[Game] The Meg Game # 10 Thread

[Marluxion]

oh rip i thought ansa was still alive, didn't see he was dead in the op

 

[Marluxion]

Vote: The Lukundo

 

[Elmage G Ace]

Also, please townies, we should really consider our votes, we wouldn't want what happened with poison to repeat, please confirm your reasoning. I feel kind of guilty not reacting in time, I had decided poison may not be Mafia, but I missed the vote lock time

For the record I did state that towns should go over their votes. Moving on...

How long until DP ends? tbh votes on All_Red is bothering me, but what's more is that two players on my suspicion list votes for her.

If I have enough time left I'll try reanalysis of All_Reds post, ignoring the 'End now' incident, but if she gets lynched and turns out town then I'll have a scum for y'all

@italicized : The two players were @Ryu Kishi and @SoulKiller (still are)

No need for explanation when it's obvious. She pulled a stunt that is extremely anti townie. If we gonna give people chances whenever they mess up might as well just beat around the bush.

He still doesn't re-evaluate his vote. @bold I guess the joke's on you. It wasn't. I had given sufficient info for reasonable doubt at this point, and she had started to prove town with her play. But she was obviously wolf. OK

i would like to remind you she played less mafia than anyone in the thread except Elmage

Michelle noticed at this point, something I had inferred earlier. That is, if you exclude, what we would consider a mistake for a post All_Red made, she was Town (from her play)

Offer us a suitable replacement that is as scummy as all_red with good explanation push for it. Because if you have someone who you think is more scummy than all_red then you should be voting for them. If you don't have anyone who is more scummy than all_red in your reads and you not doing anything about it then you are not helping the situation at all. You are just watching from the sideline.

This is just laughable. Seriously. If you read my posts with an intention to get new information, you would see that each one (or almost) contains info valuable to Towns. Except of course, you don't want to see those info, because you already knew she was town

Not really since you put yourself in this situation. It's a risk every player have to take in mafia games. If you flip out to be townie I will be extremely annoyed because you fucked us over with that stunt of yours and brought unnecessary attention to yourself. Your reasons for explaining it seems like something anyone can make up on the spot. Hence, why I am convinced.

I can ofcourse take my vote away and pray that it was truly a townie mistake but if you turned out to be scum then I will hate myself for not lynching you and I frankly experienced it more than once and it feels awful so I stopped giving people second chances.

Honestly, this is the point I expected you to change your mind.
@bold: Would a wolf do that from your perspective? This question should have crossed your mind
@italicized: That's not a counter to her reason. If you wanted to give her the benefit of the doubt, it would have been better to unvote, because if she got lynched, we'd be at a disadvantage if she flipped town(which she did)

At this point, I'd say I'll be quite disappointed if you (and it's quite uncertain to me) flipped town @SoulKiller you're supposed to be the most experienced player here, no? if so, from a town standpoint, your play this game was a let down. Might I add that it makes sense as Mafia

I have a question for you @SoulKiller first, you and All_Red both voted Poison, but you suspected her after she requested the votes be locked, if you were sure Poison was scum, there's really no reason to go after All_Red, since Poison, along with Oreki had the most votes, and locking the votes then meant Poison had a chance of being lynched... that plays into your hands, you were one of the first to comment on All_Red's reaction, even before Poison was lynched, and so your reasoning wouldn't make sense here because you voted Poison (I mean, assuming she flipped mafia, your suspicion on All_Red becomes useless)

Summary of this: SK and All_Red votes poison, but SK votes All_Red, because she wanted to lock votes

Ignoring All_Red's push for locking votes, there's not enough to confirm she's scum, not clearing her, but THAT action is what condemned her it would seem. More on this later, I have my eyes on someone else now. Will post soon

At this point I pretty much inferred she wasn't

There was supposed to be way extra time for the DP before it ended. I was waiting for posion chan to come online and improve her situation hence why I told the host that it's not cool to end everything all of a sudden when we were told we have 12 extra hours to the DP. I had my vote on poison because she was the most suspicious for me at that moment. The game has to move on and best way to gain any sort of information is by voting. I used mine you see and you did not.

Also, when all of that happened I was away and briefly skimmed through it with my phone. By the time I made it back home DP ended. The fact that poison flipped townie made me even more way of all_red stunt since it looks like a mafia who wanted to lock votes on two townies and get them lynched.

