A big plot hole

[Armathyx]

Why has Nagato never used rinne-tensei to revive Yahiko? Isn't this kind of stupid?

 

[Sasuke..]

Because he already kinda had him as a reanimated dead body, and it would cost him his life.

 

[sLm]

What? How would reviving Yahico cost him his life?

 

[CurseSealofEarth]

Because he already kinda had him as a reanimated dead body, and it would cost him his life.

This.

 

[Sasuke..]

What? How would reviving Yahico cost him his life?

Rinne tensei will cost you your life i believe, and maybe he didn't know the jutsu yet.

 

[Ōkami]

if he did that then Shippuden would have a giant question mark in it

 

[Armathyx]

Because he already kinda had him as a reanimated dead body, and it would cost him his life.

Bullshit, he had enough power to revive a ton of Konoha people after he fought the Kyuubi and used Chibaku Tensei, surely he couldhave resurected 1 person alone.

 

[Kyuubibomb]

it doesn't cost you your life it only killed nagato because he used so much chakra against naruto.

 

[DeadManWonderLand]

Why has Nagato never used rinne-tensei to revive Yahiko? Isn't this kind of stupid?

That is not a plot hole.A plot hole is a gap or inconsistency in a storyline that goes against the flow of logic established by the story's PLOT, or constitutes a blatant omission of relevant information regarding the PLOT.Nagato was tricked just like obito into using his power for "peace" He wanted the reality of this world to change bringing back yahiko does not complete his goals.

 

[Gyakusetsu]

Deva path > fodder Yahiko.

 

[~Madara Uchiha~]

the justsu i believe will cost more chakra the longer the person has been dead this is why it will probly kill him if he revived Yahiko

 

[Young Thug]

Why do people try Kishi so hard by attempting to find plotholes?

 

[Alcamea]

hmm some time ago there was a thread about rinne tensei and how nagato used it. The main opinion was that he didn't want to have Nagato in this "impure" world full of pain. Maybe he would revive him after he made everyone understand 'peace'

 

[komplexbs]

hmm some time ago there was a thread about rinne tensei and how nagato used it. The main opinion was that he didn't want to have Nagato in this "impure" world full of pain. Maybe he would revive him after he made everyone understand 'peace'

This is perfectly right. He wanted to show him the world they both dreamed of after he has already formed it.

 

[Kurama2012]

how the hell is it a plot hole you dumb or what and when did nagato state he was aiming to bring back yahiko try looking up what a plot hole is before you state when one is

 

[supino]

Rinne tensei will cost you your life i believe, and maybe he didn't know the jutsu yet.

no, it only depleted his chakra reserves after he had practically used all of his chakra that day and he did revive a lot of people. if i remember correctly Konan said to him the way your chakra reserves are now, or sth similar.

so, no. it wouldn't kill him. but probably there is sth like a time limit after which the jutsu is rendered useless. or sth else, kishi will soon tell us as in order to revive Madara with rinne tensei as the original plan was, Nagato would have to use the jutsu long after Madara died.

maybe it is sth like that: rinne tensei can either revive a lot of people simultaneously but close after their deaths, or one individual and long after his/her death.

either way it is weird that Nagato completely forgot about Yahiko and decided to save the jutsu for Madara.

said plot hole has been pointed out before, and it bugs a lot of people... on the other hand the way the story is right now many things could bug a lot of people

 

[cptenn94]

the real reason he never revived him, is probably because he died so long ago that it would cost him his life(to make the amount of chakra needed) to do so, konan knew of the technique because he had used it beforeas show here

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

so she also says that if he uses it with those chakra levels he will die, which leads to maybe he almost died before trying to revive yahiko.....

also he may not have known it at the time and only learned the technique before it was to late....what is implied is that a full chakra nagito can revive someone who died about 20 years ago(madara)... ultimatly we will never know

 

[Renon]

bleh I find it pointless to reason this shit out anymore.. hell maybe he just forgot about Yahiko.