[Photoshop] Made For Req - Opinions and CnC please :)

[Cascade]

So i made these with a render i was given, i would really like your opinions
Thanks!

avatar

Spoiler

You must be registered for see links

​

Signature

Spoiler

You must be registered for see links

​

Opinions please i havent included a text version because they requested without XD

 

[Kettei]

The avatar is really good but the sig is kinda plain.

 

[Cascade]

The avatar is really good but the sig is kinda plain.

if i had of included text - it would have filled the part when it is 'plain' (right around the light source)

 

[gordo1]

The avatar is awesome and the sig is good.

 

[zoezoe]

nice!
+rrep

 

[Naruto UzRinneganMaki]

HATE THE fractal on the avatar. kills it.

Signature is terrible.

Good job

 

[Cascade]

HATE THE fractal on the avatar. kills it.

Signature is terrible.

Good job

rather than just insulting, how about you offer some advice on how to fix or improve my gfx,

what is wrong with the signature for example, how would you fix it. stop being lazy.

 

[Third Sage]

Signature looks too empty, but I guess it'd be another story with the text included. Also, I personally dislike blue themes but if I didn't, I'd say this is great work.