[Game] Peaky Blinders Mafia Game Thread #24

[Sagebee]

I'm more so leaning toward my lynch this phase being thestatusquo can change in the course of the game

 

[Ansatsuken]

Morning. Waiting for Sagebee to catch up.
Welcome Sage

Until then @Ansatsuken talk to me about your reads. From your post to TSQ i see you dislike his former vote on Rej, do you town read Rej? Why? And why Eph vs TSQ have to be town/mafia or mafia/town?

TSQ's former vote was Ephemeral not Rej. Rej is his current vote. And I never said I dislike any of his vote. I'm just asking for his reasoning.

I have shrunk my working ground in this DP and mostly focusing on 3 people rn. So both of them are in my PoE and also includes Mr Lonely.

1 from 3 of them could be Mafia.

-Ephemeral>Not doing any scum hunting yet. Most of the time he just asking and asking people about their opinion on a subject but never had an opinion to share with people on the same subject. To be honest I think he just dragging the situation further while not actually contribute anything.

-TSQ>Same with Ephemeral. No significant contribution coming from him yet. I made a theory on one of his early comment but I think that theory could be wrong. It's not actually like what I'm thinking. And what makes me questioned any town expectation on him bcuz of these posts;

I have a hiatus of 5 months, I suck

Can I be given a free pass

Good enough for me

You must be registered to see images

You said D2, what do you need my reads for? You have plenty of content to analyse.

Looks to me like an excuses to not contributing and an exemption from being check. Don't know why people gave a free pass. Why the special treatment??

And now he accused me of pocketing him instead of understand the right meaning of that message.

-Mr.Lonely>This fella being one of my suspect entirely on guts reading. So 50/50.

 

[Ansatsuken]

VoteLynch: Thestatusquo

Currently disliking how TSQ's play compares to Ephemeral. Ephemeral down to second place. I will keep observing.

 

[Michelle]

Michelle vote of rej is weird to me I think his reasoning of creating his list to get reaction out of players makes sense and he got a reaction out of you to the point you lynched him need to hear more why you think he should be lynched.

My vote on Rej has the following reasons:
- his rainbow list was too early in the game and included everyone, not just the players who posted. And has players who didn't post useful for the game too. I mean you can't take an early hello in the game as alignament indicative.
- his answers are minimalist, like ke is affraid to post more to not slip.
- his explanation for getting reactions is not followed by his conclusion of these reactions.
- his posts explaining things are not complete thoughts imo. I waited for him to post meaningful a lot of time but he didn't do anything. He knows how I am playing, we played in other sites too, not just here so i feel that
- his read on me is not real.

 

[Michelle]

@Ansatsuken thanks for the answer.
I gave TSQ a pass for day one.
This comes from few ideas that are just not important for the game, more like external causes because we are living in the same country and I can understand a rl situation he may be in.
Maybe you can call me a softie for this and I can't deny it.

 

[Ansatsuken]

My vote on Rej has the following reasons:
- his rainbow list was too early in the game and included everyone, not just the players who posted. And has players who didn't post useful for the game too. I mean you can't take an early hello in the game as alignament indicative.
- his answers are minimalist, like ke is affraid to post more to not slip.
- his explanation for getting reactions is not followed by his conclusion of these reactions.
- his posts explaining things are not complete thoughts imo. I waited for him to post meaningful a lot of time but he didn't do anything. He knows how I am playing, we played in other sites too, not just here so i feel that
- his read on me is not real.

Do you not have a feeling of something seems look easy??

 

[Ansatsuken]

@Ansatsuken thanks for the answer.
I gave TSQ a pass for day one.
This comes from few ideas that are just not important for the game, more like external causes because we are living in the same country and I can understand a rl situation he may be in.
Maybe you can call me a softie for this and I can't deny it.

He's Romanian?

 

[Sagebee]

My vote on Rej has the following reasons:
- his rainbow list was too early in the game and included everyone, not just the players who posted. And has players who didn't post useful for the game too. I mean you can't take an early hello in the game as alignament indicative.
- his answers are minimalist, like ke is affraid to post more to not slip.
- his explanation for getting reactions is not followed by his conclusion of these reactions.
- his posts explaining things are not complete thoughts imo. I waited for him to post meaningful a lot of time but he didn't do anything. He knows how I am playing, we played in other sites too, not just here so i feel that
- his read on me is not real.

I will say I find his lack of engagement to be alarming but to make a big move like that giving him attention and questions make me town lean him.

Your reasoning it's too early to do it you lynched someone early on in the phase maybe he thought the same thing about you that acted too premature.

