If GSB hit Indra arrow

[Mellanoma]

I dont think agree entirely, the shark bomb may absorb some initially however to shape manipulate a nature requires an immense concetration of chakra. Especially if it is to retain it's form after leaving the user. You have that and then the overwhelming speed with which it's launched. I think you're right in that it'll evaporate the water. So I see it hitting the water, losing some size and a little speed (meets resistance of water), eveaporating the water then proceeding to pierce through and obliterate Kisame and possibly a country.

Without getting TOO Scientific

The things I disagree with are:

Indra retaining it's shape or getting smaller.

It's impossible for electricity to retain it's form once it's conducted by water no matter how fast its moving. Lightning hits water at 200k+ mph and immediately disperses.


GSB effectiveness (excluding the broken databook definition of GSB. )

I imagine this will happen once indra hit's it:

GSB will begin to grow from the electricity however it will be TOO much energy to absorb thus making the water extremely deadly for Kisame effectively killing him.

I figure if GSB can absorb 15% of Indra within 1 second of impact that remaining 85% will cause GSB to:

Slowly begin a war of evaporation vs absorption.
We could say 100 gallons evaporated for every 15 gallons absorbed.

Keeping in mind:

Kisame will be dead lol

 

[Pappasaur]

I like the way you guys think but I believe because of Indra's properties (Lightning based) vs Kisame's water based GSB they will cancel each other out.


Scenario I see. EVEN IF Indra Arrow's concentrated chakra hit GSB to the point GSB couldn't keep up. It's not like indra arrow would pierce through GSB. The lightning would simply be conducted and distributed through the water. Worse case the lightning would evaporate the water but Indra's arrow would be broken apart. Either way Kisame would probably die from the electicity but technically the attack would be nullified lol.

Thoughts?

It’s hard to say, but honestly with Indra’s arrow being such a powerful attack I just have a hard time seeing GSB nullifying the arrow completely. I think a weaker version would still make it through and turn kisame into a crater lol

 

[Mellanoma]

It’s hard to say, but honestly with Indra’s arrow being such a powerful attack I just have a hard time seeing GSB nullifying the arrow completely. I think a weaker version would still make it through and turn kisame into a crater lol

Read above. Basically what I was saying was the nature of Indra is what will cause it to disperse. Its lightning and lightning is conducted by water causing it to lose its shape. Kisame will be fried near instantly though lol

 

[salamander uchiha]

Without getting TOO Scientific

The things I disagree with are:

Indra retaining it's shape or getting smaller.

It's impossible for electricity to retain it's form once it's conducted by water no matter how fast its moving. Lightning hits water at 200k+ mph and immediately disperses.

Which would normally be the case as lightning normally is shapeless and stringy. However IA is sgape manipulated and concentraded.

GSB effectiveness (excluding the broken databook definition of GSB. )

I imagine this will happen once indra hit's it:

GSB will begin to grow from the electricity however it will be TOO much energy to absorb thus making the water extremely deadly for Kisame effectively killing him.

I figure if GSB can absorb 15% of Indra within 1 second of impact that remaining 85% will cause GSB to:

Slowly being essentially a war of evaporation vs absorption.
We could say 100 gallons evaporated for every 15 gallons absorbed.

Keeping in mind:

Kisame will be dead lol

I think this is where we will disagree, the volume of chakra concetrated in it was only matched by a pseudo JJ. That Pseudo JJ used all the nature energy available(planet), replicated the JJ chakra just to counter it while having the superior affinity. Shark bombs absorbtion speed doesn't really exist as we think of it, it would just get overwhelmed.

 

[ThelUchiha]

Tough call. Indra Arrow is powerful, sure, but a jutsu that feeds off the power of the jutsu it's against is instantly more powerful.

That being said though, Indra arrow is Raiton whereas Great Shark Bullet is Suiton. Raiton beats Suiton techs because it uses the water to further conduct itself. The lighting would interact with the water chakra of the shark and the Indra Arrow would feed off of that as well.

