A Misconception in Gaiden about Shin and his Surgery (*Viz Translations)

Made in Heaven

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
May 30, 2013
Messages
31,444
Reaction score
2,201
Lol I'm not entertaing your Himawari comparison, go push that somewhere else.


Sakura blitzed shin point black period and he had the visual means and readiness to defensively reciprocate her direct line of attack. Dude had 12 sharningan in her direction all activated, he got blitzed and one shotted.

Salt...

Alright, keep clinging to your Sakura feat that even a 3 y/o non-ninja pulled off against an opponent 10,000x stronger :lmao:
 

lndra

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jun 1, 2014
Messages
31,928
Reaction score
2,237
This only shows the attack afterwards and before another was coming but if you pay attention to the panel to the right in the middle of the scans, you see her clearing the debris from in front of her while the knives where there.
It shows that Shin's attacks have already landed and she was losing. From where I'm standing, Sakura is clearing the debris with her free hand. Not the one that's injured.



I read the manga lol, I dont talk out my ass like these hinata faps do but the point in making is that she clearly wasn't paralyzed of she was able to move boulders from in front of her.
If you read the Manga like you're saying, you would know that Shin's ability only paralyzes their entire body when the weapons have surfaced all around their body. Since Shin's weapon only landed on her thus far, then she was only paralyzed at that specific location.

However, he was winning that fight. And Sasuke arrived at the right time to stop his attack from landing.



Again, her arm wasn't paralyzed for the reasons I've explained already (2) Sasuke removed the knives because he was being a gentlemen and I know how much of a troll I sound like but its an honest observation.
1. Shin's weapons have been stated to paralyze their opponents when they touch. I don't care about your opinion on this, that's a fact. That isn't my opinion, again, but that's a fact. That's what THEY do. 2. Sasuke removed the knives and Amaterasu'd them because Shin's ability allows him to freely control the weapons he places seals on, not to mention they paralyze on contact. Gonna have to post these scans to show you where my knowledge is coming from:
You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images







I never said Shin didn't have the upper hand but he certainly didn't negg her nor did he place her in a position where she was left with no cards to play. Again she was clearly moving the debris from around her with knives in her arm. That's context...
Shin was going to neg Sakura if Sasuke wasn't there. She wasn't moving debris around her, as shown in the same panel where there are no debris on her hand. Rocks flying in the air isn't someone carrying debris.






1 never said she wouldve one, I said that byakugou would've reversed her wounds and given Sakura a chance to put up a good fight before Sasukes entrance.
The Byakugou isn't capable of reversing the wounds without her removing the weapons and cancelling out the chakra, which in the immediate fight, is something hard to do when getting cornered. Not to mention they only stopped after Sasuke used Amaterasu.

Now if you can provide a sound argument as to the Byakugou being stated to cancel the effects of his weapons, then sure. I'd be inclined to agree.
 

Joshutsu

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Nov 19, 2012
Messages
6,563
Reaction score
396
BINGO but the people your speaking to are clinging to their hypothetical becuase Sakura had recourse, Sakura could've easily released her seal and reverse the fodder damage his knife did.

You responding to brick walls.

I know lmao but they know and I know. If the seal ain't released, there was no fear for her life.

She was losing either way. her seal not activating doesnt matter as it was no threat to shin who had successfully kept his distance, tagged her already. Nothing suggesting that last thrown weapon won't have carved her up as she was stumbling a bit.

It does because in spite of all you are saying, she did not use byakugou.

Sasuke would've let her finish him off if he truly believed that she actually could lol. Stop denying the obvious.

She's slow enough to be injured by Shin and had Sasuke not intervened Shin could've easily put a blade through her head instantly killing her.

Sasuke could see how she was doing in the fight when he busts in an immidiately takes care of Shin? You make no sense lol

Sasuke and Naruto were injured as well so what's your point there. At the end of the day, Sakura did not ever feel like her life was in danger to the point Sasuke and co showed up.
 

