Do you think it can be so easy just like that finding the first mafia? He said he is good or prefers to be mafia than a townie bcuz he think he suck playing as a townie. And let say he's mafia, do you think Gister see the way he played right now is the best way to play as a Mafia? It because it has to many flaws. Yes we can use those flaws as our reason to vote him.
He clearly unable play properly as a townie because the way he made a case for certain player is very confusing and he jumped from one player to other player with no proper connection to whole 'drama' that involving him. The 'drama' that started between him and Odd at first. To be honest he should have Odd at least in his suspicious list and not you and quite surprisingly Koto(a confirmed townie). These all are a good ingredients to suspect him as a mafia if not Serial Killer.
Ok other than Night bullet proof townie or invisible townie, Serial Killer also have night immunity from what I know so far. Its either they become invisible if no night activity from them or they have limitless bullet proof ability in NP and only lynching can kill them.
I'm very doubtful that Gister is a mafia. Why should he exposed himself like that? Its so easy. Something that feel so easy in Mafia game always ended up with a wrong result. But he could be SK for all we know.
And there is another thing about borderline role claiming from him. How he can tell very confident that Shadow Clone no jutsu is what makes him invincible in the NP unless he knows something about the role? This is not really likely a made up claim. He need to know something about the role he speak about. Uchiha Madara also know how to perform Shadow Clone no jutsu but Mafia leader never have Night Kill immunity. Only 'Innocent' revelation when being investigate by Cop. We dont get any roles list with their ability to fake the ability claim. What is Shizune's ability? I don't know.
There are many angles we can look into. Look at every angle and decide which angle is the right one.
.