[Game] Death Note Mafia #21 - Game Thread

[Just_Red]

What? Why asking me? Where did I say that?

You stated that mafia had 2x killing ability no?

 

[Ansatsuken]

You stated that mafia had 2x killing ability no?

Other people said that?

Before entering a conversation please read all posts first?

There were many question mark there.

 

[Just_Red]

Who knows? I don't even know if there are cannibals in DN in the first place orz. Also if both SK and mafia are cannibals then they must be able to be found in the same way... right? Unless of course the term 'cannibal' is some kind of game term which I've never heard of before instead of the legit gersion LOL

Again: Are there even cannibals in DN??

Cannibals is the name of the role. Did you read the set up? Just asking, partner?

 

[Ansatsuken]

@All_Red find me that post please

 

[Just_Red]

Other people said that?

Before entering a conversation please read all posts first?

There were many question mark there.

No comment

 

[Just_Red]

@All_Red find me that post please

Tou were quoting Rej in "" (quotation marks) my mistake.

 

[Just_Red]

There is no balance in a 3v9 when mafia has 2 kills. This is UNFAIR against the Serial Killer.

So either you guys act quite paranoid or people thinking mafia has 2 kills are probably Cannibals themselves.


Helooooo guys lets have a funnitime.

What? I keep rereading your post. I still dont get it. Are you saying sk has a disadvantage because mafia can kill twice? How?? And your second paragraph makes no sence.

 

[Ansatsuken]

it looked to me like you and raunix were giving wint to fire

Raunix seemed to be very subjective with his comments while I'm being more objective to understand Sagebee's thinking on the set up and mechanics.

 

[Ansatsuken]

What? I keep rereading your post. I still dont get it. Are you saying sk has a disadvantage because mafia can kill twice? How?? And your second paragraph makes no sence.

Tbh I'm still trying to understand it.

 

[AL_sama]

Oh damn how can I forgot about factional kill. Role Madness game recently have messed up my thinking a little.

When you said vanilla I only have "no ability at all" inside my mind.

its amusing how you forgot about it even after so many games

@All_Red are you scum??

@Michelle why do you think rej can be sk??

 

[Michelle]

I don't like to talk about mechanics tbh. What do you think about Sagebee and his talk about mechanics?

A townie talking or scum talking? For me the way he talked feels townie.

Sagebee was in his town self from what i felt.

 

[Rej]

What? I keep rereading your post. I still dont get it. Are you saying sk has a disadvantage because mafia can kill twice? How?? And your second paragraph makes no sence.

I said "when" implicating the case of a 4KPN. In a 4KPN the SK is in disadvantage. Because the SK filles the niche of an "opposing Faction Kill".
Having 2 faction kills opposing a person with just 1 faction kill is not a balance. And it will never be the case.

I get town vibes from All_Red

 

[Ansatsuken]

its amusing how you forgot about it even after so many games

@All_Red are you scum??

@Michelle why do you think rej can be sk??

Because last time I played as Mafia I'm the one in charge of killing people(godfather)

Have to do with the setup.

 

[Michelle]

its amusing how you forgot about it even after so many games

@All_Red are you scum??

@Michelle why do you think rej can be sk??

where did I say that? Iirc I said Fos for Rej...

 

[Rej]

My bad.. i didn't
I would never dare to joke like a dad tbqh

No, I don't remember such thing.

I thought even if they are Cannibals they are killing with a gun, otherwise what can be the meaning of a town role to show who has a gun?
Thing is, not every cannibal is scum, one is villager.

My question is: can we have 3 NKs in a small setup? Assuming from the 2 mafia cannibals just one kills.
Worst case scenario, 4 night kills?

Here it started when Michelle followed up the discussion of Raunix and Sagebee.

And it kept on through half of page 2. And I don't like the paranoia.
@All_Red

does it explain my statement better?

 

[Michelle]

Cannibals is the name of the role. Did you read the set up? Just asking, partner?

Why do you consider Raunix your partener?

 

[Ansatsuken]

I said "when" implicating the case of a 4KPN. In a 4KPN the SK is in disadvantage. Because the SK filles the niche of an "opposing Faction Kill".
Having 2 faction kills opposing a person with just 1 faction kill is not a balance. And it will never be the case.

I get town vibes from All_Red

vig will have limited killing shot. Possibly 1 shot only

 

[AL_sama]

I never said it's the case, I meant it would be unfair if it were the case.
Also I will be busy for the next 2 hours. I just wanted to point out that I felt uneasy about the 4KPN theory some people had here and that it's wrong.

yeah but rather then saying it'd be unfair you could've simply just cleared out what a goon means tho

 

[Michelle]

yeah but rather then saying it'd be unfair you could've simply just cleared out what a goon means tho

I like this post. It's expressing a thought i had in the back of my head but i couldn't put in words.

 

[AL_sama]

where did I say that? Iirc I said Fos for Rej...

poor serial you only pitty him, why it's not unfair for town too?
Fos for Rej

here but I got my answer