Hyuga Prodigy

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Jul 4, 2009
Messages
8,562
Reaction score
639
Except sasuke chose to crush shin rather than outright kill him on the spot when he grabbed him with ps because he wanted to interrogate him and gain more information. This was after they had came back from orochimaru. Sakura had no idea they were even going to oro in the first place so how is she supposed to know?

Bold. you can't say she had no purpose when the purpose was clearly stated.

Still, Sakura should've immobilize him before he recuperate yet Sasuke was the one to crush him and restrained by shin clones in the end. I believe Sakura manage to grasp some information from him but not the specifics or secrets since Shin only explains the general ideas of Genes and his obvious connection to shin but she did not hold enough accountable information therefore it was self-explanatory why it was never shown in any panel where she shared some info to sasuke since Sasuke wanted to interrogated Shin.

And what purpose did she has again?


Neither does someone who's been here since 2009 and still hates Sakura with a passion. :ls:

Hmm interesting input. You don't see me bash sakura compare to my earlier time in NB, but I knew not to waste my time here unless it's new content worthy or new outtake such as this thread. I see you make countless bash threads and you already made over
3K Posts within the span of 2-3 months and that's not normal.

You don't make enough productive value for me to care to respond your countless baits or the same redundancies threads we got nowadays in NB.
 

Luminousi

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Feb 28, 2012
Messages
992
Reaction score
122
I thought this was what everyone believed to begin with
 

Darth AniCetuS

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Nov 4, 2010
Messages
14,091
Reaction score
838
Sasuke could see how she was doing in the fight when he busts in an immidiately takes care of Shin? You make no sense lol

Sasuke and Naruto were injured as well so what's your point there. At the end of the day, Sakura did not ever feel like her life was in danger to the point Sasuke and co showed up.

Why would he need to see how she's doing lol when he knows she was no match for Shin. Its you who make no sense...:coffee:

The point is Sakura would be dead without Sasuke. Anyone in their right mind would know this lol, Sakura with her below average Taijutsu skills was no match against Shin's blade manipulation abilities. Shin had already managed to injure her and would've killed her had Sasuke not intervened.
 
Last edited:

sasuketenten

Member
Joined
Aug 29, 2009
Messages
176
Reaction score
19
She could have just killed him off instead of healing.

While we don't know for sure,I am assuming that sakura and other medics may take a oath similar to our doctors to do no harm. It's hard to say when you look at the fact that this is a ninja world but this situation was after the fourth ninja war so we are talking more peaceful times.
 

sasuketenten

Member
Joined
Aug 29, 2009
Messages
176
Reaction score
19
Shin knew sakura was a medical ninja I guess becuase of obsessed with wanting to kill Sasuke, he knew he a had a daughter so Knowlage of his wife wouldn't be far fetched. That or Sakura being renowned as Tsunades disciple which is also highly probable.
This exactly..despite what the sakura haters May think,sakura is world renowned at this point for the reasons you pointed out....it's simply math to figure if you are targeting sasuke or his daughter you are going to easily discover who he is married to.....hell sasuke reputation alone would be a reason most ppl in the naruto world would know who sakura is.
 

Darth AniCetuS

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Nov 4, 2010
Messages
14,091
Reaction score
838
While we don't know for sure,I am assuming that sakura and other medics may take a oath similar to our doctors to do no harm. It's hard to say when you look at the fact that this is a ninja world but this situation was after the fourth ninja war so we are talking more peaceful times.

More like to do nothing where it matters...:th:
 

lndra

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jun 1, 2014
Messages
31,928
Reaction score
2,237
This exactly..despite what the sakura haters May think,sakura is world renowned at this point for the reasons you pointed out....it's simply math to figure if you are targeting sasuke or his daughter you are going to easily discover who he is married to.....hell sasuke reputation alone would be a reason most ppl in the naruto world would know who sakura is.
Tsunade said the opposite
 

Reviewing Logic

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Jul 20, 2015
Messages
9,455
Reaction score
428
they changed the capturing scene a bit making Shin's attended target Sarada only for Sakura to save her
 

Joshutsu

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Nov 19, 2012
Messages
6,563
Reaction score
396
Why would he need to see how she's doing lol when he knows she was no match for Shin. Its you who make no sense...:coffee:

The point is Sakura would be dead without Sasuke. Anyone in their right mind would know this lol, Sakura with her below average Taijutsu skills was no match against Shin's blade manipulation abilities. Shin had already managed to injure her and would've killed her had Sasuke not intervened.

