Alright, who's really stronger?

[JDuzumaki92]

Obito would just spam space-time migration over and over until Nagato ran out of chakra.

 

[Frankenstein]

First things first, there is a vs. section and you know it

OT now:

Itachi vs. Nagato goes to Nagato if we are talking about them being alive because Itachi will get exhausted and lose. If we are talking about Edo state. Then Itachi may have a chance because he can somehow manage to pierce Nagato with the Totsuka sword.

Nagato vs. Obito
1) The MS case goes to Nagato because he will manage to hold Obito back with his Shinra Tensei and then use Chibaku Tensei for more than Obito's time limit.
2) Obito with Rinnegan wins because the above trick doesn't work and he will sooner or later manage to touch Nagato, thus sucking him in the other dimension and let him rot there

 

[Codawg]

Who beats me??? The Almighty grandpa MADARA????

Bill Nye the Science Guy >_>
@OP: Eh...Obito would probably take Nagato. Itachi though, prolly gonna lose. Stamina ain't on his side in that one.

 

[A$AP Wap]

i will say nagato in both fights...it will be harder for him to win in the first one but i think he can take obito....i think people under rate nagato and grossly over rate obito...yeah he is strong i guess but they are treating him like they did kabuto...which we only just recently seen both of their true powers and whatnot.

Exactly.

 

[A$AP Wap]

First things first, there is a vs. section and you know it

OT now:

Itachi vs. Nagato goes to Nagato if we are talking about them being alive because Itachi will get exhausted and lose. If we are talking about Edo state. Then Itachi may have a chance because he can somehow manage to pierce Nagato with the Totsuka sword.

Nagato vs. Obito
1) The MS case goes to Nagato because he will manage to hold Obito back with his Shinra Tensei and then use Chibaku Tensei for more than Obito's time limit.
2) Obito with Rinnegan wins because the above trick doesn't work and he will sooner or later manage to touch Nagato, thus sucking him in the other dimension and let him rot there

Kakashi and Konan figured his trick out, so why can't Nagato do the same?
If you fight him long enough, you'll finally find out the secrets of his Jutsu and beat him like how Naruto/Kakashi were doing.

 

[duken fist]

nagato duhh. he butt raped naruto and killer b.

 

[A$AP Wap]

Obito would just spam space-time migration over and over until Nagato ran out of chakra.

You can't do it like that.
There's a Time Limit on how you can do it.

 

[Frankenstein]

Kakashi and Konan figured his trick out, so why can't Nagato do the same?
If you fight him long enough, you'll finally find out the secrets of his Jutsu and beat him like how Naruto/Kakashi were doing.

Kakashi didn't figure anything. He simply has the counter-move because his eye is Obito's eye.
Konan did figure the time limit but with the Rinnegan any attack from Nagato can be countered with the same attack by Obito.No need for Kamui if he has the Rinnegan.

 

[Yashiro]

Itachi is the greatest but I think obito is the strongest amongst the 3 I guess

 

[metallica9565]

Tobi > Itachi = Nagato

I think the majority of us can agree with this. Itachi and Nagato are pretty much equal in their own rights, while Tobi probably has a slight advantage over both of them

 

[Twin Steps]

Nagato wins both fights, he's got both senju and uchiha powers in his eyes and he himself is an uzumaki.

Nagato has rennigan, Hitachi and obiti do not, thas more than enough for him to take both of them down.

 

[Edo Odin]

Obito>Nagato>MS Obito

Nagato>Itachi>Six Paths of Pain

That's the way I view it :y (Not sure about Itachi beating the paths though)

 

[A$AP Wap]

Kakashi didn't figure anything. He simply has the counter-move because his eye is Obito's eye.
Konan did figure the time limit but with the Rinnegan any attack from Nagato can be countered with the same attack by Obito.No need for Kamui if he has the Rinnegan.

Nagato is a Rinnegan Master. He's had his whole lifetime to train with it. Obito's just now using it.
How can you say a Rinnegan Noob could beat a Rinnegan Expert?
Obito only wanted Nagato's eyes when he was dead because Obito was inferior to Nagato all along.
Obito's scared. He was also scared of Itachi too.

 

[Stark]

Current Tobi beats Nagato if he has the powers of Pain, Itachi and Nagato comes out to a tie but Nagato is slightly stronger.

 

[V h o]

Imo
1)Obito
2) Nagato
3) Itachi

I like Nagato the best. Taking people souls ftw

 

[Midday]

Nagato > Itachi by quite a bit.

As for Obito. With just ms Nagato takes this, he's able to hit Obito in a similar way to Minato. His reactions are on point and he has linked vision which will allow him to not be caught off gaurd. Obito's main offense is Kaumi on touch so if he tries to get Nagato he has to become tangible where Nagato can catch him with a shinra tensei which has been practically instant.

As for rikudo Obito it's a lot more even. It would become unfair with gedo mazo being on either side, it doesn't make much sense to have two gedo mazo's on the same battle field. Obito hasn't really shown rinnegan abilities, his main strengths are his 6 paths. Nagato has knowledge of paths and rinnengan eyes which can see the chakra from the stakes he could just bansho tennin the stakes out and it's fairly easily for him to shut them down without manhandling them.

Nagato can defeat both but Obito stands a better chance at defeating other top tiers due to Kaumi's nature.

 

[Kages]

Nagato

Then Obito.

 

[Frankenstein]

Nagato is a Rinnegan Master. He's had his whole lifetime to train with it. Obito's just now using it.
How can you say a Rinnegan Noob could beat a Rinnegan Expert?
Obito only wanted Nagato's eyes when he was dead because Obito was inferior to Nagato all along.
Obito's scared. He was also scared of Itachi too.

Well it's not like you need to be a genius to use the techniques properly. If nothing else, I don't remember Nagato making any fantastic Rinnegan move

 

[Midday]

Well it's not like you need to be a genius to use the techniques properly. If nothing else, I don't remember Nagato making any fantastic Rinnegan move

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

 

[Lilt]

I'm getting tired of Itachi Fans overrating him.

The author overrated him by having Black Zetsu call him invincible, and by calling him invincible in the databook.

You know Itachi's feats and you know Nagato's feats. What's the problem?

Tsukuyomi can only be countered by Uchiha. Amaterasu and the Totsuka took down Nagato. So, it's debatable.

This isn't as much as a problem as the Itachi vs. Nagato, but I have to say what I have to say.
Mangekyo Sharingan Tobi vs. Nagato --- Nagato wins.

Obito and Itachi can use Izanagi, which is a game-changer that is often ignored.

Tobi with Nagato's Rinnegan vs. Nagato --- That's a good question, but I'll say Nagato.

Obito improved on Pain massively, and stacked it with Kamui and Izanagi. So, no.