I think the Deva Paths would win because they could provide cover for each other. I imagine they win, but doubt they could all perform giant Almighty Pushes or Plantery Devastations.
Naraka, Preta, and Human Paths don't come close to succeeding. They're not good at dealing with numbers(because their abilities immobilize them), and there's no Deva Path obliterating most of Konoha's forces this time around.
I think Asura Path has a decent chance of reaping major destruction on the village, but again, no Deva Path means more people to deal with. Tsunade, Naruto, Kakashi, Sakura, etc, could probably handle them. Wouldn't surprise me if 100+ died in the process though.
Closest to success after Deva Path is Animal Path imo. Assuming they can summon multiple of the same creatures, their threat is stupid high. Only the stronger characters(I'm including characters like Choji's and Hinata's dad here) can contend with the summons, and only a select few of those stronger characters can actually deal with the abilities(invis & physical immunity specifically) of those summons. Animal Paths should also be drastically more coordinated. All of the animals grant shared vision, and they'd have literal hawk eyes in the skies to assist them, Cerberus with dozens of eyes tagging alongside the heads, chameleons on the walls, centipedes on the ground, etc. They may as well have wall-hacks.
I don't see any single person beating the Animal Paths because it will never a 1 on 1. Let's say Tsunade pulled up on one of the Paths. The Paths already know where everyone is, so the Path that's being attacked can just run somewhere isolated & the other Paths can regroup with the one being pursued there. Naruto and the toads also mean nothing to the dogs. Only real downside is that he has to allocate his resources wisely otherwise something like Naruto/Hinata(?) killing all his chameleons and
the Choji-family killing all his Ox's can happen. Most of his summons can also be neg-diffed by even the weaker Konaha ninja, so he has to take out a number of the stronger Shinobi before he has too few bodies to hide behind. Probably loses in the end because it's not like Konaha members would aimlessly fight their counters, they'd move around too. High-diff.
