[VS] Big Mom's Top 3 vs Whitebeard's Top 3

[Uzumaki Macho]

Katakuri, Smoothie, and Cracker VS Marco, Jozu and Vista

Who would win?

In my opinion, the Sweet Commanders would win. Katakuri would have an advantage over Marco since Marco's DF won't help him escape the mochi's stickness since he can only regenerate from damage, and Luffy, who has better physical strength feats than Marco, couldn't escape so Marco wouldn't be able to escape via brute force either. Smoothie would hold an advantage over Jozu since her juice fruit seems to ignore durability, so Jozu's diamond DF won't protect him from her. Cracker, as of now, has better feats than Vista and both have similar portrayal, so I think that Cracker could beat him.

 

[LBeezy]

Who says those characters have to fight in those exact one on one matches you have described though?

I give it to the WB crew..

Smoothie ain't finna do shit to Marco.

Cracker can probably get beat by Jozu, but Marco can for sure defeat Cracker as well.

With Katakuri being the biggest threat, I can see it ending with a 3v1 against him.. and of course he'll probably end up taking out two or at least one of them by the end, but I don't think he'll be the last man standing..

 

[Punk Hazard]

Marco had the physical strength to clash with Akainu and keep him from charging forwards. He most definitely has better strength than Luffy. His feat can slash and cut, so he can cut through Katakuri's Mochi with Haki and damage him like Vergo damaged the smoke Smoker was releasing from his body. Marco can probably get in close and slash him since he has better maneuverability. I'm giving it to Marco.

Smoothie for Jozu, Jozu has better feats given that Smoothie hasn't had feats yet, so he wins.

Vista was able to clash with Mihawk and keep him steady, to the point that Mihawk mused they should just drop it. Cracker lost to Nami and Luffy together, so I don't see him beating someone who can take on Mihawk seriously.

 

[Dgrayman]

whitebeards, because smoothie is going to sit there and not do shit just like she did in this arc, , so it's just going to be 3 vs 2.

 

[Rikudou Tobi]

Whitebeard's crew is stronger.
>Cracker may be a lot more lucid than Jozu, but Jozu's linear movement is too powerful. So you can temporarily stop him, dodge him, and maybe even trip him but you can't really overwhelm him if you're around his level. His diamond skin will bulldoze through the cracker's and take Cracker's haki hits. It only takes one hit to end Cracker since he is physical weak bodied.

>Vista can handle smoothie's feat less haki skills and her fruit power seems to work well against weak beings, no high level person from even the strawhat team was even threatened by her. (from what we've seen)

>Marco's speed is all round better than Dogtooth and strength after what he did to the admirals. The mochi sickness can only help for so long but Dogtooth lacks the fire power to permanently put down Marco. He healed from Kizaru's multiple lasers so what's a jelly shot going to do?

WB crew have a higher attack power by feats including durability and speed. Big mam's crew are more supplementary with Cracker holding the higher fire power of the group from what we're seeing.

 

[Quindale22]

I wonder what a diamond smoothie would taste like lol

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

Whitebeard's crew is stronger.
>Cracker may be a lot more lucid than Jozu, but Jozu's linear movement is too powerful. So you can temporarily stop him, dodge him, and maybe even trip him but you can't really overwhelm him if you're around his level. His diamond skin will bulldoze through the cracker's and take Cracker's haki hits. It only takes one hit to end Cracker since he is physical weak bodied.

>Vista can handle smoothie's feat less haki skills and her fruit power seems to work well against weak beings, no high level person from even the strawhat team was even threatened by her. (from what we've seen)

>Marco's speed is all round better than Dogtooth and strength after what he did to the admirals. The mochi sickness can only help for so long but Dogtooth lacks the fire power to permanently put down Marco. He healed from Kizaru's multiple lasers so what's a jelly shot going to do?

WB crew have a higher attack power by feats including durability and speed. Big mam's crew are more supplementary with Cracker holding the higher fire power of the group from what we're seeing.

Why are you calling him Dogtooth.

 

[Punk Hazard]

Why are you calling him Dogtooth.

This is the kind of discussion you made this thread for, huh?

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

This is the kind of discussion you made this thread for, huh?

I've seen you complain about someone calling him Dogtooth before.

 

[Punk Hazard]

I've seen you complain about someone calling him Dogtooth before.

Yeah but I didn't do that after making a thread asking people to tell me what they think while replying to such a post to that.

 

[Rikudou Tobi]

Why are you calling him Dogtooth.

It's cooler and I like it better. It's like calling Doflamingo "Dofy."

 

[Skull Knight]

whitebeards, because smoothie is going to sit there and not do shit just like she did in this arc, , so it's just going to be 3 vs 2.

Lol

 

[Wrappering_]

WB top 3 were Marco, Ace, and Thatch. Jozu took Thatch's place after he was murdered by BB.
Inferno Ace, Dark Phoenix Marco, and Voidlord Thatch with WB would literally ROFL-stomp BM and Kaido and their lame crews.
Teach was smart to stick with the WBs, cause the other two emperors were lame ducks.

 

[MickNerks]

I have to give it to Whitebeard crew.

Though at this point in the series Luffy does seem to be yonko commander level so I won't fault cracker for losing to him from a strength standpoint, I don't think cracker should have lost as easily as he did. His arrogance allowed him to fall in to luffy's trap which caused his defeat. The whitebeard pirates have shown to be vastly superior in intelligence than to get baited into a trap like that.

Katakuri is the only Commander that has shown competent battle skills. Smoothie has been a disapointment thus far, and though Cracker is incredibly powerful with how he uses his DF, he doesnt seem to have the intelligence needed to take off WB's top 3.

Because of smoothie and cracker, Im giving this match to WB's Commanders