A minor RP suggestion

Status
Not open for further replies.

Alternative

Active member
Elite
Joined
Feb 27, 2011
Messages
6,373
Kin
300💸
Kumi
304💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
I have a small suggestion which I would like to see people's input on. From what I understand, with canon characters you have to follow their history exactly and up to whatever point you want the character to be at, for example Sasuke having either Curse Mark or not. I would like to propose the allowance of custom history for some canon characters.

There would be restrictions on who you could use this for. I'm only saying this because a lot of people want dead characters to RP with, and it's weird reading their history and they only stop right before the end of the battle. According to that history, they're still fighting and stuff, so it's weird. If custom history were allowed to be used for endings like this, I just think it would make more sense to people. I'll take Kimimaro for example, since he seems to be the most common dead guy people like to create bios for.

"After Gaara insulted Kimimaro's loyalty to Orochimaru, he used his sand to bury him two hundred metres below the ground, where the pressure can crush even steel. Kimimaro, however, used the last one of his dances to turn the battlefield into a forest of bones, that Gaara and Lee barely escaped by hanging onto a small cloud of sand. Fuelled by his hatred of being insulted, Kimimaro emerged from one of the bones, and prepared to strike the two at point blank range. However, he finally succumbed to his illness just before he could kill Gaara, who was already out of chakra, and died. Gaara later came to the conclusion that no-one can defeat loneliness, even if it means to care for a person like Orochimaru."​

This shows Kimimaro dying right before he's about to kill Gaara. For an approvable bio, you'd need to really finish your history right before he dies, after he uses his Bone Field technique. If we were allowed to alter the ending so it fits, it could be better suited for ending. So for this next example, I'll be taking from where Gaara and Lee barely escaped.

Kimimaro, however, used the last one of his dances to turn the battlefield into a forest of bones, that Gaara and Lee barely escaped by hanging onto a small cloud of sand. Using this forest of bones, Kimimaro was able to move freely within them, and used them to escape the battle, sparing Gaara and Lee. Without exerting himself too much, he was able to hold in the rest of his strength and make it to <insert location> where he met <insert character>, a strong medical shinobi. This person was able to heal Kimimaro to a state where he would seem fully rested. Because of this illness though, he is in need of constant care.

This is only an example, but it would make more sense rather than finishing mid-battle. Of course this would only apply to certain characters who die in the midst of a battle, so someone like Kimimaro would be allowed, but Chiyo wouldn't because you can end her history right after them beating Sasori.

tl;dr Make custom history allowed for certain characters who die in a battle.

Thoughts?
 

Zoro..

Active member
Elite
Joined
Nov 19, 2011
Messages
9,661
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
I personally like this idea as long as the history dosent affect what they have. So just a minor change if they were dead. For instance I wouldnt want someone to say in theyre Minato bio that Orochimaru caught him and gave him a curse mark. It would just be a tiny change.
 

Alternative

Active member
Elite
Joined
Feb 27, 2011
Messages
6,373
Kin
300💸
Kumi
304💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
I disagree with this it is unnecessary and if you don't want canon Biography short then do not make it.
Aww how cute, someone's holding a grudge. I can tick that off my bucket list. :3

But anyway it's right as Omnom said. Although that wasn't my intention for this, it works better that way. Give a valid reason for escaping your death and it's better for a bio.
 

Iwabi

Active member
Veteran
Joined
May 24, 2011
Messages
2,857
Kin
3💸
Kumi
27💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I believe you can create history for them providing certain characters say live in the same era, for example I made a custom biography history on my first biography which was the Shodaime Tsuchikage of the Kamizuru clan so i could with him state i had battle with hashirama and it became a draw and then formed an alliance and then lead to the character founding the land of stone
 

Luther

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Sep 17, 2011
Messages
11,547
Kin
10💸
Kumi
3💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
everyone quick! get to the troll shelter thunderbolt has posted D=
Please refrain from resulting to petty reply's they don't in my opinion make you appear smart one can say they show your Inability to focus and post On topic.

