Manga-Canon Snobs Irritate Me

[Tangerine]

made a whole fking bigger then Odama rasengan does lol

Good grief. xd

 

[sG Taka]

Yea but I don't understand

Who decides whats acceptable and what's not?

If we allow this then vs threads turn into going from about the two opponents

To if this feat should be counted or is this allowed

It'd be chaos

People should try to just follow the Narutoverse logic as much as they can..dunno, I guess it'd be pretty hard but meh, I just don't like Manga snobs.

"OMG that's non-canon are you retarded?"

 

[Reborn]

I mean if we do that then we have to accept

Shino has better taijutsu in part 1 then hinata

Shadow clones can go rogue

Konohamaru rasengan is stronger then minato and jman and narutos

Theres a little kid that can scream and controls bijuus

Theres a kid for tobi to get 9 tail chakra from at the temple in sora

akamaru is soo weak he cant beat pakun

You see where this is going lol

sG I can't rep you but know that i agree 100%

Better: The way shino fought against that shinobi, could hardly be considered better tai then Hinata's in the filler, shadow clones went rouge in Naruto's dream any sort of thing can happen in a dream

And everything else you said could be considered as it's not unlikely, that girl could have special powers, it's within the context of the realm of the narutoverse as it's been done before. It wasn't like she had Hashirama's powers or anything like that shit and she went off like that. Sora situation is believable wouldn't you say, I mean the KinGin were Pseudo's as well why couldn't Sora be one?

Most definatly I do believe Kakashi's 9 dogs could wash Kiba and Akamaru, and if you haven't forgot, they won in the end so I don't see you're point really. first off they're out numbered, they're like the K9 unit of hounds and they are Kakashi's trusted summons so you wouldn't expect them to have some bite in them? Even with the Inuzukas. Not to mention Kiba and Akamaru are still like puppies if you think about it, they're still rash or whatever, hell, Akamaru is more mature then Kiba I would say.

What sG is saying is so long as the stuff isn't so far unbelievable for the realm Kishi has put out there, it should be considered valid, and because it's not 100% Kishi, it's still Naruto so why can't it be considered valid in the Naruto Discussions when it's still Naruto?!


I'm going to use anime-crap in the next vs thread I can and I'm not going to let what anybody else say stop me from using it as valid info. sG you don't even know how tired I am of hearing "It's not in the manga so it doesn't exist" I'm with you

 

[Tangerine]

People should try to just follow the Narutoverse logic as much as they can..dunno, I guess it'd be pretty hard but meh, I just don't like Manga snobs.

"OMG that's non-canon are you retarded?"

Anime snobs are far worse than manga snobs. The former is much more active than the later.

As snobbish as the manga only members can be they have a point: anime is non-canon.

Sticking to "manga is canon" is far easier than trying to argue with someone what Narutoverse logic is.

 

[Orochimaruwantsyourbody]

So essentially this thread was just pointing out that Anime Kakashi is verified in VT,but not other filler feats?​

 

[EliteKakashi]

The only issue is where you draw the line from "realistic" and "that'd never happen in the manga". It would all be based on opinion, and you would have to specify in said thread where you draw the line, and that would be pretty hard to define.

 

[kaka96]

Good grief. xd

I meant "hole" but I think you got that

 

[Better]

People should try to just follow the Narutoverse logic as much as they can..dunno, I guess it'd be pretty hard but meh, I just don't like Manga snobs.

"OMG that's non-canon are you retarded?"

Yea I mean some people get mad over it, idk.y its an honest mistake

if you go by just manga feats everyone can follow this

But if you combine manga and anime...

Will get threads like "does this count.." Or " is ranmaru dojutsu a real one?"

It'd be crazier then it is now

 

[sG Taka]

So essentially this thread was just pointing out that Anime Kakashi is verified in VT,but not other filler feats?​

I'd call you retarded, but then you would go cry to your mod friend.

What you said was an example. The point of this thread was to see if people agree with my point of view. What's my point of view? Re-read the title post and see if you can figure that much on your own, you little pony you.

