EMS Itachi > EMS Madara (No Senju DNA/Edo) --- Discussion

Cascade

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
May 10, 2012
Messages
1,469
Reaction score
327
If Itachi had EMS, would he be stronger than EMS Madara (before he got Senju DNA?) (- this also assumes that he doesn't have EDO)

Itachi:

- So we all know that the fight between Sasuke and Itachi was 'semi-rigged' as Itachi had weakened eyes from using his MS so much. This caused him to cough up blood etc.

- We also know that Itachi 'threw the fight' for Sasuke to win so he would hopefully return to the leaf after claiming vengeance - which never happened. Thus Itachi used the last of his strength to plant an Ameratsu into Sasuke's eyes and give him MS. (Technically, Itachi fought both Sasuke AND Orochimaru during his weakened state)

- He's EXTREMELY Intelligent holding advanced talents and knowledge of Ninjutsu, etc.
Furthermore - Itachi's MS abilities of Ameratsu (flames in a split second) and Tsukuyomi (only need to make eyesight) make him a worthy adversary.
Itachi also has Susano'o and with it the Totsuka Blade AND the Yata Mirror - the sword of ultimate sealing, and the shield of ultimate reflection.

- If it weren't for Itachi's weakness due to overuse of the MS + his willingness to throw the fight for Sasuke, Itachi would have DEFINITELY gained Sasuke's eyes and therefore EMS.
Finally, on top of all of this information, Itachi has revealed himself to know Izanami (and possibly Izanagi?) - which could possibly be spammed if the user had EMS.

Note:(Can Itachi control Kyuubi like Madara?)

Madara:

- Praised to be one of the strongest ninja of his time, his fight with Hashirama was legendary. He controlled the Kyuubi (Not sure if Itachi can even though he has Sharingan) and has the same if not > Itachi's intelligence and tactics.

- Madara is also able to throw (essentially) giant boulders (moons?) onto his opponents - even without use of Senju DNA.

- I believe we are yet to see Madara's regular MS techniques (the equivalent of Itachi's Tsukuyomi and Ameratsu) which would most likely be badass.

- Has Ultimate Susano'o - perfect form - which has yet to be achieved by Itachi + the Rennigan, keep in mind that without Senju DNA - he is unable to use Mokuton Clones / ANY Forest techniques that Hashi would have had.
Note:
(Whether or not his Senju DNA helped him achieve Rennigan is yet to be determined, but it is possible that Senju DNA was NOT required for Rinnegan)

- With all of these abilities - Madara has, EMS, Perfect Susano'o, Kyuubi Control, Rinnigan (and that ability of the paths) + the creation of all things!

So who do you think is the better ninja if Itachi had EMS too, and Madara had no Senju. :shrug:xd:D

Look forward to seeing your response. I think Itachi would trump him :)
 

EternalRivals

Member
Joined
Apr 17, 2012
Messages
376
Reaction score
12
Itachi is my 2nd fav, but due to Madara's enormous chakra, he owns Itachi
 

Invsblphntm

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
May 23, 2012
Messages
2,658
Reaction score
478
No, Madara was praised as the Uchiha's strongest member even though know one even knew he had the Rinnegan, Itachi would stand a chance, but in the end I believe Madara would win.
 

Wolfang714

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Jul 28, 2011
Messages
1,224
Reaction score
81
Invalid, we haven't seen Madara fight with just EMS
 

dolama

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Dec 27, 2011
Messages
718
Reaction score
109
madara is god and itachi is an ant if u compare them
 

Bigfoot34501

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Oct 24, 2011
Messages
1,488
Reaction score
208
Madara's chakra>Itachi's Intelligence if they both had EMS. The only way Itachi would be better would be if Madara was cocky during the fight and was then outsmarted by Itachi, but I think that Madara could honestly power his way out of anything Itachi throws at him
 

TheSages456

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Aug 23, 2011
Messages
6,551
Reaction score
302
If Itachi had EMS, would he be stronger than EMS Madara (before he got Senju DNA?) (- this also assumes that he doesn't have EDO)

Itachi:

- So we all know that the fight between Sasuke and Itachi was 'semi-rigged' as Itachi had weakened eyes from using his MS so much. This caused him to cough up blood etc.

- We also know that Itachi 'threw the fight' for Sasuke to win so he would hopefully return to the leaf after claiming vengeance - which never happened. Thus Itachi used the last of his strength to plant an Ameratsu into Sasuke's eyes and give him MS. (Technically, Itachi fought both Sasuke AND Orochimaru during his weakened state)

- He's EXTREMELY Intelligent holding advanced talents and knowledge of Ninjutsu, etc.
Furthermore - Itachi's MS abilities of Ameratsu (flames in a split second) and Tsukuyomi (only need to make eyesight) make him a worthy adversary.
Itachi also has Susano'o and with it the Totsuka Blade AND the Yata Mirror - the sword of ultimate sealing, and the shield of ultimate reflection.

- If it weren't for Itachi's weakness due to overuse of the MS + his willingness to throw the fight for Sasuke, Itachi would have DEFINITELY gained Sasuke's eyes and therefore EMS.
Finally, on top of all of this information, Itachi has revealed himself to know Izanami (and possibly Izanagi?) - which could possibly be spammed if the user had EMS.

Note:(Can Itachi control Kyuubi like Madara?)

