Search results

I didn't explain all of my reasoning. But if you read the rest of my posts and my interactions with the players I've listed whom you are confused by, it should be adequate. I've explained why I have Konno as town. As for Odd, while I suspected his vote to be a buss, his following posts after I...

I might usually agree, but I don't think Ryu voted just to make him look good - I think he was genuinely trying to lynch him instead to save himself or maybe take another player down. If both of them ended up being tied and both were mafia, that would be 2 mafia dead day 1. (If I'm understanding...

This is where I'm at: Probably Town: Poison, Alice (unless they were recruited), Dr. Strange, Oreki Maybe Town: Konno, Odd, Sesh (unless he's lying about knowing mafia flavors) Neutral: Sagebee, Michelle (might have been a scumlean but I kind of want to rely on Firekitten's judgement for now)...

Why do you think Strange is mafia (or not town)? I feel that Ryu pushing him at the end of day 1 may spew him as town.

There are other players in the game. There's more than 1 mafia left. There are other things you can do in the meantime, even if Sagebee is offline, no? Do you intend to vote them today?

There's at least 1 mafia between 6th and All_Red, I think.

That's fair. It was my first thought as well. But Sesh is claiming he knows the mafia flavors, and Orton was not one of them. If he's not telling the truth about that, he'd be scum and we should be lynching him. Does that make sense? Yeah, that's what I didn't understand. The association felt...

Well, according to Sesh, whoever killed FK is town. So either you believe him, and can't run with this theory any more, or you think he's defending a buddy, which would make him a top priority. I also am not understanding why you came to those three people in the first place, out of everyone in...

That was me. Ryu primarily pushed Strange for the lynch. I did see his vote on you, but Strange was the strongest counter, other than Konno, at that time. So while he could have voted you in attempt to save himself, it's not as selling of a clear because Strange had the higher chance of being...

About 2 years now, I've been playing. I see. Were you not curious who died in the night?

Correction on my #834. I don't think Konno has said she is busy? I tend to associate inactivity with busyness or claims of busyness, but it could just be lurking, which comes from either alignment anyway (with exceptions depending on the player) Also may have forgotten to finish my thought on...

I have to do some work tonight - for now, I find Konno's behavior somewhat townie. I may be reading into small things and would like a stronger tell to show up soon, but currently, she isn't attempting to alleviate suspicion of her by providing reads. Mafia, having insider knowledge, can easily...

How about this - 2 town leans, 1 scum lean, and reasons for all of those? Also, Sesh is claiming that the kill was performed by town (or not-mafia) due to him knowing all the mafia flavors. So it wasn't done to frame anyone, if mafia didn't make the kill. (I also am willing to trust the claim at...

Might be nitpicking here, but what do you hope to accomplish with this question? I'd kind of understand asking this earlier in the game, but at this point, you have enough content to find your own suspicions, so it seems a bit strange that you'd ask for others without providing your own.

This was the final vote count: Ryu's wagon wasn't massive either, and it would have been possible to create a tie if one more player voted Konno and Ryu had voted properly. Though I should actually read their posts, might be more telling than all of this.

Sorry for the bother - while I was rereading, I saw a post explaining how to ISO (or find one player's posts in a single thread), but I forgot it. Can someone remind me?

True. Firekitten has also been the most active of players, was on a scum lynch day 1, so the kill of them is not unreasonable regardless of who they were pushing. However, I recall Konno being pushed day 1, and was a viable counter train to Ryu day 1 yet was not pushed by Ryu to save himself...

Are you claiming certain knowledge that Orton is town, and that Sagebee is Orton? Kind of wondering how we're to use our abilities to the max if investigative results can't be revealed, or can they? (Also, I think I kind of assumed it was a mafia kill based on the font color, but I forgot all...

Well, that's sad. Looks like mafia have a lot of killing power. Wonder if this is to frame Konno or if Konno is actually mafia?

Me neither. It's all speculation that won't help catch mafia/SK. Not a problem unless you decide to push people based on it.