If this was a facetious post, you fail.

sG I can't rep you but know that i agree 100%

Better: The way shino fought against that shinobi, could hardly be considered better tai then Hinata's in the filler, shadow clones went rouge in Naruto's dream any sort of thing can happen in a dream

And everything else you said could be considered as it's not unlikely, that girl could have special powers, it's within the context of the realm of the narutoverse as it's been done before. It wasn't like she had Hashirama's powers or anything like that shit and she went off like that. Sora situation is believable wouldn't you say, I mean the KinGin were Pseudo's as well why couldn't Sora be one?

Most definatly I do believe Kakashi's 9 dogs could wash Kiba and Akamaru, and if you haven't forgot, they won in the end so I don't see you're point really. first off they're out numbered, they're like the K9 unit of hounds and they are Kakashi's trusted summons so you wouldn't expect them to have some bite in them? Even with the Inuzukas. Not to mention Kiba and Akamaru are still like puppies if you think about it, they're still rash or whatever, hell, Akamaru is more mature then Kiba I would say.

What sG is saying is so long as the stuff isn't so far unbelievable for the realm Kishi has put out there, it should be considered valid, and because it's not 100% Kishi, it's still Naruto so why can't it be considered valid in the Naruto Discussions when it's still Naruto?!


I'm going to use anime-crap in the next vs thread I can and I'm not going to let what anybody else say stop me from using it as valid info. sG you don't even know how tired I am of hearing "It's not in the manga so it doesn't exist" I'm with you

Well, great minds think alike No, but thanks for agreeing and for providing interesting examples.

 

[Universal Enlightenment]

You know how many time they've recycled similar materials from fillers to the manga you really don't think it's kishimoto's doing ???


Fuuma Ninken � Zanbatou - Fuuma Ninja Sword � Zanbatou & Darui

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

Sora & Danzou Wind Element

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

Ikadzuchi no Kiba - Lightning Bolt Fang & Sasuke Kirin

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

Raiton Armor

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

When did manga said they were only 3 dojutsu? I though it just said that those 3 were known as the great three

my point exactly plus the manga said that the sharingan came from the Byakugan and we all know that's a line lmao there's has to be more powerful dojutsu look at the juubi's eyes

You must be registered for see images

Yea I mean some people get mad over it, idk.y its an honest mistake

if you go by just manga feats everyone can follow this

But if you combine manga and anime...

Will get threads like "does this count.." Or " is ranmaru dojutsu a real one?"

It'd be crazier then it is now

But there's a manga section for that they should just keep it over there

 

[Orochimaruwantsyourbody]

Gotta love how you're compelling this.

When I asked the question,I don't mean it to be some form of satirization as you insecure douche prompted.

Anyways, it's been delightful hearing your well thought out posts. I often wonder why we don't share more of the same perception given our similar intellects and mannerisms.​

 

[Better]

sG I can't rep you but know that i agree 100%

Better: The way shino fought against that shinobi, could hardly be considered better tai then Hinata's in the filler, shadow clones went rouge in Naruto's dream any sort of thing can happen in a dream

And everything else you said could be considered as it's not unlikely, that girl could have special powers, it's within the context of the realm of the narutoverse as it's been done before. It wasn't like she had Hashirama's powers or anything like that shit and she went off like that. Sora situation is believable wouldn't you say, I mean the KinGin were Pseudo's as well why couldn't Sora be one?

Most definatly I do believe Kakashi's 9 dogs could wash Kiba and Akamaru, and if you haven't forgot, they won in the end so I don't see you're point really. first off they're out numbered, they're like the K9 unit of hounds and they are Kakashi's trusted summons so you wouldn't expect them to have some bite in them? Even with the Inuzukas. Not to mention Kiba and Akamaru are still like puppies if you think about it, they're still rash or whatever, hell, Akamaru is more mature then Kiba I would say.

What sG is saying is so long as the stuff isn't so far unbelievable for the realm Kishi has put out there, it should be considered valid, and because it's not 100% Kishi, it's still Naruto so why can't it be considered valid in the Naruto Discussions when it's still Naruto?!


I'm going to use anime-crap in the next vs thread I can and I'm not going to let what anybody else say stop me from using it as valid info. sG you don't even know how tired I am of hearing "It's not in the manga so it doesn't exist" I'm with you

the thing is tho, hinata was overwhelmed lol well i thought it was weird

you don't think added a whole new dojutsu is outside the realm of narutoverse?

i agree with him, but my point was who decides what acceptable and what not?

we'd have threads and posts arguing forever about what should and shouldn't count

 

[Totsuka No Tsurugi]

manga is the only canon material, am sorry but this thread won't change anything

 

[Tangerine]

The way shino fought against that shinobi, could hardly be considered better tai then Hinata's in the filler

If I remember correctly he mangaed to beat her in a spar, improving drastically. Unless I'm wrong. He may not have better Taijutsu in that episode, but it was suggested/shown he could learn better at it than Hinata can.

