Nagato's Rinnegan.

[MickNerks]

Nagato did not get his rinnegan from Madara. Tobi said that he gave nagato the rinnegan, which was proven to be a lie because nagato was a child before obito was born so its impossible that obito gave him the rinnegan. Madara said he unlocked rinnegan shortly before his death, but he has never said that he gave nagato the rinnegan. He only expected Nagato to revive him. There is no manga page where Madara says he gave nagato the Rinnegan. So everyone who keeps making statements that madara gave nagato the rinnegan is false because there is no manga pages to prove it. The only valid statement we can make is that Madara met Nagato before he died. And Madara most likely introduced Obito to Nagato. That is it.

 

[Simple Math]

agreed ^^ made a theory about this

 

[OnPoint]

Tobi claimed that he was the one who gave Nagato the Rinnegan, but Obito was

You must be registered for see links

to be the real Madara Uchiha when he said that; so how does Obito being younger than Nagato prove anything?

 

[SeriouslyNO]

You must be registered for see links

Read abit, i might answered your questions with proof,

 

[Midday]

Madara said he awakened rinnengan before just before his death,

You must be registered for see links

. Nagato gained his rinnegan before Madara's death by a few years.

Nagato was Jiriya's first student so he has to be at least Minato's age. Minato at that point was an adults and would be at least 5+ years (so he's 18 as Obito was 13) older than Obito, Nagato must of had rinnengan a few years before

You must be registered for see links

point in time. 5+ years isn't shortly before someone's death.

 

[10023213]

Madara said he awakened rinnengan before just before his death,

You must be registered for see links

. Nagato gained his rinnegan before his death.

Nagato was Jiriya's first student so he has to be at least Minato's age. Minato at that point was an adults and would be at least 5+ years (so he's 18 as Obito was 13) older than Obito, Nagato must of had rinnengan a few years before

You must be registered for see links

point in time. 5+ years isn't shortly before someone's death.

he didn't gain it because he was about to die, he gained it because he saw his parents die
i agree with the rest though

 

[Midday]

he didn't gain it because he was about to die, he gained it because he saw his parents die
i agree with the rest though

I was talking about him getting rinnengan before Madara's death, so I agree with you. I cleared up my post a little.

 

[Gryphus]

he didn't gain it because he was about to die, he gained it because he saw his parents die
i agree with the rest though

He is right, Madara awakened the rinnegan right before his death, but Nagato had them at least 5 years before Madara saved Obito, because Nagato is older than Obito, at least that's how I see it :S

 

[Champ]

Everyone knows Obito was speakin thru Madara as medium. Just like he said Rinne tensei was supposed to be used on me, and Madara confirmed that it was supposed to revive him

 

[MickNerks]

Tobi claimed that he was the one who gave Nagato the Rinnegan, but Obito was

You must be registered for see links

to be the real Madara Uchiha when he said that; so how does Obito being younger than Nagato prove anything?

Because if Madara gained the rinnegan before his death, then he had saved obtio and trained him which took at least a year or more. Nagato had the rinnegan as a kid during the second shinobi war. Obito hadnt been born yet, thus madara wasnt close to death because he died after he saved and trained obito. Thus madara didnt give nagato his rinnegan. Plus madara hasnt made one statement recognizing the fact that nagato had his eyes.

 

[9tailsJinchuuriki]

Everyone knows edo tensei revives the person exactly as the person died. So if Madara gave the rinnegan to Nagato and somehow survived by switching his eyes with other sharingan, he would've came back with just the sharingan. So Nagato awakened the Rinnegan.

 

[Gryphus]

Everyone knows edo tensei revives the person exactly as the person died. So if Madara gave the rinnegan to Nagato and somehow survived by switching his eyes with other sharingan, he would've came back with just the sharingan. So Nagato awakened the Rinnegan.

That is not exactly true, you just have to look at Madara and you will see that its totally possible to modify the body/revert it back to a previous state
I do find the trasplant thing contradictory btw

 

[9tailsJinchuuriki]

Kabuto said he modified it yes, but that doesn't mean he re-awakened Madara's rinnegan. Kabuto didn't even know Madara had the rinnegan until he used it

 

[OnPoint]

Because if Madara gained the rinnegan before his death, then he had saved obtio and trained him which took at least a year or more. Nagato had the rinnegan as a kid during the second shinobi war. Obito hadnt been born yet, thus madara wasnt close to death because he died after he saved and trained obito. Thus madara didnt give nagato his rinnegan. Plus madara hasnt made one statement recognizing the fact that nagato had his eyes.

'Shortly' is a vague term. He gave Nagato his eyes and lived to meet Obito.

 

[Sentinelsgalore]

Kabuto said he modified it yes, but that doesn't mean he re-awakened Madara's rinnegan. Kabuto didn't even know Madara had the rinnegan until he used it

I believe Madara gave Nagato the ability to awaken the rinnegan, I dont think he literally gave him his eye's. Similar to how Itachi gave Sasuke the ability to awaken his mangekyou. Thus, Madara still had his eyes when he died.

 

[Zato]

If Madara died old then don't you think that when he was to be revived by Nagato that he would be old again? Edo tensei revives you back to the way you were before you died. Madara was brought back young, the only that Kabuto did was improve the Hashirama cells within him or added to him or w/e. If he could improve people's Edo's and make them younger or what not then how come he couldn't improve Nagato? Nagato was still drained and his legs were still damaged from his fight with Hanzou. Kabuto stated that he feared Nagato lacked mobility so if that was the case then why not fix it if he could? Because I highly doubt he could.

 

[TrollingSage]

'Shortly' is a vague term. He gave Nagato his eyes and lived to meet Obito.

So why does he still have his eyes when he saved Obito?

 

[Stark]

We can't believe everything Obito says, he said he was Madara..