[Question] 10th Nakama

[NarutovsLuffy]

Who will be the Strawhats 10th Nakama ?

I want it to be Rebecca, Violet (or Viola whatever u call her), or Leo (I know your going to say "what !?" But I think Leo can be a cool Strawhat member)

 

[Reaper]

its like we just recycle threads nowadays

 

[ultraChalk]

So our runner ups are

Kinemon (somehwat likely)
Momonuske (somewhat likely, higher than Kinemon)
Rebecca (likely if Kyros allows her to become a pirate, but why would she want to leave the father she just met again, and why would she want to become a pirate?)
Koala (likely)
Sabo (unlikely, he's a revolutionary)
Violet (unlikely, she doesn't have the personality for the strawhats and... I just can't see it)
Law (no)

Out of all of them the ones I want most are Momo because he has extremely high potential to become an awesome fighter with all of his abilities, and Rebecca because she has an awesome personality, developed background and abilities of speed/reflexes.

The only way Momo could become a pirate is if Kinemon died and left him to the Strawhats which is possible, but idk about Rebecca. So it'll probably be Momo. But even then I doubt that.

Koala would be a good choice too. I'm very interested in seeing how her and Boa would interact with each other. But I have to see more of her and it seems like she's a revolutionary.

 

[Dr Strangelove]

I want Sugar still >.<

 

[kyuuubi]

Momonosuke

 

[ultraChalk]

I want Sugar still >.<

Are you joking or serious?

I don't even see her as a candidate.

 

[NarutovsLuffy]

I want Sugar still >.<

I rather have Sugar as a strawhat than Momonuske !!!

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

So our runner ups are

Kinemon (somehwat likely)
Momonuske (somewhat likely, higher than Kinemon)

They'll join Law. As them being added to Laws crew will increase the Parallels between the Whitebeard Pirates and the Heart Pirates.

Rebecca (likely if Kyros allows her to become a pirate, but why would she want to leave the father she just met again, and why would she want to become a pirate?)
Koala (likely)
Sabo (unlikely, he's a revolutionary)

Never going to happen.

Violet (unlikely, she doesn't have the personality for the strawhats and... I just can't see it)

Oh really? She is in a similar situation to Robin back in Alabasta. She's perfect Strawhat material.

To be honest for me the three candidates are Kyros, Viola and Sugar

 

[ultraChalk]

They'll join Law. As them being added to Laws crew will increase the Parallels between the Whitebeard Pirates and the Heart Pirates.


Never going to happen.


Oh really? She is in a similar situation to Robin back in Alabasta. She's perfect Strawhat material.

To be honest for me the three candidates are Kyros, Viola and Sugar

1. Since when were the Heart Pirates and Whitebeards trying to be paralleled?

2. Koala has a chance.

3. But the intensity and severity of her situation are absolutely nowhere near Robins. She's wanted for killing a couple guys who broke up with her. Robin on the other hand was working under, and betrayed a Shickibukai.

And the only reason Luffy recruited Robin was because she was about to kill herself. Rebecca is not in that same situation and just got in touch with her family, so she's probably going to want to stay there and live with them now.

Kyros- absolutely not, he's going to stay with the king and serve under him. he has no desire to be a pirate.
Violet- doubtful.
Sugar- Super doubtful i am laughing. Unless those are your opinions then ok

 

[Dr Strangelove]

Are you joking or serious?

I don't even see her as a candidate.

Serious :| Obv she's not a candidate now. But in an ideal world she would be my first pick.

I rather have Sugar as a strawhat than Momonuske !!!

And ikr :3 >.<

 

[Moonbird]

Isn't it pretty obviously Jinbei?

he even all-ready accepted the offer, though he needed to finish up some buisness of his own first, honestly, I would not be surprised, at all, if Jinbei shows off the moment that Ki'omon and Momo leaves the ship.

I thought the manga had all-ready established that! pretty loud and clearly, Jinbei is going to become a straw-hat when he is done doing what-ever it was he needed to do first.

 

[Maly]

I think Bartolomeo has still the highest chance to be it. But i more wish that no one is going to join this arc.

 

[Love Cook]

Sugar will never join, her devil fruit is too complicated to randomly use. It's plot holes waiting to happen.

Kyros would be awesome as strawhat. I hope Franky makes a leg for him, he spend a lot of time with the toy soldier after all

 

[Moonbird]

Wait... doesn't Merry/Sunny count for a Nakama to?

So.. doesn't that mean any next Nakama would be Nakama number 11?

 

[Reaper]

Wait... doesn't Merry/Sunny count for a Nakama to?

So.. doesn't that mean any next Nakama would be Nakama number 11?

No it doesnt
Technically they would consider it nakama but its still their ship,not a nakama like a living being

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

1. Since when were the Heart Pirates and Whitebeards trying to be paralleled?

2. Koala has a chance.

3. But the intensity and severity of her situation are absolutely nowhere near Robins. She's wanted for killing a couple guys who broke up with her. Robin on the other hand was working under, and betrayed a Shickibukai.

And the only reason Luffy recruited Robin was because she was about to kill herself. Rebecca is not in that same situation and just got in touch with her family, so she's probably going to want to stay there and live with them now.

Kyros- absolutely not, he's going to stay with the king and serve under him. he has no desire to be a pirate.
Violet- doubtful.
Sugar- Super doubtful i am laughing. Unless those are your opinions then ok

Okay, I guess I have to show you some threads:
Kyros for Strawhat:

You must be registered for see links

Heart - Whitebeard mirrors:

You must be registered for see links

Viola for Strawhat:

You must be registered for see links

(Also I'd like to add some new content to that thread if I could. She's had flashbacks and is interacting with Luffy which are crucial for Strawhats during the recruitment process)

Trust me bro. I've made tons of theories. I know some things...

 

[Moonbird]

No it doesnt
Technically they would consider it nakama but its still their ship,not a nakama like a living being

Except.. arguable in the context of this specific Manga... the ship is in fact a person, and has a soul, as well as a voice that can communicate with the crew in dire circumstances when absolutely needed. Even appeared in a human like form in front of Usopp, talked to all of them later.
Appeared in his human like form again in a TV-Special observing them.. they do have a living guardian spirit following them, and living with them, and they consider that ships-spirit... what-ever.. that was created with Merry and moved along to Sunny, a Nakama..

It's a tiny bit ambegious, but I think it can be argued that there is an alive spirit, with a mind, soul, voice and every-thing of its own, called Merry, that follows them around as a bonus Nakama, protecting them when needed.

At least that must count for half a nakama, right!?


And before any-one says. "But it's just a ship!" .. every-one are just drawings in the harsh reality of things, and in the context of the manga, that ship is a darn person!

I've cried more over that damn ship than i've done over death of main characters in other fictional medias... darn it.

 

[Zorø]

Sugar would be a good candidate.....but I want violet to join I find her ability interesting.

 

[crono0929]

i dont think there will be a new nakama this arc, Rebecca, Violet, Riku and Kyros are going to stay and try to rebuild the OLD dressrosa.

The strawhats will Gain tons of allies by the end of this arc tho.

Barto Club
Don chinjao's army.
former toys.

 

[xXVergiliusXx]

i dont think there will be a new nakama this arc, Rebecca, Violet, Riku and Kyros are going to stay and try to rebuild the OLD dressrosa.

The strawhats will Gain tons of allies by the end of this arc tho.

Barto Club
Don chinjao's army.
former toys.

I agree with all this