A while back there was a thread about discussing the next big three, so I'm not going to repeat it all again about how that title was specifically for Naruto, Bleach and OP and not some kind of a permanent club that has to consist out of three series. But anyway someone brought this series up in that thread. Back then I hadn't read the series as it was still relatively new with not even 30 chapters, so it was way too soon to say anything about. By now I have read the series and I can say that your comparisons are way off.
DBZ by default shouldn't even be mentioned here as it belongs to a different generation and he role it played in the evolution of the manga industry is so important that it's ludicrous bringing it up here. Bleach likewise doesn't belong here as Bleach has always been an odd series and is simply too different to be comparing it with Black Clover.
The only one of the series you mentioned that can be compared with Black Clover is Naruto. I'm considering writing a review of this series and I would best describe it as Naruto meets Fairy Tail. Black Clover follows the traditional Shonen Jump-recipy that's an almost guaranteed success: a supernatural world where people use a common power source with a not so bright MC of an unknown origin that has zero talent, but somehow possesses and extremely powerful ability. That description can be applied as easily on Naruto as on Aster and therein lies the problem. Series like this are enjoyable because they're easy to read and can always create a fanbase relatively fast, but the fact is that so far there is nothing particularly unique about it. At this rate it would really be nothing more than some kind of a pseudo-Naruto of far lesser quality.
The level of DBZ it nearly certain will never achieve and you better pray it will not become like Bleach. If it however wants to be compared to Naruto in a good way in the future, it still has a very long way to go.
Btw Tsuchi and I have been making discussion threads a few times about the latest chapters:
You must be registered for see links
