Interesting reaction. It's almost like you were waiting to pounce on me.
Lewd. But also yes.
Didn't you already repeat that first line on Poison this game?
Indeed. For different reasons, but yes.
How is this obtuse, Ratchet? You act like you've never seen a reads list before.
It's not the reads list that's the issue. It's the weird system you've used that just makes it harder to determine due to the order it is placed in. I don't know what's wrong with "Town/Lean-Town/Null/Lean-Scum/Scum", and ranking the list in order roughly. Instead of using like 7 different colours to represent the same thing.
I think there's something different about Ansa right out of the gate and I feel like he's playing too aggressively. I also don't like how he's chosen Poison and Tiger as his first targets to pick on; two members of the scum team last game. While Ansa doing this could be just his pent-up frustration from last game, his actions and reactions almost seem too methodically compared to last game where I felt he was more natural and easy-going.
That's fair. It has also pinged me a little, how I've made some attempts to discuss with Ansa, but he has made no effort at all to engage with me. I feel like if the angle was just mere frustration, then I should also be an object of that for him, in fact he should be feeling very confident in his ability to read me right about now. So to make no effort at all on his end is surprising to me.
Luk has also been a tad aggressive, but dissimilar to the purely chaotic aggression he was showing last game. There were also a couple of specific things, but I've forgotten already (if you really must know, I suppose I can ISO Luk later).
Not so sure about this one. Last game I started to engage Luk, but pulled off when it was looking like I was going to be a leading lynch candidate, and never picked it back up again because there was no reason to do so. I want to hold his feet to the fire more this game, and I feel a number of his posts have been nonsensical. I don't however see his play as drastically different from last game.
Your placement is simply yellow, not too suspicious, but still on the list. Your defense of Bee and you saying "I mean, given he was scum last game, Bee would have motivation to subtly change how he plays regardless of what he rolled, no?" pinged me because reading your posts this game, you are playing differently than I think I've ever seen you play before, and I just pinged on that subtle connection.
Eh. I mean, I'm not wrong. If Bee rolled scum again, he'd have reason to change it up, and he has the fluidity in his approach to easily do just that. As for me playing differently, I mean I guess? My point is to say that, Town or Scum, using just the last game as a baseline for expected behaviour for any alignment is somewhat flawed. You actually have a town read on Bee, which is interesting given this rationale.
Aether gets a soft blue town read because I've watched him play town now twice in a row and feel this could be the start of his town game as well (TBD).
I'll be frank - I'm not even going to pretend to understand this one. I don't find Aether particularly scummy. I just don't notice anything of note he's done. I think Aether would agree with that assessment too.
I think TSQ seemed game and ready to play and stir up the pot a bit. Angelus nicely defended himself from Poison's accusations (which I believe was her stirring up the pot a bit). And I mean, are you really questioning why I read myself town? Should I put myself on my own scum list? What are you trying to get at there?
I feel like you missed my point here. My issue was you'd ranked those two players at the same level as you ranked yourself - what am I to take from that if not "very strong town read"? I actually don't really care much for people including themselves in their own reads lists, but when you introduce the styling you have, and you put yourself at the top (obviously) and teo others share that position, I'm going to question it when it comes without reason.
What have you had enough of, exactly? You and I have not had a single interaction yet in this game, you actually defended me when Poison accused me of being scum because I was apparently playing like her scum meta, and I've clearly stated I was going to be busy until now. I was up at three thirty this morning to go and work for twelve hours (including six hours of driving) and I'm exhausted and want to go play Fallen Order.
I mean, I believe you on that. I just wasn't impressed by what you put forth when you did come into this thread. Most of this post is much better though, at least because it gives some reasons behind your logic, and reasons I actually find, well... reasonable. Yet, I'm not removing my vote just yet, because...
However, as I promised last night, I came on to catch up and be a respectful player to the host and my fellow players. Now, if you're not scum, **** you because you're being rude. Any other questions?
I dislike this part. Particularly the bolded. It feels like an Appeal to Emotion, forcing me to either accept I'm being rude or I'm scum. I don't feel like I have been rude, all told. Aggressive, maybe? Sure. One more question - between Ansa and Luk, which one would you prefer to lynch today?