You hurt my head. You literally are making no sense. It doesn't matter how you think she was doing because he did not go in there to spectate, he went to save her regardless of how the fight was going. See example:

Sakura saved Sasuke and Naruto from Shin, does that mean he couldn't handle it? She knows he could and she came in and still punched the crap out of him. She did however save them whether they needed it or not.

Sasuke came right in and saved her when she was in the middle of fight under identical circumstances. That does not mean she could not handle it. He also saved her whether she needed it or not. Byakugo was not up, so she did not need it until proven otherwise.
 
Last edited:

Darth AniCetuS

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Nov 4, 2010
Messages
14,091
Reaction score
838
You hurt my head. You literally are making no sense.

Sakura saved Sasuke from Shin, does that mean he couldn't handle it? She knows he could and she came in and still punched the crap out of him.

Sasuke came right in and saved her when she was in the middle of fight under identical circumstances. That does not mean she could not handle it.

How did she save Sasuke when by your own admission Sasuke was perfectly capable of saving himself?

But please do explain how she beats an uchiha with mulitple sharingans and precog, S/T abilities and has the advantage of ranged attacks using her pathetic taijutsu skills and the only time she landed a hit on Shin was using sneak attack when he was occupied with Naruto and Sasuke.
 

Joshutsu

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Nov 19, 2012
Messages
6,563
Reaction score
396
How did she save Sasuke when by your own admission Sasuke was perfectly capable of saving himself?

But please do explain how she beats an uchiha with mulitple sharingans and precog, S/T abilities and has the advantage of ranged attacks using her pathetic taijutsu skills and the only time she landed a hit on Shin was using sneak attack when he was occupied with Naruto and Sasuke.

Because the act of saving someone doesn't always have to do to do with their capabilities if you can ever understand that. People can be saved without needing it, the act of intervening in a situation in itself can be considered as such.

I don't need to explain, she managed to run up on him without him noticing for some reason and was found in the middle of a fight with him outside of byakugo at that makes me not hold him in high regard.

Sasuke found Sakura like she found him. Stabbed and they both took someone out for each other which helped a situation both times no matter what might have went fine if either fights were to persist. The world will never know what would have happened in either case.

Just speculation based on how much you like or dislike a character or if you feel they have adequate feats. I don't care. I will go forward with that I believe because byakugo is a code red i could really die in this situation technique and it didn't show up. I have nothing else to say I have not said before.
 

Darth AniCetuS

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Nov 4, 2010
Messages
14,091
Reaction score
838
Because the act of saving someone doesn't always have to do to do with their capabilities if you can ever understand that. People can be saved without needing it, the act of intervening in a situation in itself can be considered as such.

I don't need to explain, she managed to run up on him without him noticing for some reason and was found in the middle of a fight with him outside of byakugo at that makes me not hold him in high regard.

Sasuke found Sakura like she found him. Stabbed and they both took someone out for each other which helped a situation both times no matter what might have went fine if either fights were to persist. The world will never know what would have happened in either case.

Just speculation based on how much you like or dislike a character or if you feel they have adequate feats. I don't care. I will go forward with that I believe because byakugo is a code red i could really die in this situation technique and it didn't show up. I have nothing else to say I have not said before.

Lol again, you can't save someone who is not in any danger.

So you don't hold him in high regard just cuz he was distracted and wasn't paying attention to Sakura. Anyway we're discussing 1 v 1 and how Sakura manages to beat Shin.

You've failed to explain how Sakura beats him.
 
Top