Which won would depend on if the shark absorbed the raiton before it was conducted or not. If it's required to touch the raiton before it absorbs then the Indra Arrow would simply overpower it. If the shark only had to be near the tech to absorb it, Great Shark Bullet would win.

In the anime, the great shark BIT the Daytime Tiger so I assume that's how it would absorb the tech. If the shark had to bite the Indra Arrow, the raiton within the tech would overpower the shark likely before it could be absorbed.

Summary: Indra Arrow would win.

Without getting TOO Scientific

The things I disagree with are:

Indra retaining it's shape or getting smaller.

It's impossible for electricity to retain it's form once it's conducted by water no matter how fast its moving. Lightning hits water at 200k+ mph and immediately disperses.


GSB effectiveness (excluding the broken databook definition of GSB. )

I imagine this will happen once indra hit's it:

GSB will begin to grow from the electricity however it will be TOO much energy to absorb thus making the water extremely deadly for Kisame effectively killing him.

I figure if GSB can absorb 15% of Indra within 1 second of impact that remaining 85% will cause GSB to:

Slowly begin a war of evaporation vs absorption.
We could say 100 gallons evaporated for every 15 gallons absorbed.

Keeping in mind:

Kisame will be dead lol

I think that Indra's arrow would destroy the shark in instant

 

[Pappasaur]

Without getting TOO Scientific

The things I disagree with are:

Indra retaining it's shape or getting smaller.

It's impossible for electricity to retain it's form once it's conducted by water no matter how fast its moving. Lightning hits water at 200k+ mph and immediately disperses.


GSB effectiveness (excluding the broken databook definition of GSB. )

I imagine this will happen once indra hit's it:

GSB will begin to grow from the electricity however it will be TOO much energy to absorb thus making the water extremely deadly for Kisame effectively killing him.

I figure if GSB can absorb 15% of Indra within 1 second of impact that remaining 85% will cause GSB to:

Slowly begin a war of evaporation vs absorption.
We could say 100 gallons evaporated for every 15 gallons absorbed.

Keeping in mind:

Kisame will be dead lol

Read above. Basically what I was saying was the nature of Indra is what will cause it to disperse. Its lightning and lightning is conducted by water causing it to lose its shape. Kisame will be fried near instantly though lol

Oh wow, I completely missed that post lmao. In that case, how far is sasuke standing from the blast? Cause that much lightning couldn’t be contained, you’re right. That’d be one massive explosion lol

 

[Pappasaur]

Which would normally be the case as lightning normally is shapeless and stringy. However IA is sgape manipulated and concentraded.




I think this is where we will disagree, the volume of chakra concetrated in it was only matched by a pseudo JJ. That Pseudo JJ used all the nature energy available(planet), replicated the JJ chakra just to counter it while having the superior affinity. Shark bombs absorbtion speed doesn't really exist as we think of it, it would just get overwhelmed.

Ignoring the absorption rate, I think they’re just talking what’ll happen once the lightning hits the water. The chakra may have been concentrated at the start, but lightning is still lightning and most likely once it hits a large body of water (GSB) it would act like natural lightning would and splinter through every which way the water offers. Nature has a pattern of following the path of least resistance, and fragmenting through every bit of the water would be just that. No, I highly highly doubt GSB could absorb Indra’s arrow, but at the point most likely it wouldn’t matter. Indra’s arrow would burst and if it covered a susanoo arrow as the base, I think that arrow would still go flying through

 

[Mellanoma]

I think they’re just talking what’ll happen once the lightning hits the water. The chakra may have been concentrated at the start, but lightning is still lightning and most likely once it hits a large body of water (GSB) it would act like natural lightning would and splinter through every which way the water offers.

Yes this is exactly why I made the comment about indra dispersing. Ofcourse kisame will be fried to the point of disintegration but it wont maintain its form once its conducted by water.

 

[To Whatever]

GSB eats it.