Madara:

- Praised to be one of the strongest ninja of his time, his fight with Hashirama was legendary. He controlled the Kyuubi (Not sure if Itachi can even though he has Sharingan) and has the same if not > Itachi's intelligence and tactics.

- Madara is also able to throw (essentially) giant boulders (moons?) onto his opponents - even without use of Senju DNA.

- I believe we are yet to see Madara's regular MS techniques (the equivalent of Itachi's Tsukuyomi and Ameratsu) which would most likely be badass.

- Has Ultimate Susano'o - perfect form - which has yet to be achieved by Itachi + the Rennigan, keep in mind that without Senju DNA - he is unable to use Mokuton Clones / ANY Forest techniques that Hashi would have had.
Note:
(Whether or not his Senju DNA helped him achieve Rennigan is yet to be determined, but it is possible that Senju DNA was NOT required for Rinnegan)

- With all of these abilities - Madara has, EMS, Perfect Susano'o, Kyuubi Control, Rinnigan (and that ability of the paths) + the creation of all things!

So who do you think is the better ninja if Itachi had EMS too, and Madara had no Senju. :shrug:xd:D

Look forward to seeing your response. I think Itachi would trump him :)

madara>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>itachi
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
 

Hashirama Senju 48

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Jun 2, 2012
Messages
522
Reaction score
35
If Itachi had EMS, would he be stronger than EMS Madara (before he got Senju DNA?) (- this also assumes that he doesn't have EDO)

Itachi:

- So we all know that the fight between Sasuke and Itachi was 'semi-rigged' as Itachi had weakened eyes from using his MS so much. This caused him to cough up blood etc.

- We also know that Itachi 'threw the fight' for Sasuke to win so he would hopefully return to the leaf after claiming vengeance - which never happened. Thus Itachi used the last of his strength to plant an Ameratsu into Sasuke's eyes and give him MS. (Technically, Itachi fought both Sasuke AND Orochimaru during his weakened state)

- He's EXTREMELY Intelligent holding advanced talents and knowledge of Ninjutsu, etc.
Furthermore - Itachi's MS abilities of Ameratsu (flames in a split second) and Tsukuyomi (only need to make eyesight) make him a worthy adversary.
Itachi also has Susano'o and with it the Totsuka Blade AND the Yata Mirror - the sword of ultimate sealing, and the shield of ultimate reflection.

- If it weren't for Itachi's weakness due to overuse of the MS + his willingness to throw the fight for Sasuke, Itachi would have DEFINITELY gained Sasuke's eyes and therefore EMS.
Finally, on top of all of this information, Itachi has revealed himself to know Izanami (and possibly Izanagi?) - which could possibly be spammed if the user had EMS.

Note:(Can Itachi control Kyuubi like Madara?)

Madara:

- Praised to be one of the strongest ninja of his time, his fight with Hashirama was legendary. He controlled the Kyuubi (Not sure if Itachi can even though he has Sharingan) and has the same if not > Itachi's intelligence and tactics.

- Madara is also able to throw (essentially) giant boulders (moons?) onto his opponents - even without use of Senju DNA.

- I believe we are yet to see Madara's regular MS techniques (the equivalent of Itachi's Tsukuyomi and Ameratsu) which would most likely be badass.

- Has Ultimate Susano'o - perfect form - which has yet to be achieved by Itachi + the Rennigan, keep in mind that without Senju DNA - he is unable to use Mokuton Clones / ANY Forest techniques that Hashi would have had.
Note:
(Whether or not his Senju DNA helped him achieve Rennigan is yet to be determined, but it is possible that Senju DNA was NOT required for Rinnegan)

- With all of these abilities - Madara has, EMS, Perfect Susano'o, Kyuubi Control, Rinnigan (and that ability of the paths) + the creation of all things!

So who do you think is the better ninja if Itachi had EMS too, and Madara had no Senju. :shrug:xd:D

Look forward to seeing your response. I think Itachi would trump him :)

Thats a tough question.... But I have to go with Madara, eventhough Itachi is my favourite character.
Madara led the Uchiha in many battles, being the leader of one of the two most powerful clans of his time. We know Itachi's a genius but Madara was the best of the best, considering he had the Mongekyo and alot of chakra.
 

Cascade

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
May 10, 2012
Messages
1,469
Reaction score
327
madara>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>itachi
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images

You've given proof of Madara's power but not of Itachi's, Bias much?
 

Bogard

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Apr 7, 2012
Messages
21,914
Reaction score
2,378
Itachi's problem is not MS or EMS, but chakra. With plenty of chakra, even with MS, i think he could beat EMS Madara
 

Hinata0

Member
Joined
Jun 5, 2012
Messages
30
Reaction score
0
Nooooop, Madara would easily beat Itachi, have you seen him in the war????
 

Stark

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
May 13, 2012
Messages
16,922
Reaction score
1,206
We haven't seen Madara fight only with EMS, so we can't say anything now
 

Hinata0

Member
Joined
Jun 5, 2012
Messages
30
Reaction score
0
Staarkk is right, how can we know what hes like without Senju, but what about that clip from generations????? i think he had EMS then without Senju DNA and he lost to Hashirama theere, so Itachi over hashirama?
 

Cascade

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
May 10, 2012
Messages
1,469
Reaction score
327
What are you talking about, if Madara lost to Hashi, then if Itachi > Madara doesnt mean Itachi>Hashi.
 
Top