I Personally think he made a smart move by doing that he did an obviously irrational thing and wait to see which players he could bait out so far your the only one having a strong reaction to his list. He put me high on his list too I just simply asked him what's up with that and reason he gave was sufficient for me.

It's not even as if he actively tried to push any of those susses towards anyone so I cant find anything scummy in what he did.

What's your thoughts on thestatusquo so far?

 

[Mr.Lonely]

Ok so I'm mostly suspicious of Mr.Lonely being scum, I'm also a little suspicious thestatusquo but for other reasons

@Mr.Lonely is mostly just because they have only posted once and I feel that they may be hiding
@Thestatusquo

I didnt even know what AL (alignment indacative) posts were. But I have a feeling that they wanted this so that they could draw suspicion off of themselves because it seemed that Michelle and Eph were on to them, though I could be wrong.

Michelle and Eph seem like town to me this far, mostly just due to how active they are.

Actually if you must know, i've been sick all week XD. I'm juggling this game with college.

Not me. in a scale of 1 to 10 how scummy do you think i am?

I dont know Alice, you looking pretty scummy to me lol In all honesty, I can never get a good read off of you until a day has passed or so.

 

[SoulKiller]

You must be registered for see images

 

[Thestatusquo]

Vote Count

Michelle - Thestatusquo - Unvote - Rej - Unvote - Rej
Thestatusquo - xEphemeralx
SoulKiller - Michelle

Rej (X1)
xEphemeralx (X1)
Michelle (X1)

You literally quoted my post where I changed my vote to Rej lol

@Poison chan

 

[Thestatusquo]

Best waiting to be prodded instead of sharing thoughts of his own volition is to be kept in mind

As is tsq acting like he's entitled to doing nothing and wanting a free pass to go with it

Ok calm down, I never said I wasn’t going to do anything, I’m saying “Stop depending on me and instead of demanding me to be a village idiot so you can get an easy read on me, let me hunt scum. I can’t do both”

 

[Thestatusquo]

You said the warning that I gave to you means I want to pocketing you. Absurd. First of all I don't see any problem with Elmage's vote. In my early comment I've made a theory that said "The post, it could be TSQ's strategy to catch scum by posting that". Here you're highly mistaken if you think I read you as town from that post. My comment should be read in a way if you're town.

So if you're town you should be blamed if town wasting the lynch on you. You still play a passive game like in the previous game. But the difference here you posting more. I have ISO your posts and most of it not looking really helpful. Many trivial comments that can't be a source of reference to other players. You know right which faction where their opinion not worth a dime???

Saying "You really did rand wolf didn't you?" How is that being helpful?

Ok you have voted 2 people so far but can I see your reasoning. You have stated why you vote Ephemeral but what is your reasoning on voting Rej???

If you are scum TSQ that means you've given people a sign. If they believe you're scum they going to vote you

But if they think it looks so easy and for someone who had in the previous game(Prime Number) rand scum maintaining the same approach in this game is something for people to evaluate.

That’s your problem for meta reading me instead of reading my posts

 

[Michelle]

Your reasoning it's too early

How come? the game has already 2 real days and over 270 posts which for us is a big day 1 amount.

It's not even as if he actively tried to push any of those susses towards anyone so I cant find anything scummy in what he did.

The problem is he isn't actively scumhunting. Not lack of scuminess but lack of towniness made me have the scum read for him.

 

[Thestatusquo]

Michelle my reasoning has nothing to do with this corona thing by the way

 

[Michelle]

Michelle my reasoning has nothing to do with this corona thing by the way

Good to know.

 

[Michelle]

I am stuck home and highly paranoid so I am in no good shape to play

 

[Thestatusquo]

I just think it’s funny how you guys say “Why is TSQ receiving special treatment” when in fact, the only “special treatment” i get is always being under the spotlight Day 1

You are looking for patterns when catching scum me without merely thinking how devastating it can be if you lynch me Day 1 without even giving my reads.

What if I flip town?

Seems like i’m not an asset if town any way, so what are we doing here?

Ansa please, talking special treatment. SK has been posting nothing but gifs, and he’s probably going to skate until he dies.

 

[Thestatusquo]

You’re relying on past experiences in order to catch a scum, you’d much rather ignore my posts and anyone else’s for that matter and think “Well TSQ isn’t doing this when he did this as a town game so let’s lynch him instead”

I’m sick and tired of this and it’s time y’all learned a lesson. Read my damn posts and don’t expect me to put on an act for you. Treat me like anyone else.

 

[Thestatusquo]

I’m not going to play from the frame which you presume to be my town game. I’m hunting.