I'm only on the pg 40s still catching up
This will be my lynch till I catch up
vote lynch: @Poison chan
The reason being in most familiar with her playing style than those I listed shes usually making more constructive reads in game spend more time defending and fluff posting than actual scum hunting seems also it isnt me that gets bad vibes with poison game this round.
This was Sage's first post in the game. He admits that he hasn't caught up, but then tosses a vote on Poison, arguably D1's most talked about person. This is just an easy vote in my eyes when I don't feel I vote was necessary upon initially entering the game.
What's the theory exactly unless soul did something scum I rather bet on poison
Here's Sage, who still hasn't caught up, and asked the thread about Soul v Michelle to help clarify what's going on, but still seems to want to move the lynch away from Soul and onto Poison. There was a lot of reluctance by Sage to commit one way or the other on Soul v Michelle and he actively tried to move away from these two lynches quite often. I'm not really sure why he would want to move away from it when it clearly needed to be resolved.
Hey everyone long time no talk bit intimidated on the size of this mafia game seeing alot a new players that I need to adjust for. So far only caught up to reading half way in the game so far.
So far my susses are for poison, tiger, thestatusquo, rej and bee number 2.
Reasons are for some playing styles feel off, some feel eager to get town support and some were active for the fluff posts and but disappeared when actual game got going on.
I'll finish and finalize my reads later in the day.
This is a pretty shit read list if you ask me. I think besides Rej, all the others were being questioned as scum a lot and again, it feels like easy pickings here. Not to mention his reasons for suspecting his reads list are vague and not independently attributed to a single player. Instead, we are meant to make the connections on which reasons belong to which player. Not super helpful.
Alright let's get this show on the road I'm all caught up
I'll start with the michelle and soul dispute last game after looking at both there comments I think theres a case to say both are scum but I lean towards michelle more because shes been fluff posting throughout the entire game, soul fluff posted intiatially but last phase he took more serious in his analysis and scum hunting. His case on how Michelle hasnt been serious in game was good one. And personally didn't like her initial lynch of ancient and various lynchs with no real reason.
My vote last phase was with poison and after fully reading it didnt help her case. She was acting emotional and defensive frol the beginning just to be sussed and gives a lynch. She repeatedly said she was having personal issues as an excuse maybe true or also manipulation to be looked at erratic town. In past when ever she would give reads it was more constructive not in this one and she was praising how Toujo was such a good lynch even tho you had x and Toujo on same suss level. To me shes easily the scummiest player in the game.
With the toujo and x dispute not sure why it escalated to that level and there arguements didnt seem constructive to the game. I didnt like x initial post gave reads no basis after that he got into argiemenhs couldnt really find him scum hunting. Also didn't like how he said he didjt mind getting lynched when there wasn't a wagon on him and in general that type comment always comes off manipulative.
Also needs to be noted how ryu and angel lack presence in the game worries me
If we're to assume this is Sage's first 'real' post on the game due to him saying the show is now starting and he's finally all caught up, there's surprisingly little here that's helpful. He comes in and says that he's leaning towards Michelle because of her fluff. While I didn't think Michelle had done a lot up to this point, I don't know if I would consider her posts fluff. It just feels like Sage was trying to do everything to avoid Soul being the lynch.
The two lynchs I'm for are either poison and Michelle because to me have biggest cases in being scum
This post screams "DON'T LYNCH SOUL".
I think I might be for a poison lynch since it would cross off people in being town and put us in best position to scum hunt
Considering how little attention Poison received after D1, I'm not sure what her flip would have informed us of.
Michele scum lean hard
And tigerr I soft scum lean because seems wishy washy but dont cant remember him to do anything apparently scummy
Wolf point.
Why do you view soul scum
It's actually concerning how many of Sage's posts are focused on the Soul v Michelle argument, specifically how he keeps asking people why Soul is scummy.
Let's move past arguements and just give reasons I looked back to when you casted the vote you didnt give a reason what's your rationale that souls the best lynch this phase.
The tiger gave was him being hostile to rej
Rej reason is dismissing x as cop
And michelle doesnt like soul sussed him
All these arent good reasons to go after him
What's your reason?
Yet another player Sage questions about suspecting Soul.
In the end of the day if people are dead set on pushing their lynchs without discussing them go ahead I'll try my best to steer the conversations productively but if no one wants to give effort themselves we will get another pointless myslynch that we've been getting every phase now
Irony in its finest form considering how you've literally pushed Poison since the moment you entered into the game.
@-PK- I'm willing to go after soul since you this adamant about it but if your wrong for me your going to take the blame on it
So be sure how much your willing to pursue this if you arent that sure to say 100 or 90% then I need arguements from you because the one you gave you said was just a theory which you backed out on last phase.
Not really sure why Sage would be trusting PK's case on Soul, but since Soul had lynch immunity, you can't really give points in Sage's favor for thinking about switching his vote to Soul.
Please state those reasons because as I'm looking at the soul case so far it's pretty flimsy from all going after him
Literally the next post from Sage. After stating he'd be willing to vote Soul, he then says the Soul case isn't good. It seems like he's trying to get players to give elaborate reasons on why they're voting for Soul so he can use them as his own and hide behind them.
The soul and michelle lynch seems a gamble to me theres an argument both are scum most agree poison is scum
And if we are talking pure reasons no one has a good reason pushing the soul lynch that's popular now
Everyone better state there rational for lynch I'm not letting anyone get away with bandwagoning
Still trying to direct away from the Soul v Michelle wagons.
also give your reasons why soul is scum
Here Sage asks for my case against Soul. He is WAY to concerned about Soul not to be connected.
Why soul is the good lynch for you
How many players has he asked this question?
Whsts your opinion on poison I don't want to pursue soul or michelle lynchs because seems a gamble to me cases for both arent strong while poisons is
Another player.
Agreed this forced michelle and soul lynch is dumb where we aren't discussing it forced to pick sides going to lead to another mislynch
Still trying to get everyone off the Soul v Michelle argument.
I'll keep discussing this poison lynch some more but seems people are too occupied with popular lynchs in the phase
If people dont want to discuss it I'll go with soul since pk backs it
Gross, gross.
Ehh
unvote
vote lynch: soul killer
If this this is a mislynch
@-PK- Your responsible for this more than Michelle
Sage excusing his behavior and voting based and instead hanging the blame on PK. Seems pretty shady.
Vote Lynch @Sagebee
The amount of posts that Sage made either questioning people about their suspicion of Soul, attempting to drive people away from the Soul v Michelle conflict, and asking people/trying to get people to vote for Poison is ultimately the things that I deem a very clear connection with Soul. I don't think that there's any doubt that Sage was not alright with Soul being lynched. If he really was concerned about Soul v Michelle he would have talked more about Michelle, but his focus was mostly on Soul whenever his posts were about Soul v Michelle. The obsession with Poison from his opening post also screams that he picked an easy case in D1 and just stayed behind it. This is the clearest teammate of Soul and we're fools if we don't vote him out.
