[VS] Big Mom vs MF Whitebeard

[Passerby]

Imo Mama wins.
Prometheus and Zues will nuke oyaji alive lmao!

Nothing Whitebeard can do to take out the Sun and Cloud and Big Mom would tank the Gura Gura.

 

[TheLegend0713]

Basically, there's no easy answer. These questions are kinda silly like that, because there's always variables that you can't simplify. We don't know the full extent or limitations to the Gura Gura, so there are people who will come up with hypothetical scenarios; the "what if x allows y". Hell, assuming it's a 1v1, it's up for interpretation on what that means for Big Mom. All her homies were made using her powers, so can she use all of them, or is she limited to using the ones with her own soul in them, or does that even count as 1v1?

Having typed that, I'm down to debate this. Whitebeard's shockwaves can travel through air, allowing him to hit Prometheus and Zeus. I think it's fair to assume the shockwaves would have some effect on them. Whitebeard's probably gonna be able to take advantage of the terrain of the fight, because, you know, he can cause goddamn EARTHQUAKES, but in terms of physical strength, Big Mom would almost certainly win.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

Whitebeard beats Big Meme high diff.

 

[arv993]

BM wins high diff, WB getting a heart attack means there is no way BM is losing, she is more durable than him, can fly meaning shes not affected by the shockwaves as much and she has enough firepower/lethal attacks.

 

[chopstickchakra]

Imo Mama wins.
Prometheus and Zues will nuke oyaji alive lmao!

Nothing Whitebeard can do to take out the Sun and Cloud and Big Mom would tank the Gura Gura.

I don't think Zeus and Prometheus will be as big a factor as you give them credit for when WB's Gura Gura could effect the air around him. What would happen to Zeus or Prometheus if they got hit with a Gura?

 

[Wrappering_]

I'd say a Draw.

 

[HashiraMadara]

lmao Newgate rekt!

Mama mentioned with giants he could defeat other Yonko, and "EVEN EDWARD NEWGATE" meaning Newgate was a Yonko > others.

 

[Punk Hazard]

Basically, there's no easy answer. These questions are kinda silly like that, because there's always variables that you can't simplify. We don't know the full extent or limitations to the Gura Gura, so there are people who will come up with hypothetical scenarios; the "what if x allows y". Hell, assuming it's a 1v1, it's up for interpretation on what that means for Big Mom. All her homies were made using her powers, so can she use all of them, or is she limited to using the ones with her own soul in them, or does that even count as 1v1?

Having typed that, I'm down to debate this. Whitebeard's shockwaves can travel through air, allowing him to hit Prometheus and Zeus. I think it's fair to assume the shockwaves would have some effect on them. Whitebeard's probably gonna be able to take advantage of the terrain of the fight, because, you know, he can cause goddamn EARTHQUAKES, but in terms of physical strength, Big Mom would almost certainly win.

I don't think Zeus and Prometheus will be as big a factor as you give them credit for when WB's Gura Gura could effect the air around him. What would happen to Zeus or Prometheus if they got hit with a Gura?

Why would vibrations in particular have more affect against them than Buso-infused punches?

 

[chopstickchakra]

Why would vibrations in particular have more affect against them than Buso-infused punches?

I don't know that they would I was just thinking back to the air cracking during the gura attacks and was wondering how they might affect Zeus or Prometheus, if they could "crack" or disrupt their form. But that crack could just be a visual cue for the readers and not actually have any influence on anything in story. Prometheus would be more likely to be affected since as Jinbei explained he is fire and wind(shockwaves) could put fire out.

 

[Rikudou Tobi]

Big mam's shown promising strength at the very least on the level of a giant. Buso color haki is strong enough to clash with G4 luffy, while Whitebeard was shown to be good enough to touch an Admiral while yet at the same time get bypassed by one.

So the only thing I can really distinguish between them is their power of their devil fruit. Which one is more promising and destructive than the other.

Newgate wins with some high great difficulty.

 

[arv993]

lmao Newgate rekt!

Mama mentioned with giants he could defeat other Yonko, and "EVEN EDWARD NEWGATE" meaning Newgate was a Yonko > others.

Yes but MF WB is a shell of himself and is prone to heart attacks.

 

[HashiraMadara]

Yes but MF WB is a shell of himself and is prone to heart attacks.

OP never stated MF

 

[chopstickchakra]

OP never stated MF

Did you read the title? The MF doesn't mean Mother ****in

 

[HashiraMadara]

Did you read the title? The MF doesn't mean Mother ****in

kek I read specifically the thread post not the title

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

kek I read specifically the thread post not the title

So you just click on threads without reading the title?

 

[Tomato God]

So you just click on threads without reading the title?

Actually needed that laugh!
But if edward has full control of his haki like he should have we have seen the gura gura shake the whole planet (Caused tsunami's around the world) so you basically would have the tital waves edward caused vs the sun and the sky.

Ocean and land vs the sun and the sky. Sounds bad ass

But big mom is invincible, so was edward when Ace first met him. if It was White beard from then I would say White beard from then would use the force of the air to dissipate Zues and promethus and then it would be a 1v1 battle between Nepolean and bigmom vs Gura gura spears.

But MF white beard is a glass cannon. Probably could **** her shit up but she would eventually eat him.