@bold: But she did attempt to improve the situation.
@italicized: And your reason was because she was using metas to justify players actions. Great reason!

eh I feel like I contributed enough in this DP. Honestly, if people wanna lynch me for stating my mind and actually trying to do something as townie to catch scum. Then please lynch me this DP and get it over with. This way you can actually focus on capturing scum. That being said, I gotta go good luck on whatever choice you guys make.

Note this bolded towns

SK votes poison

SK replies to poison, asking for reads

Poison's reply

SK doesn't like that she's using metas. OK.

Luk pointed out something important here, Sk asks for reads (which is ok) get's peoples thoughts and opinions and all, when he finally posted his own reads, there was actually nothing new, most of it was just restating/organizing what others say, basically it could mean he wants to check everyone's knowledge so he wouldn't reveal new info, but I could be wrong, perhaps I overestimate his abilities, or maybe he's scum

1. He votes Poison based on the fact that she's using meta reads to justify actions, that's basically what most people are doing when they say 'I know this person, he wouldn't do this/that' he also disregards Poison's reply, more like ignores it, sloppy

2. Originally has All_Red as town, but changes his mind after she pushed for vote lock (keep in mind they both voted for the same person >> Poison)

3. He was the first to vote poison, based on meta reads. In fairness, the Zoro issue didn't help either, it made poison look sus

4. He hasn't provided new reads based on the new info, he just decided to stick with All_Red (which is fine) but the thng is, if that post didn't exists, he wouldn't have any reason to sus her (he actually gave All_Red town read in the beginning)

Verdict, you're either very sloppy in this game (perhaps due to some reasons his head is not fully in the game) or you're a mafia

My effectiveness is fading... @_@

Please read bolded towns

 

[Marluxion]

wait no
Vote: Cemeteries

 

[Marluxion]

wait no
Vote: PoisonedSquid

 

[Marluxion]

WHY ARE YOU ALL WOLVES

 

[Elmage G Ace]

wait no
Vote: Cemeteries

please check how to vote/unvote properly, I don't want what happened with All_Red to repeat itself . Thanks

 

[Marluxion]

Ceme isn't being flakey, Luke sounds nothing like normal and squid's posts feel way too formal

why are all my buddies wolves

 

[Elmage G Ace]

WHY ARE YOU ALL WOLVES

Bruh! What you doin?! Reads please

 

[shade0180]

Vote: Soul Killer.


The dude is literally doing as much shit as possible to muddy the game.

You guys can review his post if you want to.

 

[shade0180]

Vote: Soul Killer.

 

[Marluxion]

michelle is town at least

 

[Marluxion]

Bruh! What you doin?! Reads please

i'm catching up on the thread and replying as i go, feel free to ignore me or ask questions as i do it
i likely won't answer them until i'm fully caught up tho

 

[Michelle]

Marl, Luk plays different here, as well me and i think Squid as well. Ceme didn't post enough.

What do you you think about SoulKiller?

 

[Michelle]

Please @everyone put @ in front of voted name to can be sure is correct voted.

 

[Marluxion]

Marl, Luk plays different here, as well me and i think Squid as well. Ceme didn't post enough.

What do you you think about SoulKiller?

still catching up
where i'm at ceme has been decently active but i'm glad to hear that changed
glad for ceme's alignment, not for the gamestate obv

like i said i'll post reads and answer stuff when i'm caught up

 

[Elmage G Ace]

At this point, I'm wondering if we still have an invest. All_red was watcher right? Can there be more invests? Also do these invest post their findings here? I thought if All_Red did invest she could post her finds when she died... I need to understand the rules better T_T

 

[Elmage G Ace]

Also, for those who are trying to read SK and is too lazy busy to go through all this posts, you can read my posts from last DP

 

[Michelle]

At this point, I'm wondering if we still have an invest. All_red was watcher right? Can there be more invests? Also do these invest post their findings here? I thought if All_Red did invest she could post her finds when she died... I need to understand the rules better T_T

As madness game everyone has a RP more or less powerfull. But all inactives being roleblocked and not even one flip being cop or protective role i think they are still alive, but roleblocked. So we have a pile of VTs (vanilla town) in the living town team.

 

[Ryu Kishi]

Honestly I don't trust Michelle she was pushing hard on all red only to come right at the end and say that all red is not a good lynch. She obviously after town cred.

Also Abu (I think his name is) he is obviously scum.

Sk says he is busy with rl which is most likely true. But from his play so far he does lean scum.