Good way to start is by giving your read list currently if possible?
Post automatically merged:
You mentioned before that zoro is hella scummy and here again you are saying that he is your top suspect yet it's all talk no action. If he truly was your number 1 suspect then where is the vote? taking your time before voting ? or could it possibly be distancing?
Again, I believe this is a bug due to auto merger that shows the "last edited". Site was under maintenance yesterday and I guess some bugs still lurking. I did mention in the post before your previous one that it shows that I edited one of my posts as well and that it's most likely a bug. The server is fucking with us.
Again I did not give you any official warning. Just in general for everyone. Realized later on that its shows for alot of people who auto merged sign of "last edit". So, let's move on for now wanted to state something and I did. If people actually edited I will know so no one try anything funny
The forum put a mention of editing at some automerged posts. Check the moment of posting and the moment of "editing".
I think no one break the rule but we can chack this. @SoulKiller
Post automatically merged:
Also of you don't want your posts to be moderated respect the forum rules please. @shade0180
Enogh with fluffs
Soulkiller looks like i am here to amuse you. i shall continue.
Is hard to play with so many inactives, some sharks can hide between them.
In this game will contain a Shop mechanic. Players can go visit the shop during the day phase. It will be closed once the day phase ends. A maximum of 3 players can buy the item in there at a time. Once 3 players buy something, it will be closed immediately even if the DP hasn't ended. The only thing you will find in the shop is a protective enclosure that is specifically made to protect you against shark attacks. If you buy this item you will be unable to use your night action for the upcoming night. You also won't be able to buy it in the next day phase. This shop has the possibility to go away for the rest of the game.
IF mafia has access to this protection does that mean the sharks are a separate groups, is it possible we have 2 groups one mafia and the other sharks?
This shop has the possibility to go away for the rest of the game
Is it possible that this is controlled by a player. which is part of town or an independent? I don't think this is mafia but we do need to protect this person if it is indeed a player ability.
The forum put a mention of editing at some automerged posts. Check the moment of posting and the moment of "editing".
I think no one break the rule but we can chack this. @SoulKiller
Post automatically merged:
Also of you don't want your posts to be moderated respect the forum rules please. @shade0180
Enogh with fluffs
Soulkiller looks like i am here to amuse you. i shall continue.
Is hard to play with so many inactives, some sharks can hide between them.
do the mafia also have access to this? because this might be some huge shit if mafia is the shark and town needs to know about this shit.
IF mafia has access to this protection does that mean the sharks are a separate groups, is it possible we have 2 groups one mafia and the other sharks?
Is it possible that this is controlled by a player. which is part of town or an independent? I don't think this is mafia but we do need to protect this person if it is indeed a player ability.
So that's as far as I got for this game.
Post automatically merged:
wait since when did I said I didn't want my post moderated? Also I haven't broken a single rule as far as I know.
If you paid attention I did ask the host about how to buy the items and you can buy it by simply PMing him that you want to buy the vest. Also, you haven't breaking any rules please forget about it and focus on the game.
So basically you won't die until all the civilians are dead right? The sharks/Mafia can harm you and lessen the number of civilians just by existing in the game?
We have 16 players, not including Drago. And in those 16 players, 4 probably are mafia and 2 probably are 3rd. So if invest gonna start invest all town in order to make a good alliance, in the meantime mafia probably be standing as the winner.
Time is a luxury that town does not have in the mafia, not all the time
I do get a town vibe from Ansatsuken from the beginning, as how attacking he seems to be right now to find the scum or confirm other's role, if he hadn't changed his playstyle that is.
About,
Oreki, he doesn't seem to be cool right now. After getting pointed by Ansatsuken. Unlike zorro who is chilled.
Michelle seems pretty decent as to why she seems relaxed about getting investigated.
Unless, Ansatsuken is partnerd with Michelle in the "Shark Company" and trying to put on a show of being innocent. Too early to make a judgement right now. The probability of them being in any faction is identically similar.
24Hours so time still plenty. That's just one of my strategy.
We can use our skill in reading a player in this first DP and deduce who might play the scummiest or act very suspicious. Tbh what I'm doing now and next will reveal many things.
"And in those 16 players, 4 probably are mafia and 2 probably are 3rd."
Sounds like you know something hmm....
You must be registered for see images
________________________
And all your remaining post after that doesn't have an ounce of sense.
"So if invest gonna start invest all town in order to make a good alliance"
This Doesnt make sense
You put it like Invest know all the town in this game.
If they found someone so suspicious in this game but hard to lynch they can invest that player.
"in the meantime mafia probably be standing as the winner."
We are not just standing idle, doing nothing inside every DP and only waiting for NP m8. We observe, read players, looking for clue inside every DP.
And one fact you missed is that invest have higher chance to find town inside their investigation than Scum. It because Town formed a majority of players in Mafia. Players that play like a Scum could be a Town. So by investigating that Player and know about their true alignment that would help in clearing up that player.
Underlined part
It really does not sound like he knows something. Just seems to me that he is making guesses based of past games. I would jump to the same conclusion.
