I didn't understand your first paragraph
Also, I think you give me too much credit, however I understand your paranoia, will I have played it different as scum? Maybe, maybe not, a lot of things I'd have done differently,
Just for fun: I'd have taken you or houtarou out, or indeed Toujo if you're all town, throw towns into looking into the clash you and Toujo is having, I'd try to get Michelle and Alice on my side, because they're stubborn as town, and would defend me, I may end up sacrificing one of my team mate... See where I'm going? A lot of things.
So ask yourself, in the context of this game, which faction will my current actions favour?