Search results

Somewhere in the Town pile: Alice, Elmage, Vaseline Probably dying at EOD: Odd Scum read: Rej, Poison Unless Odd is wolf, I probably have too many Town reads, and right now I don't think you're teamed with Rej, so I've got some re-reading to do before EOD. I probably always lynch Rej today though.

I knowingly subbed into a sinking slot, and the only way to pull myself out of it is to trust myself and hope I can bag a wolf to clear my name. I won't do that by being indecisive.

To summarize my thoughts on Rej, their posts just don't come across like they have no knowledge. I get the feeling Rej is always comfortable, never pushing for answers, never striving for the truth, always being careful not to offend anyone too much. I think the strongest read I've seen from...

I'm sorry, nobody informed me I was supposed to struggle on any reads. I'll write a strongly worded letter about this post game. Tell you what. Pretend my predecessor doesn't exist. Read me off what I'm doing and saying. At least give me another Day phase, to have chance to gain some potential...

Hard to make this kind of call without having Alice or Elmage flipped, but I would say that if either flips green this is a very bad look for Rej, it comes across like encouraging V-on-V confrontation.

This isn't even a read, it's just pointing out an evolving style.

The outcome of the read on Alice here feels at odds with the first statement. If Alice treats Ansa (and others) like they are players unalighed to her, and you Town read Ansa, then surely the default position to take on Alice is that she's wolf. "Null" is not in opposition to Town, and it being...

Earlier I said that I had some bad feelings about Rej. I'll try and put into words, if I can, exactly why those feelings came about. This was the first post that pinged me when I started reading the thread. The tone just feels off. I'm not sure I can explain it any better than that. The casual...

My slot was already swinging from a noose by the time I got here. If I end up being chopped then at best I did what I could but did not have enough impact to either A) change the minds of towns, or B) counteract the influence of wolves. Also I believe you'll find I don't take particularly well...

Rej, what made you decide to vote my slot over Alice's?

Alice, why were you okay with not lynching yesterday? If we don't lynch, how are we gonna kill wolves?

None, currently. I came out of retirement as a personal favor to Michelle.

I think his question was fine, but his approach to it was confusing given his own apparent TR of Alice. At first glance it looked like Vaseline Guy was trying to discourage me from Townreading Alice. At second glance it looks more like he's trying to figure out how I got there from Alice's...

I actually noticed three instances of Alice trying very hard to meta-read you as Town. I've put them in a spoiler below and highlighted the pertinent parts of the quotes in whatever random color my mouse landed on. She's trying very hard to get you to play into her Town meta knowledge of...

I'm going to put this entire conversation back into context for you. To paraphrase: Alice: I'm not going to put you in my towns right away because in our last game you were mafia and you burned me. Elmage: Well, I burnt you when I was mafia last game, I may as well burn you when I am town...

He has the word "vaseline" in his name.

I have never played with any of you before. I can't try to narrow my POE with meta. So I'm going to try to do it by analyzing interactions. Healthy? Maybe not. But I'm pushed for time and need a direction to go in, so this is what I'm doing. Feel free to disagree with me if you like.

Well, I don't. But I do make assumptions when I have gaps in my knowledge. It helps me to prioritize where I should be looking.

Poison, if you thought it was too early to provide real thoughts/reads, why did you so easily accept Rej's production of thoughts/reads?

Oh wait, you aren't voting him. I don't think? If you're not, ignore me. If you are, please respond.