Is Sasuke right in seeking revenge against Konoha or not?

[Oxide]

-Please don't use this thread to bash Sasuke (or other characters)!
-Be nice to each other!
-Have fun while posting and reading!

The elders of Konoha (Koharu and Komura currently) deserve everything Sasuke plans to do to them. Danzou and Sarutobi already payed for their crimes. Even trough the elders were partly right in trying to stop the Uchiha's (their succeeding would have caused even more bloodshed then the death of the Uchiha clan), it was wrong of them to kill every member of the clan, especially the children (Sasuke's age or younger) at the time.
So while Sasuke has the right to seek revenge against the elders, he does not have the right to seek revenge against the Konoha as a whole.
His line that they all deserve to die because they are laughing and are enjoying the peace Itachi created is absurd.

Him wanting Kurenai's son dead (just because he was born in Konoha) is just a proof that Sasuke doesn't think rationally anymore and that he is blinded by hatred and his thirst for blood.

 

[Lord Snow]

Yes i think he is right, i would do the same thing

 

[Kianto]

Agree + rep

 

[Oxide]

Sasuke's revenge isn't justifiable, but not irrational either. The elders decided to kill those who were weak and innocent amongst the Uchiha, not just the ones responsible for the planned rebellion. Since the elders killed all Uchiha indiscriminately, the only equivalent revenge is to kill all konoha equally indiscriminately. An eye for an eye, is what Sasuke wants. Just as the Elders took everything from him, so he wishes to destroy everything they wanted to protect.It might not be fair on those innocent people simply living their lives, but that's the fate the elders carved out for them with their act of genocide. To think they would get away with such a crime is what is irrational. Sasuke is entirely the consequence to their deeds.Sasuke is wrong, at least on a moral level, and he may have been driven mad, but the revenge itself isn't irrational. *soooooo Idk..

 

[Black Adam]

-Please don't use this thread to bash Sasuke (or other characters)!
-Be nice to each other!
-Have fun while posting and reading!

The elders of Konoha (Koharu and Komura currently) deserve everything Sasuke plans to do to them. Danzou and Sarutobi already payed for their crimes. Even trough the elders were partly right in trying to stop the Uchiha's (their succeeding would have caused even more bloodshed then the death of the Uchiha clan), it was wrong of them to kill every member of the clan, especially the children (Sasuke's age or younger) at the time.
So while Sasuke has the right to seek revenge against the elders, he does not have the right to seek revenge against the Konoha as a whole.
His line that they all deserve to die because they are laughing and are enjoying the peace Itachi created is absurd.

Him wanting Kurenai's son dead (just because he was born in Konoha) is just a proof that Sasuke doesn't think rationally anymore and that he is blinded by hatred and his thirst for blood.

/Thread

 

[Illyasviel]

he should only kill the elders which I think he will do but will fight the rest of konoha

 

[sG Taka]

It's understandable, not right.

 

[kaka96]

When his objective was the elders, it was okay, but now he wants to kill people who had nothing to do with the events that happened therefore, his plan is to kill thousands of innocent people and that is in no way okay

And what crimes are you referring to with Sarutobi? his only mistake was with Orochimaru

 

[Roofy128]

no

 

[XMrLiNdOrX]

Eradication of the elders shuld b sufficient.

 

[YoItsJo]

He's right to seek revenge against the Elders. He isn't right to wanna go on a killing spree.

 

[Diottcas]

Not the whole village but those shit stained elders need to die

 

[Reborn]

Na he's not right.

 

[Sage of Infinity Paths]

THat is right!!

 

[XMrLiNdOrX]

But I truely believe if sasuke runs into itachi he will consider going bak to the village, not that he wuld b allowed.

 

[Lord Snow]

The elders wanted the whole uchiha clan gone, why can't sasuke want the whole village that always hated the uchiha gone.

 

[Tim Tebow]

It not everyone fault.... So no Sasuke is wrong.

 

[Reborn]

The elders wanted the whole uchiha clan gone, why can't sasuke want the whole village that always hated the uchiha gone.

So, two wrongs make a right?

And in this case there was no wrong done on the side of the village so one wrong makes a right to you?

 

[Blaze Release]

He is in the wrong, but i can understand

 

[Ethylacetat]

Sasuke's revenge isn't justifiable, but not irrational either. The elders decided to kill those who were weak and innocent amongst the Uchiha, not just the ones responsible for the planned rebellion. Since the elders killed all Uchiha indiscriminately, the only equivalent revenge is to kill all konoha equally indiscriminately. An eye for an eye, is what Sasuke wants. Just as the Elders took everything from him, so he wishes to destroy everything they wanted to protect.It might not be fair on those innocent people simply living their lives, but that's the fate the elders carved out for them with their act of genocide. To think they would get away with such a crime is what is irrational. Sasuke is entirely the consequence to their deeds.Sasuke is wrong, at least on a moral level, and he may have been driven mad, but the revenge itself isn't irrational. *soooooo Idk..

but look at it from this side itachi let only one uchiha child alive and it is corruped that much from it hate that just this one litte child puts the village in danger imagin 20 sasuke clones driven from hate seeking revenge and joining oro or following akatsuki... just because the dont eliminate the whole clan just the one that planned a rebellion..