Sora situation is believable wouldn't you say, I mean the KinGin were Pseudo's as well why couldn't Sora be one?

KinGin and Sora gaining Pseudo Kyubi chakra was done differently from the other. Sora: his father (?) collected leftover Kyubi chakra. KinGin: Ate the meat of Kyubi.
Where was it decided chakra can just be left lying around?

They're like the K9 unit of hounds and they are Kakashi's trusted summons so you wouldn't expect them to have some bite in them?

They're mostly used for tracking, but Kakashi's fight with Zabuza had him use his Nin-dogs to subdue Zabuza. Pakkun admitted to Sakura he wasn't that useful in a fight and as far as I know, the same may be said for the other dogs. I'm sure they're more effective as a pack.

What sG is saying is so long as the stuff isn't so far unbelievable for the realm Kishi has put out there, it should be considered valid, and because it's not 100% Kishi, it's still Naruto so why can't it be considered valid in the Naruto Discussions when it's still Naruto?!

There's the issue with biased people or those in the unknown.

sG you don't even know how tired I am of hearing "It's not in the manga so it doesn't exist" I'm with you

They say that, because it actually doesn't exist.
I'm tired of hearing about anime only members wanting anime to be allowed because it either supports their arguement or because the character they're arguing for hardly has any manga moments.

But if you combine manga and anime...

Holy crap. Could you, for example, imagine Anti Hinata versus Pro Hinata? You'd have Hinata fans arguing mostly based on her anime feats (as her anime self is far better than her manga comparsion) and those who don't like mostly basing her manga moments.
So what do you do? How about a suggestion? Firstly, learn about her manga self before considering what is accepted in the anime. Does it make sense she'd have good Taijutsu? Yes? Good. What about good battle strategry? It wasn't suggested in the manga? Then don't add it.
Same can be said for other characters.

 

[Better]

You know how many time they've recycled similar materials from fillers to the manga you really don't think it's kishimoto's doing ???


Fuuma Ninken � Zanbatou - Fuuma Ninja Sword � Zanbatou & Darui

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

Sora & Danzou Wind Element

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

Ikadzuchi no Kiba - Lightning Bolt Fang & Sasuke Kirin

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

Raiton Armor

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

my point exactly plus the manga said that the sharingan came from the Byakugan and we all know that's a line lmao there's has to be more powerful dojutsu look at the juubi's eyes

You must be registered for see images

But there's a manga section for that they should just keep it over there

so there should be two vs thread forums?

 

[sG Taka]

manga is the only canon material, am sorry but this thread won't change anything

Close minded people should stay in Church.

So what do you do? How about a suggestion? Firstly, learn about her manga self before considering what is accepted in the anime. Does it make sense she'd have good Taijutsu? Yes? Good. What about good battle strategry? It wasn't suggested in the manga? Then don't add it.
Same can be said for other characters.

Good example.

 

[Totsuka No Tsurugi]

Close minded people should stay in Church.

i came here nicely and yet u reply like that ? LOL

if u want to complain go cry to kishimoto since he's the one who decided everything

 

[Universal Enlightenment]

i came here nicely and yet u reply like that ? LOL

if u want to complain go cry to kishimoto since he's the one who decided everything

And your point is???

so there should be two vs thread forums?

Now your just be ridiculous lmao

 

[sG Taka]

i came here nicely and yet u reply like that ? LOL

if u want to complain go cry to kishimoto since he's the one who decided everything

You came to this thread with an already existing point of view and stated that no matter what this thread established, you would ignore it and continue with your same point.

And your point is???

I wonder myself.. lol

 

[Totsuka No Tsurugi]

And your point is???

manga is the only canon material, if u don't agree go cry to kishimoto

You came to this thread with an already existing point of view and stated that no matter what this thread established, you would ignore it and continue with your same point.

why should i change my perspective ? i state that cause that was the right thing to do, considering something beside manga pages as canon material can only be done by the author himself, not you.