vUmbrav
Member
- Joined
- Jul 20, 2012
- Messages
- 50
- Reaction score
- 7
In light of the recent thread about failed information on Tobi not being Obito I have created a list of facts that COMPLETELY disprove the theory that Tobi could be Obito. I have also made a list that suggest the information is inconsistent with Obito being Tobi, but still don't completely disprove. I will add more as more information is revealed. Also post other facts that I may have missed and I will add them to the list.
Undeniable Facts
1. Tobi has been revealed to be an old man. Obito is Kakashi's age. Kakashi is not an old man. Therefore Obito is not an old man. So Obito cannot be Tobi.
2. Tobi fought with the fourth Hokage Minato just a few years after Obito supposedly died during Kyuubi attack. Obito was still a child during that part of history while Tobi was an adult, this also goes hand in hand with #1.
3. Tobi claims to have given the Rinnegan to Nagato as a child and that it was originally "his" (referring to Tobi). Nagato was born many years before Obito was born. So Obito could not have given Nagato the Rinnegan.
Facts that don't Completely Disprove the Theory
1. Obito was crushed by a rock and presumed dead, so Obito cannot be Tobi.
2. Obito had just awakened his Sharingan and was still in the process of training to become a great ninja yet he was able to go toe-to-toe with his own sensei Minato in only a couple of years.
3. Tobi controlled the Kyuubi with his Sharingan. Tobi also knew about the requirements necessary to release a Bijuu from its host, including when is the best time to do so. Obito could not have obtained all of this information in such a short time. Especially considering his Sharingan eye was crushed and the other one gone, so he could not have read the Uchiha tablet.
4. Tobi controlled the fourth Mizukage Yagura through genjutsu. This is an inconsistency with timeline and talent.
Undeniable Facts
1. Tobi has been revealed to be an old man. Obito is Kakashi's age. Kakashi is not an old man. Therefore Obito is not an old man. So Obito cannot be Tobi.
2. Tobi fought with the fourth Hokage Minato just a few years after Obito supposedly died during Kyuubi attack. Obito was still a child during that part of history while Tobi was an adult, this also goes hand in hand with #1.
3. Tobi claims to have given the Rinnegan to Nagato as a child and that it was originally "his" (referring to Tobi). Nagato was born many years before Obito was born. So Obito could not have given Nagato the Rinnegan.
Facts that don't Completely Disprove the Theory
1. Obito was crushed by a rock and presumed dead, so Obito cannot be Tobi.
2. Obito had just awakened his Sharingan and was still in the process of training to become a great ninja yet he was able to go toe-to-toe with his own sensei Minato in only a couple of years.
3. Tobi controlled the Kyuubi with his Sharingan. Tobi also knew about the requirements necessary to release a Bijuu from its host, including when is the best time to do so. Obito could not have obtained all of this information in such a short time. Especially considering his Sharingan eye was crushed and the other one gone, so he could not have read the Uchiha tablet.
4. Tobi controlled the fourth Mizukage Yagura through genjutsu. This is an inconsistency with timeline and talent.
Last edited:
