A song of Ice and Fire

Anduril

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Mar 17, 2011
Messages
12,892
Kin
42💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
So, For some time now I have been considering this series for my next read. But I was waiting for the sixth part of the book to be released. To start the books, in which case only the last book (Hopefully) will be left.

But what I really want to know from people who have read the books is (considering the fact that I have been watching the series Game of thrones and can almost visualise all parts of it stark naked - no pun intended) that
"Will the earlier books bore me, since I have already seen them in action?"
 

Urda

Active member
Supreme
Joined
Aug 4, 2011
Messages
23,637
Kin
2,223💸
Kumi
7,705💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
The tv series is done differently than the books. Not only that but they are going a step further to make their own alternate ending, so the story has to come together. Anyway, similar to the Harry Potter movies and books, the books are clearer because it feels the holes the tv series had to skip to make it all fit into the 1-hour show - that's the upside. The downside is the book isn't as entertaining.
 

Caliburn

Supreme
Joined
Apr 6, 2009
Messages
20,771
Kin
2,805💸
Kumi
525💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
The books and series are quite different. There are so many details about the history of Westeros and so many different plot lines in the books that it was impossible to add all of them to the series. They removed a large chunk of the Westerosi trivia and regularly shifted with the plot lines by editing them, moving them to another character or removed them completely.

I also first watched the first two-three seasons and then read all the current released books and I can tell you that they're two different experiences. In each chapter you view the story from a specific person's point of view, including his thoughts. In the series there's each scene a major character, but you mostly don't have that one person perspective. Instead you've got the interaction between several major characters. This difference has a large impact on you perspective on both the story as the characters.

If you want some of the most recent examples: Doran Martell, Rouse Bolton and Sansa.

Some of the Sand Serpents were indeed annoyed by Doran's supposed passiveness and one of them tried a coup, but failed miserably. Doran then explained to appease her his attempts to get the Targaryen dynasty back on the Iron Throne, attempts that where so secret absolutely no one found out about them.

Rouse Bolton was shown to be extremely devious and being fully aware of Ramsey's character. He made sure that everyone surrounding Ramsey was in fact loyal to him, so in reality Ramsey didn't had that much power.

The things Sansa went through this and the last season are in fact a combination of what happened to two different characters. The one who was forced to marry Ramsey and got raped by him, was a girl named Jeyne Poole. A friend of Sansa and the daughter of one of Eddard's men, who got captured in King's Landing. After that they made her impersonate Arya Stark to give the Boltons a legit claim on Winterfell. She then eventually fled with Theon. It seems that in the next episode Sansa will reach Castle Black, but in the books there's another girl who fled towards it: the daughter of Karstark (the one Robb executed) because one of her family members was trying to take over the house by forcing her to marry him. He pursued her to the Wall where Jon put him in a prison. The Karstarks had officially joined Stannis's cause, but in reality were working for the Boltons and were planning to turn against him.

They condensed all of that into Sansa's plot line and the Karstark treachery into Ramsey's coup.


So yeah the books and TV series are two very different experiences.
 

KillerbYo

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Sep 5, 2011
Messages
3,509
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I haven't read the books but been thinking about it as well but I think the series is better if you read the books, they cover an entire book in one season so it fills in the gaps more.
 
Top