Uchiha rebellion.. How would this have gone?

[ReLax -]

Ch-144 pg 8... Yea you lost all credibility. Also you act like hiruzen is the only good ninja.... Yea also i set the scenario... so you need to read the thread too.. This alone proves you wrong.
Kisame - You could somehow win, but I couldn't stand up to such an opponent for more than a couple of minutes... It's on a completely different level.
Itachi - Ah... Either (we) both (he says both/two, meaning him and Kisame) would die, or it would be a draw... The result wouldn't change even if we increased our numbers.
Kisame - It was good that we found him at the ramen shop... And he has one of the Legendary Sannin as a lucky charm. That guy (Jiraiya) might be a fair match for the strongest Uchiha from Konoha and the Mist's strongest swordsman.
Itachi - Hmm, even so... It's said that every strong man has a weakness..

That line doesn't even exist on this site manga.

You must be registered for see links

I think you lost all credibility.

I'm betting Itachi and Shisui weren't the only strongest Uchiha out of the clan.

So, you indicate that the Sannin were there, but yet we don't have any confirmation on that. As far as I know all the Sannin were away from the village, Oro = Missing Nin, Tsunade = Dan/brother death, and Jiraiya = finding peace/spying on Akatsuki. So, I doubt they were there, I barely seen Jiraiya stay at the village he usually took Naruto and left on some journey.

tachi also used his weakness. (Girls girls girls) in a genjutsu on a girl to distract jman... But this was years after the killing of the clan in which i am sure he got stronger. So there you have it. Jman= Kisame and itachi at this point in time and in MY scenario jman is in the village...

And what does that prove again? Didn't Jman catch Itachi and Kisame in the toads belly indicating no one ever escaped it, but yet itachi got out with ease?

 

[Sonin]

That line doesn't even exist on this site manga.

You must be registered for see links

I think you lost all credibility.

I'm betting Itachi and Shisui weren't the only strongest Uchiha out of the clan.

So, you indicate that the Sannin were there, but yet we don't have any confirmation on that. As far as I know all the Sannin were away from the village, Oro = Missing Nin, Tsunade = Dan/brother death, and Jiraiya = finding peace/spying on Akatsuki. So, I doubt they were there, I barely seen Jiraiya stay at the village he usually took Naruto and left on some journey.



And what does that prove again? Didn't Jman catch Itachi and Kisame in the toads belly indicating no one ever escaped it, but yet itachi got out with ease?

With ease using Ameratersu draining A SHIT TON of chakra.. Also it was in the anime which is still credible.

THIS IS MY SCENARIO: i said the sanin meaning Tsunade and Jman are both there. I didn't say the WERE. But in this debate they are.

 

[Sonin]

That line doesn't even exist on this site manga.

You must be registered for see links

I think you lost all credibility.

I'm betting Itachi and Shisui weren't the only strongest Uchiha out of the clan.

So, you indicate that the Sannin were there, but yet we don't have any confirmation on that. As far as I know all the Sannin were away from the village, Oro = Missing Nin, Tsunade = Dan/brother death, and Jiraiya = finding peace/spying on Akatsuki. So, I doubt they were there, I barely seen Jiraiya stay at the village he usually took Naruto and left on some journey.



And what does that prove again? Didn't Jman catch Itachi and Kisame in the toads belly indicating no one ever escaped it, but yet itachi got out with ease?

The discussion on that page was elongated in the anime in which itachi went on to describe the scenario. If you want the episode i will give it to you.

 

[Satsujinki]

In case this is a mass battle vs thread, then I'm not participating, but if solely a "What if"...

There were ongoing negotiations with the Uchiha... You have to consider the possibility of them simply walking out of the village and either forming their own, or joining another. Of course, the Konoha likely wouldn't be alright with that, considering that the Uchiha were privy to a lot of Konoha's secrets... I don't think they were really interested in a coup, they were obviously flexing their muscles in order to get better leverage on the deal, but I don't think they could take on the entire village...

In this case, you have the following two scenarios:

a) They were planning to go all-out against Konoha... Which leads to...
a1) They actually HAD the muscle to win
a2) They wouldn't mind going to their graves as free man
a3) Neither, but they were hoping to, amidst the likely 4th Shinobi World War, make the most of what they stirred

and...

b) They'd rather leave on bad terms

I'm not sure what to think... The whole Uchiha massacre seems not to make much sense.

 

[alakai200]

We all know Tobi mentioned why Itachi eliminated his clan.. Say he didn't do that and he fought with them... How would the leaf war go. I want support and thought. Relevance of time and powers. The sanin are in the village. Do not bring up Yata or the Sword(Itachi's) because i dont think he had that at this time.. But yes have fun. Be creative and think of how it would pan out..

I think the authority of the leaf would suppress the rebellion with a LOT of casualties but i would like to hear what everyone has to say ..

Also if the 4th was still around i think they would have completely said nah... *(Fanboy... just a little)

It would have ended terribly, the Uchiha Clan still would have been decimated. I think if the 4th was still alive they might have pushed to have an Uchiha be next in line to be Hokage, like Itachi.

 

[Cataclysm]

The End.

 

[Totsuka No Tsurugi]

The Uchiha would lose. Sure they're a powerful clan, but not nearly powerful enough to take on an entire village.

Had Minato been alive the coup never would've happened or been planned considering Minato could've cleared the Uchiha from any suspicion of the kyuubi incident.

agree with this, minato is the key for that misunderstanding yet he died before he can reveal what exactly happened that night, even minato don't know how bad could it be

 

[Big bengi]

The uchiha would win. Manipulating all bijuu, animal summons n dropping them on the leaf.
The konoha higher ups knew this. Thats why they did what they did. Shit there are only two uchihas left but look at what they are doing to the rest of the ninja would.

 

[Sonin]

The uchiha would win. Manipulating all bijuu, animal summons n dropping them on the leaf.
The konoha higher ups knew this. Thats why they did what they did. Shit there are only two uchihas left but look at what they are doing to the rest of the ninja would.

All bijuu???? There is only the nine tails at this point and to manipulated they would have to unseal him which was not stated that they could. Do you have any proof of summons?

 

[obscoral]

uchihas would rape the WoF out of sleeping konoha
and slaughter majority of fodders (genin/chuunin/jonin/elite)
but finally they would have been exhausted and got overwhelmed by konoha forces

 

[Retsu]

it would've gone horrible, other villages would converge in the chaos kidnapping konoha ppl to learn their jutsu's, think hyuuga incident times 9000

 

[Sonin]

uchihas would rape the WoF out of sleeping konoha
and slaughter majority of fodders (genin/chuunin/jonin/elite)
but finally they would have been exhausted and got overwhelmed by konoha forces

That is how i forsee it.

 

[Kyrik]

Yeah, the Uchiha would have lost ultimately sure they're strong but they couldn't have beaten the entire leaf village.