A "should be rule" for VS threads and Top ____

[KingHashirama]

This is getting annoying the point where one gets confused so bad, and it also pisses of many fans of other bases.

Example:

My top 5

- Edo Madara
- Edo Hashi
- Edo Nagato
- Edo Itachi
- Naruto

If you can't tell the problem in the above example, then let me clarify it for you. When you put "EDO" in front of a character.. your basically rating a CREATION in your top w.e .. If you are going to do that then other characters should also have EDO in front of their name. And the excuse of "They weren't summoned" Doesn't matter. In fact there is only 1 Edo who can't be controlled and thats Hashirama.... Other Edos CAN be controlled... =].

Either DON'T use them in your top 10s.... or make every single character into a EDO.


Second Example:

Edo Itachi vs Naruto

AHAHAHA, Naruto can't beat Itachi since he can't seal....

I have no problem with these fanboy VS battles... BUT they in the end lead to flame wars and etc. For Itachi to be a Edo Kabuto needs to be there to summon him...

So for VS battles either have them living or have both as EDOS.

 

[Sensational]

I don't think pre edoed characters should be included at all, its not at all fair to pit an immortal in every sense of the word against a mortal

 

[i OblivioN i]

Nope, because this is basically an error.

Example: Nagato is using Madara's eyes. If Madara fights Nagato, he wont have his eyes.
Obito is using senju DNA
Sasuke is using Itachi's eyes
Naruto is using the Kyubi's chakra

Oro/Kabuto are using edo characters.
(Btw if Kabuto summons Madara, Madara will just release himself and Kill Kabuto)

 

[Saikyokami]

proof that madara can be controlled or GTFO

 

[-Raviel-]

This isnt gonna do jack-shit.....just saying.... but I agree though

 

[foxyladyland]

honestly I think it might be okay sometimes to use edo...
as long as the edo broke out of edo control from the user.

 

[Saikyokami]

oh yah wrong section xd

 

[KingHashirama]

proof that madara can be controlled or GTFO

Proof that he can't be controlled? if you have no proof no point wasting your time.

Nope, because this is basically an error.

Example: Nagato is using Madara's eyes. If Madara fights Nagato, he wont have his eyes.
Obito is using senju DNA
Sasuke is using Itachi's eyes
Naruto is using the Kyubi's chakra

Oro/Kabuto are using edo characters.
(Btw if Kabuto summons Madara, Madara will just release himself and Kill Kabuto)

Apparently somehow Madara will still have his rinnegan when Obito revives him with killing himself.

And also, I'm saying Immortals vs Mortals = unfair.. while your here talking about characters in different time periods of the storyline shouldn't be compared....

Madara can't release himself if Kabuto binds him.... O_O.

 

[~Madara Uchiha~]

This is getting annoying the point where one gets confused so bad, and it also pisses of many fans of other bases.

Example:


If you can't tell the problem in the above example, then let me clarify it for you. When you put "EDO" in front of a character.. your basically rating a CREATION in your top w.e .. If you are going to do that then other characters should also have EDO in front of their name. And the excuse of "They weren't summoned" Doesn't matter. In fact there is only 1 Edo who can't be controlled and thats Hashirama.... Other Edos CAN be controlled... =].

Either DON'T use them in your top 10s.... or make every single character into a EDO.


Second Example:



I have no problem with these fanboy VS battles... BUT they in the end lead to flame wars and etc. For Itachi to be a Edo Kabuto needs to be there to summon him...

So for VS battles either have them living or have both as EDOS.

Cool Story Bro.

 

[Chibiusa]

I agree with you. I don't see why edos are included in the same list as living characters. Being edo shouldn't be considered a feat for them. They didnt do it themselves. Vs threads should be character vs character using their own feats. Being dead doesn't count

 

[Shikage]

what does edo even stand for?

 

[Lightbringer]

Lol again with the fanboyism.....seriously.....Hashirama is the only one who can't be controlled? I do recall Madara having free will and breaking control so this is a fail.

and if you say, well if Kabuto could have erased his mind to control Madara, well Orochimaru could have done the same thing to Hashi, and no mind means no way to break out.