Don't dye your hair red. Well I said I'm gonna dye it white but then my parents said they'll kick me out of the house. So I'm sticking to blue for now. Don't go with red, shanks. You are an adult. Dye it white. ? maybe add some sparkling glitters and a cute little bow. ?
i am still thinking at sharks attacks and civilians, more than anything. Adults, kids, family members searching each others, all are suspense elements of the flavour. I talks to my imagination lol.
Back to the game,
I have town lean for Ansa and Oreki, also Ryu can be town.
Poison and Zoro make me worried, i have mixed feelings for them.
And Poison pointed out "Zoro is chilled while Oreki is not"
Feels like a 'support' from the other side(Poison).
In actuality our arguments were about "Its good to apply this kind of investigation strategy or its actually not?"
I told Oreki if he keep coming at me and be negative over my strategy I'm gonna look at him, 1) as a wolf that trying to leads me into believing what I'm currently doing is a wrong strategy and that's not how town should play(especially invest). A Wolf that trying his best to manipulate and control my action. A Wolf that trying to play as Townie. 2) A Wolf that not expecting this kind of strategy would be used here and saw it very dangerous to the survival of Mafia. So trying his best to convince me and everyone that its not a best idea.
But,
Tbh Scum will not against anything that can waste town ability. But when Oreki showed his concern(over my strategy) I think that genuinely what he believes as a town. He thought I only suggested that Investigator should go for Townie only and ignored suspicious players. That's what I believe.
But,
Then I saw Oreki mellowed down his reponse/action towards me. Feels that he unable to convince me so he chose to go with me. But they he did it feels unnatural.
He even not responding properly to some of my posts.
So what's in my mind right now?
1) Oreki_Houtarou still not cleared. Like 60/40. 60% Town, 40% Wolf.
2) Poison Chan if she's mafia she trying her best to take advantage on my approach in this game. Post a read and gain my trust. How I came to this conclusion? Its Zoro and the way he presenting his opinion here;
I get a vibes they could know each other.
3) Zoro has becoming my obvious suspect rn. His posting, his level of activity and weird approach into this game.
4) Ryu Kishi played very timid here.
I agree, the reads you made do make sence. My only question would be if your 60/40, why not vote. If your sus is a little more then half, then pressure the user to get more out of him, to satify your investigation. No?
Alright, I read through everything and it looks like there isn't much to talk about except for one thing. My opinion of Oreki's belief is quite interesting to me. I do agree that it's better to not check someone who claims they want to be checked, but it's not about the invest going "Hey, I think this guy's scum, time to see if I'm right." It's more useful to check null reads or individuals who act the same as either alignment. As for when a possible invest should reveal themselves: Don't do it unless if they think it's absolutely necessary. Don't out to confirm a townie and if they can lean the votes towards a red check without outing themselves, go ahead and do it
okay maybe a tiny bit of luck . (don't kill me pls)
You can trust me ansa ^^
Does he tho? does he truly know the answer? why the vagueness dear?
It's amusing the fact that you assume the invest can investigate one time.
I feel kinda weird vibes from this. From one side it can be all cool and dandy and you are actually a townie who want to gain people trust by asking the investigator to check you out first. But you see you can also be mafia god father who get investigated as innocent regardless. The fact that you are requesting it this early is making me unease at the moment. You are not in any tough spot or anything. Yet here you are requesting people to investigate you first.
A mafia/serial killer can prove to people that they are townie by their play. However, by investigating them you know for a fact if they are a townie or not and see if what they are doing is honest and pure or just all a ploy. Unless ofcourse if he is god father then at that point you just have to trust your instincts along with your analogy.
Highly doubt there 4 mafias in play here in a 16 player game. That is too much for a size of this game.
Cool you agree with some of ansa points. Have any of your own personal points you wanna share with us instead of other people points?
Why is zoro giving you scum vibes to the max? care to elaborate?
VETEST ALERT? that's it? my poor heart can't handle this.
damn that's a bold statement this early on. So you are saying that poison is your top town read because she briefly mentioned meta reads of people? hell it's not even meta reads. More like mini summary of people style lol. Probably copied pasted all our names and then briefly summed them up in about 1-16 words and the only person with 16 words is ansa and the majority are one liners xD. This by no sh
Interesting read you have there regardless lol.
I am the one who needs protection here :/ remember last game? xD
Again, not liking how you are pushing invest to invest you when you are not a major suspect yet. Also, this early in the game. It feels more like a serial killer with invest immunity or mafia god father trying to get on cop good side early on in the game.
I suggest, we wait until the end of the DP and agree together on who we think is the most suitable to be investigated etc.
Post automatically merged:
Also, Vote shade0180
reason :
Post automatically merged:
Regarding the setup I tend to not think about it too much for now. Major rule in succeeding in any mafia game is to play it normally by scum hunting and lynching scum.
