[Predictions] big mom stronger than whitebeard

[nkiev1]

i think big mom is stronger than whitebeard because

big mom tanked luffy G4 punch like is nothing,

big mom kill the giant when she is 6 years old..

big mom pirate is more stronger than WB pirate,

what about your opinion

 

[Yeah right]

I think they had to be equal since big mom would have had to take him out to gain territory and power. So she is either equal to or weaker to white beard.

Though, since this story works with power scaling, white beard had to be the weakest Yonko.

I should add, remember when white beard got stabbed by his crew mate. That spear thing would of never penetrated big mom.

 

[Love Cook]

I think they're more or less equal, but Whitebeard was on his last legs when he was on Marineford.

 

[Our Lord Sasuke]

Stronger than the old.. yeah maybe

 

[Liquid Snake]

So your saying big mom beats roger as well since wb was about equal to roger? And no WB would stomp BM its easy to say BM wins but if WB was alive during this part of one piece him and his whole crew would be op imagine if wb used haki like how its being displayed now and conquerors haki at that no one could stop him

 

[arv993]

What version of WB? MF WB wouldnt win in all honesty

 

[Bimbonium]

This is actually one of the reasons I've come to dislike MF, it's far too inconsistent. We can try to make up reasons (like they didn't want to destroy the plaza) for MF playing out the way it did, but as we progress down the line and start seeing more of the characters present at MF we'll see that it's like everyone was taking the war easy, both the WB pirates and Marines (especially the Shichibukai).

OT: give 5 yr old BM haki, and she'll probably do better than WB at MF. (except against Akainu).
Realistically tho, I'd say she's about the same level as old WB, maybe a little stronger.

 

[Rikudou Tobi]

They were the same strength, in fact kaidou big mam and whitebeard had around the same strength at that young age too. Look at what weevile has done, young whitebeard was said to have the same strength.

 

[Kingu]

"I think big mom is stronger than whitebeard because...
big mom pirate is stronger than WB pirates"

Logic 101.

 

[NarutoWA]

Being a tank does not necessary have to relate to being powerful. I can see Shanks getting stabbed.. but is he weak? Nope. That might just be devil fruit ability of hers

 

[ArabianLuffy]

I think Big Mom is stronger than Whitebeard, because Big Mom tanked Luffy's G4 punch like it's nothing

So can Whitebeard tank Luffy's G4 attacks too, but the Whitebeard we knew during Marineford is nothing to Whitebeard Prime.

Big Mom killed Jorl when she was 6 years old.

Yeah, she is Admiral rank for 6 years old child like her back those days. Should we compare her to Edward when he was 6 years old? How does that work in comparison? I wish Oda could tell us any thing about Edward when he was 6 years old.

Big Mom Pirates are more stronger than Whitebeard Pirates.

Then Why 2 years ago it was called Whitebeard Era?

 

[Jaylord]

probably wb is stronger than big mom a little but their power are really close they also rival each other because its ompossible that the 4 yonko dont face or fight each other just one time

 

[MadaraReturns]

Not stronger than prime WB, also not stronger than Marineford WB , it'd be a long fight. WB is heavily underestimated, maybe if WB would get some heart attacks she'd win. Tanking G4 would be a feat WB on MF could also do.

 

[Olorin]

what difference a chapter makes -.-

 

[Itachi Minato]

This is actually one of the reasons I've come to dislike MF, it's far too inconsistent. We can try to make up reasons (like they didn't want to destroy the plaza) for MF playing out the way it did, but as we progress down the line and start seeing more of the characters present at MF we'll see that it's like everyone was taking the war easy, both the WB pirates and Marines (especially the Shichibukai).

OT: give 5 yr old BM haki, and she'll probably do better than WB at MF. (except against Akainu).
Realistically tho, I'd say she's about the same level as old WB, maybe a little stronger.

I agree. I don't dislike MF but its going to be quite obvious that nobody went all out in that war.

 

[MadaraReturns]

I agree. I don't dislike MF but its going to be quite obvious that nobody went all out in that war.

Like Bimbodium and you said, it doesn't fit indeed, for example like Kid Doffy's Conquerors Haki with black lightning and stuff, no one else who used Conq. Haki had such an effect. I know they 'changed' the Conq. Haki's look with Doffy but still.

Oda should've planned ahead now Marineford doesn't make sense. Doffy at Dressrosa looked stronger than Kizaru and Aokiji at Marineford. Even though he isn't, even Kid Big Mom was hyped more than many at MF

 

[Love Cook]

Like Bimbodium and you said, it doesn't fit indeed, for example like Kid Doffy's Conquerors Haki with black lightning and stuff, no one else who used Conq. Haki had such an effect. I know they 'changed' the Conq. Haki's look with Doffy but still.

Oda should've planned ahead now Marineford doesn't make sense. Doffy at Dressrosa looked stronger than Kizaru and Aokiji at Marineford. Even though he isn't, even Kid Big Mom was hyped more than many at MF

Nah, it was fine. It was the end of part 1 and Oda hit reset during the timeskip on the haki mechanism and explained it to us.

If we would've seen everybody at full power at marineford it wouldn't have made any sense. Oda was able to cover it up largely by having all the top tiers clash and smacking Luffy around.

the only thing that suffered was Whitebeard's portrayal, but there was no real way around that, but he still went out swinging. If Oda gave him yonkou level haki feats like we've seen now with Big Mom, he also had to give them to the admirals, and Doffy etc.

So there was no real way of future proofing this untill haki was explained to us by Rayleigh during the timeskip.

 

[Itachi Minato]

Nah, it was fine. It was the end of part 1 and Oda hit reset during the timeskip on the haki mechanism and explained it to us.

If we would've seen everybody at full power at marineford it wouldn't have made any sense. Oda was able to cover it up largely by having all the top tiers clash and smacking Luffy around.

the only thing that suffered was Whitebeard's portrayal, but there was no real way around that, but he still went out swinging. If Oda gave him yonkou level haki feats like we've seen now with Big Mom, he also had to give them to the admirals, and Doffy etc.

So there was no real way of future proofing this untill haki was explained to us by Rayleigh during the timeskip.

Don't get me wrong I understand why Oda had to do what he did and it was necessary but comparing characters pre and post time skip will become impossible when we start seeing pre skip characters go all out. I bet you when we see Akainu go all out people will say he took it easy against WB tho that makes no sense.

 

[Love Cook]

Don't get me wrong I understand why Oda had to do what he did and it was necessary but comparing characters pre and post time skip will become impossible when we start seeing pre skip characters go all out. I bet you when we see Akainu go all out people will say he took it easy against WB tho that makes no sense.

Yeah but like I said that works two ways, WB got nerfed too. But I see where you coming from because people will "forget" Whitebeard because he is dead and he will be downplayed.

We should all just draw a line between pre and post skip and don't compare because we went from OMG was that haki ?!!! to oh the butler has haki too.

 

[Cohle]

No one matched Primebeard and Roger. Except like Garp.