[Discussion] If an edo Hashirama appeared on the battlefield would Madara win or lose?

[GdaTyler]

If he appeared out of nowhere would he win or lose. Considering Madara is a billion times stronger than when he died, it means he could probably beat him.

 

[Hipster Madara]

He could stop him for a while at least.
He would need help sealing him tho

 

[Nerow]

You know that can't happen right.

 

[TheSages456]

hashirama would beat him just like he did before and if hashirama doesnt have a sealing tech(doubtful), he could just let bee seal him or something.

 

[KGB Kakuzu]

Well Madara basically has traded Kurama for Mokuton and the Rinnegan so I'd say it is till like it would have been back then, an insane fight that could go either way. Still I would expect a shock factor from Madara so Hashirama might have an initial advantage as Ninjas are supposed to take advantage of situations and be stealthy XD!!!

 

[Scooby Doo]

Madara has Hashi's powers now + rinnegan so Madara would win IMO.

 

[repulse]

Your poll choices aren't the greatest. Add other options.

 

[Klubargutan]

this forum is full of idiots, thats why i dont come here too often, edo madara's techniques and strength= nagato+himself+hashirama+immortality+izanagi/yin/yang+ invincibility+infinite chakra and can extract souls with rinnegan and has 10 tailed beast inside his mazou. edo hashirama= the weak loser who fought against hiruzen, he has no tailed beasts in his collection(he had them, as obito said, thats why i think madara lost...) to use against madara and so...he would get raped instantly
stupid people here voting for edo hashirama LOL

 

[Aaroninja]

Hashi is an expert with seals now. Madara just has the rinnegan and Mokuton. Hashi could still seal him if he gets close enough

 

[aashish1996]

nobody would win nor lose since they are edo unless sealing jutsus are used.

 

[Fhayr]

What if Edo-Hashirama could retract/remove/control his Cells in Madara. He inherited the body of the Sot6P for christ sake, his cells have been abused to hell, would only make sense that he can control them.

That rids Edo-Madara of Wood Release and without Senju DNA he can no longer control his Rinnegan; but that still leaves Madara with EMS. You also have to take into account we don't know how/when Hashirama died, it's entirely plausible he could've learned/unlocked some Senju-Body progression.

But they're both Edo, so no one wins. Unless Hashirama restrains Madara and allows both of them to be sealed.

 

[thegame]

If he appeared out of nowhere would he win or lose. Considering Madara is a billion times stronger than when he died, it means he could probably beat him.

A billion times is a lot... so you must be a fanboy? Guess I can't respect a proper response then... anyway it's impossible to foretell such a battle. Hashirama fought Madara and the kuybi, which says a lot. If edo Hashi appeared now, Madara would of course have his mokuton, though he probably would be far from hashis level in using it. Hashi also already knows his perfect susano, so that he will defeat, low diff... But Madara also had kuybi back then, so the real question is, whether rinnengan makes him stronger than if he had the kuybi under his control. I doubt that though.. so hashi still wins, and if madara wins, he wont rape hashi, it will be high diff as well.. fan kid

 

[phantom1]

Hashirama will defeat madara with no difficulty. Fix ur poll

 

[GdaTyler]

A billion times is a lot... so you must be a fanboy? Guess I can't respect a proper response then... anyway it's impossible to foretell such a battle. Hashirama fought Madara and the kuybi, which says a lot. If edo Hashi appeared now, Madara would of course have his mokuton, though he probably would be far from hashis level in using it. Hashi also already knows his perfect susano, so that he will defeat, low diff... But Madara also had kuybi back then, so the real question is, whether rinnengan makes him stronger than if he had the kuybi under his control. I doubt that though.. so hashi still wins, and if madara wins, he wont rape hashi, it will be high diff as well.. fan kid

I'm not a fanboy of Madara... but if he can now be able to summon meteors and have many new techniques, then he must be that many times stronger than how he was before. I don't really particularly like Madara that much, so sorry. The way it seems is that you're probably a Hashirama fan boy, though you're saying it very subtly. Go away and don't dare call me a fan kid you hypocrite. Also this is just a manga discussion, I'm not taking it seriously.

 

[RikudoKami]

Madara would still win.. stop misinterpreting what he said to the Kage.. he was really saying only one person was ever able to give him a run for his money.. Rinnegan plus Mokuton > Mokuton...

 

[Wabbit]

immortal madara with rinnegan+hashirama's powr VS immortal hashirama
only plus thing abt hashirama is immortality

 

[Makoto]

Hashirama would win. If Madara is so much stronger than Hashirama and would beat Hashirama, why does Madara keep praising and talking about Hashirama's power?

 

[AnaHatake]

Well I don't believe that Hashirama would appear out of nowhere as his body was seal by the third, but if he did it'd be so freaking cool!!
I believe Hashirama would win after all he believes in the will of fire. But then again Madara has grown stronger...I think it would be a rather close call but Hashirama would come out on top. The good guy always wins

 

[thegame]

I'm not a fanboy of Madara... but if he can now be able to summon meteors and have many new techniques, then he must be that many times stronger than how he was before. I don't really particularly like Madara that much, so sorry. The way it seems is that you're probably a Hashirama fan boy, though you're saying it very subtly. Go away and don't dare call me a fan kid you hypocrite. Also this is just a manga discussion, I'm not taking it seriously.

You make a thread about something that is impossible to even give a slight hint about, and yet you say madara is a billion times stronger. How can I not believe you are a fanboy? We have no knowledge of how their battle ended except that Hashirama won. Might as well be that Madara lost by obtaining his DNA in whatever unthinkable possible way, which would mean Madara is stronger. May even have been a walkover for hashirama, we don't know a thing about how long it took, how his chakra reserves were when it ended, etc.. Basically you can't even compare them, and morons all over these forums do it everyday - and what do they use? Max 3 sentences, cause that is as much as they can say about that fight... Whether Madaras meteor is a big deal for hashi, we simply have no knowledge that can provide us a qualified answer except for what we saw when he fought 3rd hokage as an edo, and that can't be compared due to the time skip U_U