$$ Now to Alt suggestions,this idea is not good you cant alter masashi work, or try to become him the reason why we allow character in our rp system to have several element is maybe to keep it real as possible that is fine but to actually want to make or add history or even minus from the already given in the anime/manga in my opinion is unnecessary and in some ways is infringing kishi work.My final verdict is this is not gonna be good if exacted in the role play,this is merely my opinion and IN my opinion this this will not work out however i am just one member so good luck in having your ideas imposed..$$
 
Last edited:

Omnom

Active member
Elite
Joined
Oct 7, 2010
Messages
6,401
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
Please refrain from resulting to petty reply's they don't in my opinion make you appear smart one can say they show your Inability to focus and post On topic.

$$ Now to Alt suggestions,this idea is not good you cant affect or try to be kishi the reason why we allow character in our rp system to have several element is maybe to keep it real as possible that is fine but to actually wont to make or add history o even minus from the already given in the anime/manga in my opinion is unnecessary and in some ways infringing kishi work. My final verdict is this is not gonna be good if exacted in the role play,this is merely my opinion and my opinion this this will not work out however i am just one member so good luck in having your ideas imposed..$$
Who are you to issue final verdicts? :|

For some reason, you can't use / don't have a brain to be able to understand the point. By your reasoning, any character who has died in the manga / anime can't be use. And they are limited to the jutsus they have shown. That makes total sense.... Not. We're not making a rival manga or trying to sell Kishi's work... We're adding in an extra paragraph on the bios to add why our character lived through what should've killed them, or why a Jiraya bio is in Kirigakure for example. Just because your suggestions get shot down as the trash they are, please don't try to put down the rare occasion that a suggestion is actually worth something.
 

Luther

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Sep 17, 2011
Messages
11,547
Kin
10💸
Kumi
3💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
Who are you to issue final verdicts? :|

For some reason, you can't use / don't have a brain to be able to understand the point. By your reasoning, any character who has died in the manga / anime can't be use. And they are limited to the jutsus they have shown. That makes total sense.... Not. We're not making a rival manga or trying to sell Kishi's work... We're adding in an extra paragraph on the bios to add why our character lived through what should've killed them, or why a Jiraya bio is in Kirigakure for example. Just because your suggestions get shot down as the trash they are, please don't try to put down the rare occasion that a suggestion is actually worth something.
Thank you mr omnom for that insultive comment you have been reported,i never stated and said that character who are dead cant be used i simply stated that character who are dead or alive and have small or short history should be left untouched in terms of their history no individual should make up little stories or history explaining what or why occurred from an expected action which was made by the the manga and anime author kishi not happen to the character ,and yes each individual has their own opinion that is why is stated my opinion and in ky opinion which is my decision=My verdict this is not a good ideas.Also u suggest you don't insult member like me when trying to quote them and reply to them insultive comments only need to bans and infractions let us enjoy this forum please don't ruin it by petty stupid and irrelevant comments.
 

-God of War-

Active member
Elite
Joined
Jun 3, 2011
Messages
6,332
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Who are you to issue final verdicts? :|

For some reason, you can't use / don't have a brain to be able to understand the point. By your reasoning, any character who has died in the manga / anime can't be use. And they are limited to the jutsus they have shown. That makes total sense.... Not. We're not making a rival manga or trying to sell Kishi's work... We're adding in an extra paragraph on the bios to add why our character lived through what should've killed them, or why a Jiraya bio is in Kirigakure for example. Just because your suggestions get shot down as the trash they are, please don't try to put down the rare occasion that a suggestion is actually worth something.
No! You have no brain!
It is his opinion to say if it is good or no. Why you should flame him like that?!
He (Thunderbould) disagrees with this suggestion you disagree with his suggestions. His suggestions aren't trash! He tries to help the forum with what he got and has respect. He should be respected for this. +That you and Alternative started to flame him cause he doesn't agrees with you.
Don't try flaming again, cause I will be there and stop you!

Also
@The Fifth Kazekage:
There is no need to do that. We are not rabbits like you to do that. And try not flaming the other members. Or else...don't try it with my friends!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Luther

Scorps

Active member
Supreme
Joined
May 23, 2008
Messages
25,974
Kin
613💸
Kumi
408💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Enough with the flaming. Jeezz.... :| Btw, you can stop the history on the point right before the character dies and add a small phrase or two to make it possible. However, as you understand it doesn't really matter does it?
 
  • Like
Reactions: -God of War-
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top