Preta can absorb any ninjutsu? Really?

[Exaar]

Perta can just suck the chakra out of Mokuton, without chakra it cannot move it would just turn into a useless chunk of wood.

Same goes for doton, without chakra the rocks would just crumble and fall aprt since it's chakra that is holding them together and giving it life.

Also wasn't Jman's oil a "solid material"?, preta path also absorbed it with no problems.

 

[SasukeTheViper EMS]

Nice Thread man ...+rep , makes alot of sense !

 

[Dantee]

Hyperbole in the Db.

 

[Flame Alchemist]

no there are points you are wrong.
the technique isn't always active. that part is as you said. you need to activate a technique to absorb it. so if you catch the user off-guard you can hit him with a ninjutsu.
but I don't know if there is an interval between using it a second time.

however it can absorb solid things as long as it's infused with chakra.

example:

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

he did absorb a huge amount of liquid. and liquid is also a matter with mass and volume

 

[Dunmire66]

I think people are mistaking. The sealing jutsu Preta absorb in-coming attacks. So what i mean is that, if an attack touches the user before he activates Preta, he can't absorb it. That's why Madaras clone weren't able to absorb the last Jinton attack made by Onoki before protecting himself after with Perfect Susanoo. He said himself that cuz the clones were protected by Susanoo, he didn't had time to use Preta to absorb it. It's also the reason why Nagato couldn't absorb Amaterasu. There is a radius were the jutsu is activated and that help to absorb all ninjutsus.

Also, people believe that Preta absorb every type of ninjutsus, which is somehow true, but what they failed to realise is that Preta is not absorbing the ninjutsu itself, but it absorbs the chakra used in the ninjutsu, and that's why the jutsu vanished.

So for people saying that Preta could absorb things like Mokuton, or Madaras meteor, or even doton techniques, it's wrong, cuz eventhough it's a ninjutsu, it creates solid material in a large scale, so Preta would have difficulties to absorb the chakra in the technique. And at that time, the user will receive the damage of the solid/physical technique

That's why Preta would be useless against such techniques, at least it's what i think

No madara says he let the Minton hit him so the gokage would see hashiramas face on his chest

 

[Dantee]

Actually we are not sure if the meteor is even made of chakra but I get your point.

 

[iSpeak]

Absorbing all jutsu's is just a hyperbole. Preta Path's ability is that it can absorb any form of chakra.
Mokuton would get absorbed, since it is still made from chakra (with the exception of the Mokuton clone and a couple Mokuton variants). I have the official translated 3rd databook for proof.
Doton techniques which are made from chakra would get absorbed, but doton techniques that manipulate already existing earth cant.
I don't know about Madara's meteor.

 

[Bogard]

however it can absorb solid things as long as it's infused with chakra.

example:

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

he did absorb a huge amount of liquid. and liquid is also a matter with mass and volume

Like i've said,

Also, people believe that Preta absorb every type of ninjutsus, which is somehow true, but what they failed to realise is that Preta is not absorbing the ninjutsu itself, but it absorbs the chakra used in the ninjutsu, and that's why the jutsu vanished.

He absorbed the chakra in the oil and that's why the oil vanished, but against solid attacks like Mokuton or doton jutsus, what i'm saying is that the time he wants to absorb the chakra in the jutsu, he will receive the physical damage in the contrary of oil which is liquid. That's why using Preta there would be a great mistake

 

[OnPoint]

False, it can absorb Mokuton, which remains entirely chakra based. With regards to the Meteor, the technique used was Banshou Tenin, so of course it wouldn't be able to absorb the rock. Doton techniques can be absorbed if new earth is created with the user's chakra, not if the user's chakra is used to manipulate already existing earth. If this is the case, then only the chakra in the Doton technique will be absorbed, so the user will no longer be able to manipulate the earth. It could absorb Amaterasu if it activated in time.

It's true that the user must manually activate the absorbtion seal, although you were wrong in claiming that it couldn't absorb certain jutsus.

 

[fastrthnwind]

False, it can absorb Mokuton, which remains entirely chakra based. With regards to the Meteor, the technique used was Banshou Tenin, so of course it wouldn't be able to absorb the rock. Doton techniques can be absorbed if new earth is created with the user's chakra, not if the user's chakra is used to manipulate already existing earth. If this is the case, then only the chakra in the Doton technique will be absorbed, so the user will no longer be able to manipulate the earth. It could absorb Amaterasu if it activated in time.

It's true that the user must manually activate the absorbtion seal, although you were wrong in claiming that it couldn't absorb certain jutsus.

Care to explain why it can absorb certain jutsus? What types are you referring to? Just out of curiosity

 

[OnPoint]

Care to explain why it can't absorb certain jutsus? Just out of curiosity

Did you read my post?

 

[Flame Alchemist]

Like i've said, He absorbed the chakra in the oil and that's why the oil vanished, but against solid attacks like Mokuton or doton jutsus, what i'm saying is that the time he wants to absorb the chakra in the jutsu, he will receive the physical damage in the contrary of oil which is liquid. That's why using Preta there would be a great mistake

they are also made of chakra.

most of mokuton techniques create wood and manipulate it. so mokuton would be absorbed.
some doton techniques only change the shape of the earth within the area. they won't be absorbed but there are techniques where you create earth. and they will get absorbed

 

[fastrthnwind]

Did you read my post?

Yes I did.

Everything he said was fine.

 

[OnPoint]

Yes I did.

Everything he said was fine.

So what did you disagree with from my initial post? Because that was correct.

 

[Hakymaru]

Nice theory @poster +Rep

 

[fastrthnwind]

So what did you disagree with from my initial post? Because that was correct.

you were wrong in claiming that it couldn't absorb certain jutsus.

That one right there. I didn't get it.

 

[iSpeak]

Like i've said, He absorbed the chakra in the oil and that's why the oil vanished, but against solid attacks like Mokuton or doton jutsus, what i'm saying is that the time he wants to absorb the chakra in the jutsu, he will receive the physical damage in the contrary of oil which is liquid. That's why using Preta there would be a great mistake

Many people don't seem to understand how nature manipulation works.
They are simply moulding and manipulating their chakra into an element, giving it the same properties as that element. So Every part of it is still chakra. Whether it is solid, liquid or gas. You cannot make a real life element (such as real water) out of chakra alone. It will always be chakra, meaning it will all be absorbed. You can only give it life like properties (through Yang), but it would still be chakra made.
Manipulating natural made elements are a different story though.

 

[SSW Imp]

Very good explanation

 

[Bogard]

they are also made of chakra.

most of mokuton techniques create wood and manipulate it. so mokuton would be absorbed.
some doton techniques only change the shape of the earth within the area. they won't be absorbed but there are techniques where you create earth. and they will get absorbed

Not saying he can't absorb chakra in Mokuton/doton, but that the time he wants to absorb chakra in the Mokuton technique, he will receive the physical damage of the jutsu since Mokuton or doton creates physical things in the contrary of oil or water which are liquid, so no need to worry about

 

[OnPoint]

That one right there. I didn't get it.

Er, he said that it couldn't absorb Mokuton or certain Doton techniques, which is totally incorrect.