Although im not gonna lie getting that vest from the store seems very compelling lol. How do we buy one tho? do we simply just mention you that we wanna buy one? does it cost money? how exactly does it work? @Dragomir
Underlined part:
She wasnt requesting, but accepeting an offer, mind you.
I agree with whatever else you said.
Hopefully you'll remove votes as fast as you give them, when evidence presents istelf.
I don’t really have many good thoughts other than having a strong suspiscion on Ansat only cause talking about mechanics is something scum typically does to make it seem like they’re doing something, while in reality doing nothing. Bonus points if it’s one of their first posts, which it is :3
I have even found something similar inside Michelle's game. Its when Duke3star claimed Lukundo and the Cow's(Both are mafia) posts as very townie. It just a simple post like that of Cemeteries so how you can confirmed someone as 100% townie from a simple post. Seems like(Cemeteries) is looking for your trust.
I know I have been attacked by one of mafia member right now.
It amusing the fact you think you let the invest, invest more town looking players first. Yeah, sure scum can look like the most towniest player and town can look like a scummiest player. But when you invest, who you gonna choose to invest?
The most scummy looking player in your eyes?
Or a Most towniest looking player in your eyes?
Of course, you're gonna choose the most scummy looking player to invest not the most townies in your eyes, right?
About -zoro- even you can see his post don't really hold anything worth, I mean you can write an entire essay just filled with game setup assuming information, but you can't count that as game-related information that let you [rgress the game, can you?
Personally I'd choose the towniest, reason being, they are my least sus, therefore being the ones with the most potential to commit NP killings without my suspition.
So why not have the invest check the people that reacted to the request instead of the person that requested to be checked in the first place? There's more information gained from checking someone who you're unsure of. And I'm pretty sure a framer would never frame their own teammates or even can because A. They would show up as Mafia anyway and B. Any invest check on that night would be guaranteed to be correct as the frame wouldn't be on a Townie.
Okay saw new players such as @shade0180@AbuHumaid and @PoisonedSquid.. ◀@Poison chan is this your long lost brother? Are you guys veteran Mafia players?
Welcome and hope you enjoy playing here.
Yes I always play like this. I'm not good in catching Scum. I base my readings on the tone of posts and not the actual content of the post.
I'm most comfortable when playing as a Townie because I don't need to defend myself too much and no pressure on my part on protecting my teammates and stay out of their way because of my noobish way of playing.
one could be drawn to suspect Ansa, he seems a bit too aggressive, and starts of blaming... however his interesting start to the game would favour townies in the long run, don't see why he'd do that.
I would have to disagree with Oreki on invest a townie being a waste, Ansa has the right idea with respect to forming an alliance, so if I Ansa is innocent, it would mean Michelle probably is too, by association, and that would be a useful info for townies... I don't know about the whole Godfather stuff though (like I said, noob)
I find it suspicious that both poison, and Zoro, low-key vouched for each other (at least from my perspective) I could be wrong, but yeah, both are suspects. It's still early though, still observing...
You can count on me @Ansatsuken not completely sure about @Michelle but I'm going with you both as townies for now
Yeah, while one already went offline after voting me, I guess that guy really is mafia. I mean his reason for voting is mostly come from twisting my words lol
Hmm weird. Because it does show for me that you edited. Checked and nothing to major I saw if anything at all but just fair warning in case people forgot.
Post automatically merged:
rofl it even shows that I edited one of my post I made 5 minutes ago. Guess site is being weird I guess. Unless it counts auto merge as editing? hmm
FINALLLY RESPONDED!
After two hours of reading cause I'm godam slow!
Okay guys.
So my sus is Poisen.
Vote Lynch: @Poison chan
Reason: I think is purposely trying to opt out of issues and arguments to look like a townie. I suspect they could be third party. A reread will be down with evidence that proves this.
Post automatically merged:
FINALLLY RESPONDED!
After two hours of reading cause I'm godam slow!
Okay guys.
So my sus is Poisen.
Vote Lynch: @Poison chan
Reason: I think is purposely trying to opt out of issues and arguments to look like a townie. I suspect they could be third party. A reread will be down with evidence that proves this.
You said: "He went offline after voting me" then followed it with "he really is scum"
I was responding to this claim and not to your whole argument.
Also could you elaborate on where he twisted your words?
You said: "He went offline after voting me" then followed it with "he really is scum"
I was responding to this claim and not to your whole argument.
Also could you elaborate on where he twisted your words?
I also said his reason came by twisting my words, there are a lot of players who are inactive and if he really is thinking about finding scum then he should do it more seriously
Sometimes, it does, 90% of time it only makes you a target. Why do i know it because I always do it.
And someone always just assume you are sus for doing it, and then for some reason those who claim it is a way to avoid being sus ended being scum after all.
I also said his reason came by twisting my words, there are a lot of players who are inactive and if he really is thinking about finding scum then he should do it more seriously
Sometimes, it does, 90% of time it only makes you a target. Why do i know it because I always do it.
And someone always just assume you are sus for doing it, and then for some reason those who claim it is a way to avoid being sus ended being scum after all.