I said many times 'canon' is a fan made concept, so Kishi cannot consider it as canon. For some people including myself, if it's not Kishi's serialization, it's not really canon. But yea this is a subjective topic.

 

[Akiretsu]

So far only you acknowledge it as canon.

No, but because I'm actually author myself and have gone through the same things Kishi is going through with his work, I have a better understanding of where Kishi's mind set is as opposed to someone like yourself.

You don't become a supervisor and read a script about your work done by another author and don't give a **** about how they portray your characters or verse. Only an Idiot would think that, seriously. You don't even have to be an author to know that. If you create a story for x amount of years and then I come along and am about to continue where you left of OFFICIALLY and you supervise me, you're not gonna let me just do whatever after reading my script and seeing things you don't like or want to be portrayed. You're just not. What i write has to be up to par with your standards as you'd be my supervisor.

So if you want to think it's not canon, then by all means go ahead.

 

[Akiretsu]

Not at all, it will be canon to you, and like I said many times 'canon' is a fan made concept, so Kishi cannot consider it as canon. For some people including myself, if it's not Kishi's serialization, it's not really canon. But yea this is a subjective topic.

Well, i consider canon what the author acknowledges as part of their story. If you don't, that's your business.

 

[Natsu Shazneel]

No, but because I'm actually author myself and have gone through the same things Kishi is going through with his work, I have a better understanding of where Kishi's mind set is as opposed to someone like yourself.

You don't become a supervisor and read a script about your work done by another author and don't give a **** about how they portray your characters or verse. Only an Idiot would think that, seriously. You don't even have to be an author to know that. If you create a story for x amount of years and then I come along and am about to continue where you left of OFFICIALLY and you supervise me, you're not gonna let me just do whatever after reading my script and seeing things you don't like or want to be portrayed. You're just not. What i write has to be up to par with your standards as you'd be my supervisor.

So if you want to think it's not canon, then by all means go ahead.

If you are an author than where is your manga?

Kishi himself has not really given a shit about his manga for some time now. It has been proven by his interviews where he has freely dissed his own creation. Right now you will be witnessing a joke of his manga. The artist he has chosen is an average artist. His story will be no different than what we have seen already. Kishi himself stated the reasons why he never thought of continuing Boruto's story. Yet we see another artist attempting to continue where he left off.

So in other words it does not matter if Kishi supervises it or not. His standards have already fallen since the ending of the manga. He no longer shows the same passion he had for the series some time ago.

Oh I will. To me the original series ended two years ago. Whats going on now is pure milking.

 

[Dark Sonic]

I see your point. Fuller house had me like just stop

You must be registered for see images

Man where do you get that pic from? I always wonder where people get these funny basketball player heads or any other guy olol

 

[lndra]

To be fair.

If my favorite characters end up with shit development, or just do a complete 180 from Kishimoto's original interpretation (based on my understanding). I would definitely be angry, especially at the fact that this series would be treated as 'canon'. I really wish it wuold be some filler shit. Like testing the waters.

We don't need no Gaiden chapter 1 rerun. Feel me?

 

[Nick01]

You must be registered for see images

I dont really care anymore. Rip in peace Boruto's face.

Lmao.

 

[Tantalus Thief]

Man where do you get that pic from? I always wonder where people get these funny basketball player heads or any other guy olol

it's from a forum called box.den(remove the . I put it in there, because this will happen if I put a x and together this happens xd).

 

[shelke]

If the author approves it, then it would be canon.

 

[Magnolius]

It hasn't even been officially released yet, let alone canon :sdo:

 

[chopstickchakra]

Then dragon ball gt is also canon

I don't know much about GT but did Toriyama or WSJ(or whoever owns the rights to the manga) authorize it? If so then yes by definition it is. I know fans like to say it isn't because it did some crazy stuff and with Super now being made (I believe with Toriyama himself involved) we have a new canon from the author which gets more weight than outside continuations(like how the old Star Wars expanded universe from the books after the movies was considered canon no longer is canon because the studio that owns the rights have put forth their own "official" canon with the new movie)

I'm also not clear on the aspect of a different medium. See Boruto is being continued as a manga like the original work whereas GT was an anime continuation. It's easiest to think of it like American comics now, Batman was created by Bob Keane and all the comics since then are canon (unless noted otherwise by oneshots or what if's) but any original concept cartoons or films are not canon because they didn't originate from the same medium as the original.

 

[Magnolius]

I don't know much about GT but did Toriyama or WSJ(or whoever owns the rights to the manga) authorize it? If so then yes by definition it is. I know fans like to say it isn't because it did some crazy stuff and with Super now being made (I believe with Toriyama himself involved) we have a new canon from the author which gets more weight than outside continuations(like how the old Star Wars expanded universe from the books after the movies was considered canon no longer is canon because the studio that owns the rights have put forth their own "official" canon with the new movie)

I'm also not clear on the aspect of a different medium. See Boruto is being continued as a manga like the original work whereas GT was an anime continuation. It's easiest to think of it like American comics now, Batman was created by Bob Keane and all the comics since then are canon (unless noted otherwise by oneshots or what if's) but any original concept cartoons or films are not canon because they didn't originate from the same medium as the original.

:sdo:

 

[Aznkidd]

Sure, but my point about 'canon' and what I and many others consider it to be still stands. This series does not stand on the same ground as the NARUTO manga serialization by Masashi Kishimoto. Not in the slightest.

he is just being lazy cause he is rich now, so hire somebody else to do his job while still have his finger lay on it....

just imagine microsoft or apple, they are not Bill Gate's nor Steve Jobs' entirely. This is same to Naruto, Kishi plays a major part in it.

 

[Jellal Fernandes]

If you are an author than where is your manga?

Kishi himself has not really given a shit about his manga for some time now. It has been proven by his interviews where he has freely dissed his own creation. Right now you will be witnessing a joke of his manga. The artist he has chosen is an average artist. His story will be no different than what we have seen already. Kishi himself stated the reasons why he never thought of continuing Boruto's story. Yet we see another artist attempting to continue where he left off.

So in other words it does not matter if Kishi supervises it or not. His standards have already fallen since the ending of the manga. He no longer shows the same passion he had for the series some time ago.

Oh I will. To me the original series ended two years ago. Whats going on now is pure milking.

This pretty much. Its sad really...if this new manga had actually tried to do a different ending to naruto. I wouldnt of had any problem with it.