"VS" Thread's are completely pointless!

[YellowFlash1]

I really don't understand why people continue to do Vs thread's!

There completely pointless ... I don't think people understand that there is no right or wrong answer .. well, to a degree .. Let me explain why! You always see people doing ...

Itachi V Minato ...

Naruto V Sasuke

Killer Bee v Kakashi

Nagato V Madara

The list goes on forever tbh!

Now why is it that there is no winner or there is no right answer? Well it's pretty simple. You see when you come up with the fight in your heads it's completely based on your imagination! So, The fight that you explain to us and why he can win is completely hypothetical and based on certain situation that you use while the battle in taking place in your head. What do i mean?

Well if you actually think about it ... The over-exaggeration example i'm going to use here is possible it's incredible unlikely though..

Itachi V Minato

Itachi starts the fight by challenging Minato ... 20m distance apart..

Itachi is running towards Minato, Itachi falls over a rock taking his eye of minato for a split second and bammm Minato wins ....

Minato is challenging itachi to a fight ... (Even though there both dead)

Minato runs at itachi ... All of a sudden he's caught under a genjutsu .. Why ? Minato has knowledge on itachi sharingan ? How can this be ......

Because .. It's completely hypothetical therefore you will always make your favourite character win like 90% of the time ... Kish uses the same logic he makes strong character and just gives them a fight and it's decided on how he want's the story to go.

Point i'm trying to make guy's, is that it's completely pointless to make Vs thread because there isn't ever going to be a winner and the fact that i think every single fight has been debated before... ​

 

[Kettei]

Naruto vs Shizune.
Who wins?

 

[SQY]

Completely agree.

 

[YellowFlash1]

Naruto vs Shizune.
Who wins?

In the thread i said " To a degree" Meaning if it's completely illogical then it's being stupid ...

People always fight about Minato v itachi .. Everyone creates Situations in the fight... And people use counters and they use counters and they use counters and it goes on .. Meaning there isn't actually a winner...

 

[Narutoisgodly]

this was pretty obvious but +rep anyway

 

[Simple Math]

in vs threads its

logic > opinion > fanboyism

some people dont understand that

 

[killerbeesama]

i posted sth. like that a long time ago
people said they know it, but its fun to discuss...

i think everybody knows that its pointless to discuss fictional battles

 

[Dihajum3]

Ture..Very True.

What's even more frustrating is people keep creating the same Thread over and over and over again and yet those Threads manage 30+ pages. If i make a lengthy Minato Vs Itachi thread right now, You can bee sure it'll pile up pages. We have gone with such discussions for ages now.

The VS Threads have been reduced to a place where Fanboys fight each other without giving a shit about the Manga. Sad, Truly Sad.

 

[YellowFlash1]

i like vs threads

It just turns in the a never ending fight .. And everyone makes them all the time, It's always different situations to prove one is better or its "WHY HE BEATS HIM" or whatever .. Point is there pointless and cause never ending arguments

 

[The God of Wind]

Here's a slightly better explanation to why they're pointless.....

You must be registered for see links

 

[-Punk-]

But its fun to hear other peoples opinion is it not?

 

[Invsblphntm]

Many people before you have made this stupid thread before. Obviously it's all hypothetical, even fights in the manga are hypothetical. You can always something like "Naruto lost to Sasuke cause he didn't summon Bunta."

Everything is hypothetical, get over it.

 

[Punk Hazard]

That's what makes them fun to debate in. Since it's all hypothetical, there are hundreds of scenarios that can happen. This just makes them even more debatable. I doubt you'll understand.

 

[BossManKakashi]

If vs threads are pointless so is the base, or any leisure activity. Take that "half-empty" non sense to whence it came. Please?

 

[YellowFlash1]

But its fun to hear other peoples opinion is it not?

Yeah it was fun the first time ... then the second time, the 3rd time was a little meh .. The fourth time was like "I though we went over this" The firth time was a start of an argument and guess what ... the 100th later it was still an on going argument. Haha

 

[YellowFlash1]

That's what makes them fun to debate in. Since it's all hypothetical, there are hundreds of scenarios that can happen. This just makes them even more debatable. I doubt you'll understand.

You doubt i will understand what?

Hey minato wins because he kill tobi will a frying pan this time instead of a rasengan ...

No man tobi will win this time because he will use a ramen cup to lure minato .. and hit him with a log!

Point is it becomes stupid ... and people take them far to serious, not to mention it's always the same stuff that get's discussed.

 

[BossManKakashi]

Yeah it was fun the first time ... then the second time, the 3rd time was a little meh .. The fourth time was like "I though we went over this" The firth time was a start of an argument and guess what ... the 100th later it was still an on going argument. Haha

Then dont read threads you've read before? Haha we got a real noob on our hands here fellas

 

[YellowFlash1]

Then dont read threads you've read before? Haha we got a real noob on our hands here fellas

Who said i read them?

Was more of an observation...

 

[Champ]

Welcome to Naruto forums

 

[BossManKakashi]

Who said i read them?

Was more of an observation...

Well if you haven't even read them how would you know if the thread contains new updates cause of power upgrades or new and interesting perspectives on the match-up? New people joining everyday. Point is that you shouldn't voice such a shallow and negative opinion in public and expect anyone to agree with you.. Cept for the jobbers