I don't know what your Yin or Yang training was like up until this point. But based on a lot of the customs you've submitted for each field individually, as well as some of your usage, I want to make sure you have a more sound understanding going forward. So I want to know exactly what you think are the limits of each field respectively. What separates Yin-Yang Release from having Yin and Yang Releases? Why is a hyphen and 40,000 Kumi the difference maker in the field's usage?
I'll break it down as best as i can.There is a little more than just Yin-Yang in those Truth-Seeking Orbs that makes them more complex than this. Don't worry about the basic passive benefits right now, either. We'll get to those in a little bit. I'm asking you more about your training in the past. You could answer this question in a single sentence if you wanted. What is Yin-Yang? What happens when, as you say, you achieve 'perfect harmony?' What does perfect harmony mean? You should start by breaking down Yin and Yang as independent fields, totally separate of each other. But we know that this is never truly possible, right? A slight tangent: but why can't Yin and Yang ever be separate? Are there Yin techniques where it is just totally devoid of any Yang/physical energy? And on the other side of that coin, are there Yang techniques totally devoid of Yin?
Indeed not, there are three different types of TSB though. Yin, Yang and the Yin/Yang ones. I think the similarity of the three is that all of them consists of the five elements?There is a little more than just Yin-Yang in those Truth-Seeking Orbs that makes them more complex than this
What is Yin-Yang? What happens when, as you say, you achieve 'perfect harmony?' What does perfect harmony mean?
You should start by breaking down Yin and Yang as independent fields, totally separate of each other. But we know that this is never truly possible, right? A slight tangent: but why can't Yin and Yang ever be separate? Are there Yin techniques where it is just totally devoid of any Yang/physical energy? And on the other side of that coin, are there Yang techniques totally devoid of Yin?
Remember, Yin and Yang (the separated forms) Truth-Seeking Orbs no longer exist in the RP. So don't worry about them in the context of training or how Yin-Yang works. That said, I'm referring to Six Paths Senjutsu; that is a key component in achieving Yin-Yang Truth-Seeking Orbs.
The answer to the question is basically the answer to what separates a Yin Release user from a Yin-Yang Release user. Any Yin Release technique utilizes some level of Yang, and vice versa. For instance, if you look at Change into Hell where do you think the Yin aspect of the technique is? Because, as I think we discussed earlier (or your previous teachers, because if they didn't then they shouldn't be teaching Yin or Yang), there is always a presence of the opposing energy within any technique. This includes Yin or Yang State, the respective pinnacle technique of each field separately. I'll skip to the answer to make it easy: consciousness, imagination, and emotion. That is the Yin within Change into Hell. When you augment an elemental technique with vitality you also grant it a consciousness and mental awareness. It might not literally have a brain, but you've basically given it the ability to think for itself. That is where the Yin comes in - mental. Sound familiar?
That's the key distinction here. A Yang user inadvertently uses Yin to some extent to grant a sentient elemental familiar consciousness. The concept of consciousness is itself Yin - anything related to the spirit, mentality, thinking, etc. A Yin-Yang user on the other hand achieves this not by accident, but by design. They are able to control the other side of the ratio. What other techniques in Yin-Yang see this very clearly. I want you to think on it, because it matters. A wrong answer is fine; but it's important you think about it because this concept is critical to making your YY customs and just in general to how YY works.
So in short, you're right - Yin-Yang is how one "make(s) the combination flow together." But I wanted to add depth to your answer, because this is training and that matters. All this will be, in some form or another, present in the customs you submit. Or it should be; I know I personally pay attention to it when I submit YY customs or check others. And I know that LoK and Daemon look for it as well. That's why the conceptual stuff is really important when it comes to YY. It might seem asinine on its surface but when it comes to creating customs it is of paramount importance. Especially because Yin-Yang as a field has so few canon techniques attached to it.
Now for your last paragraph, because in my infinite wisdom I've typed this as I read your post rather than read it all and then reply - yeah, basically. That's what I reference above. There is no true separation, and this includes thee two States.
So, with all that said we're about ready to move onto techniques. I'll post the first one, but I still want you to answer that question I posed to you earlier. Also please read through the Yin and Yang lists and ask any questions you have on how they work. Anything at all, especially new or edited ones.
(In'yōton, Onmyōton: Chakra no Sōzō) Yin-Yang Release: Chakra Creation
Type: Supplementary
Rank: S-Rank
Range: Short
Chakra: N/A (+300 per turn)
Damage: N/A
Description: A unique ability available only to Yin-Yang masters, Chakra Creation pertains to the ability to focus on ones physical and spiritual energies and draw more from one's essence. This allows the user of the technique to replenish and regenerate a limited amount of chakra. This is done by clapping one's hands and focusing, meditating for a moment.
Note: Must meditate for 1 full turn before ones chakra starts to regenerate[/s]
Alrighty then, big yikes that if a clone disperses and has performed that technique the user will die. Did not at all expect that..So you basically answered your own question. A Yin-Yang Master can control both halves of the ratio. While a Yin user might be able to shift the ratio of their spiritual to physical, which inadvertently lowers their physical energy, a Yin-Yang Master can control both consciously and achieve greater results. Personally, this is why I don't really think the Yin and Yang States being separated and delegated to each energy individually is very accurate. To achieve Yin or Yang State means controlling both sides of the ratio to maximize one without killing yourself. This wouldn't really be possible without having mastered the other half. But that's just a personal gripe.
Yeah, basically. People achieve this mechanism passively. But a Yin-Yang Master can do this consciously, like making their body into a factory rather than just letting it be something that happens organically. It's also faster, considering you gain 300 chakra per turn that you successfully meditate. In the Ninja World passive regeneration manifests at a 10% rate day. That means for most people they only gain back ~160 chakra/24hours. This allows a Yin-Yang Master to regenerate at 300 chakra/45 minutes. That's significantly faster.
As for the clones, the answer is yes. Or at least I think it is. I don't actually use clones in battle because I think they're lame as hell. But one word of caution if you do - when a clone disperses a portion of its chakra returns. If you regenerate a clone's chakra and you exceed your own cap when it returns you will die.
As for the last question - yes. Meditation is more than just not taking damage. It's about clearing one's mind. If you get hit by a boulder and are thrown backwards by it then you won't be meditating anymore. Even if you don't take any damage from the boulder or the impact. It's all based on the circumstances of the situation.
(In'yōton, Onmyōton: Chakra no Jokyo) Yin-Yang Release: Chakra Removal
Type: Supplementary
Rank: S-Rank
Range: Short
Chakra: N/A (-200 per turn)
Damage: N/A
Description: A unique ability available only to Yin-Yang masters, Chakra Removal pertains to the ability to focus on ones physical and spiritual energies and draw in chakra from those nearby. This allows the user of the technique to drain a limited amount of chakra from opponents. This is done by clapping one's hands and focusing, meditating for a moment. After a full turn, a collective max of 200 chakra is drained from those in the landmark per turn for up to 4 turns each. Should one be touched directly, the user doesn't need to meditate.
Note: Must meditate for 2 full turns before ones chakra starts to drain.
Now the opposite.
Alright then, thanks for clearing it up.That passive is probably changing in the future. It's worded so poorly and so bizarre. I don't understand your question though; techniques that are less than 200 chakra? Chakra Removal works by targeting a person, not their technique.
And yeah, it really should say Short - Long for the range. I'll have to edit that.
Same deal as chakra creation, we create chakra from nothing here. I suppose the technique itself is so complex that it needs to have a cost compared to the chaklra creation technique? The technique also is allowed to be revived at the cost of the move and if it didn't cost any chakra to do so it'd be rather stupid and i honestly think that's also a main reason why it has a chakra cost at all. It would probably been lower if the reviving wasn't a thing.Before we get to the technique itself, why do you think Creation of All Things can create an entity with 2,000 chakra but only requires an input of 500?
Same deal as chakra creation, we create chakra from nothing here. I suppose the technique itself is so complex that it needs to have a cost compared to the chaklra creation technique? The technique also is allowed to be revived at the cost of the move and if it didn't cost any chakra to do so it'd be rather stupid and i honestly think that's also a main reason why it has a chakra cost at all. It would probably been lower if the reviving wasn't a thing.
We're also creating a living entity with a chakra pathway system much like our own, which also results in their sheer existence to generate chakra over time(i guess..?).
It's mostly the second part; you are creating an entire being with it's own Tenketsu system. Although you would think this would require sheer amounts of chakra to create, you are using heavy amounts of spiritual and physical energies. One could argue these energies are separated at initial use and on combined when the beast itself is created. Spiritual and Physical energies combine to create chakra itself, which can be attributed to why the Creation has higher chakra - when created, it's energies coalesced to make a pool of chakra.
Another question: Yin governs imagination and in the context of CoaT, is responsible for the actual body and entity you create. If this is the case, why do you think Creations are unable to have KGs/HA that the user does not have if they are able to give form to their thoughts?
To your question, if that was the case i could probably use Yin release with other Kekkei Genkai my bio doesn't have but i cannot. Simply because the entity and body i create is from my imagination, i cannot imagine how kekkei genkai/HA's i don't have even works because my bio doesn't have this information. Sure, I could maybe gain information from battle but it's still not something a bio learns how to use just because they observe techniques from the battlefield. When it comes to Dojutsu and Shikotsumyaku, that is most likely an RP restriction rather than a "realistic" one if this technique were ever going to be used in the manga/anime by a Yin/Yang master who's not Hagoromo.
I guess the limitation is put into perspective of the creator. I cannot create life force higher than my own or the exact same as my own which is 160 hp. I can heal, using Yang surely but i cant make a technique that lets my health pool grow larger which indirectly this would let me do with a CoaT.That's correct - Although Yin creates things from imagination and is dictated by creativity, you generally cannot imagine how a KG fully works without having it, at least in the context of "in universe" where we refer to our actual characters. To create a KG, you need to understand that ability, how it works, its limitations and more; anything different could literally create a completely different ability. There is a part missing so I'll ask a similar question.
Another question (these are more so regarding limitations than function): Yang governs vitality and breathes life into form, essentially granting sentiency to entities and objects. This is important to note because it can only grant life to things that are an entity of some sort (statue, shadow person, Elemental Familiar, etc) or an object that can be interacted with (boulders, pools of water, houses, etc ). In the context of CoaT, when breathing life into form, why is this Creation's life capped at 150 health and not higher such as 200 like a Sage if they are able to freely give life through this technique?