Ashura or Minato?

[kiiro]

He said it depends on the reincarnates power, I didn't think their was a level to it considering that

You must be registered for see links

You must be registered for see links

I know he's referring to Indra, that's the whole point I was saying the whole time.
Tobi said Indra had the powerful chakra, not Ashura. Hagormoo said the exact same thing.

Ashura has physical energy and stamina while Indra has mental energy and chakra
Indra=Powerful chakra
Ashura=Stamina
I've been telling you the difference the whole time wtf.

Yes I did read and see. He didn't merge chakra to Madara, didn't try to heal him or anything like that. He touched him saying that it must be an other way to Tobirama. And Hogoromo didn't thank him. He said he is to kind.

 

[salamander uchiha]

You need to stop being so redundant and actually read what is being said here instead of conjuring your own fiction manga.
Indra inherited his chakra genes, That's what I said and that what the manga said.
You keep saying "he inherited genes"
Genes what? What in the genes did he inherit? Because Kishi said chakra genes and you keep repeating genes like as if "genes" is a counter to "chakra genes."


Do you know what bodily chakra? He said he inherited chakra genes, you need to pay attention to what type of genes are being inherited. Saying that he "inherited genes" doesn't make sense because there's a type of genes that are being inherited.
Read what he said:

You must be registered for see images

He possessed "genes containing my powerful chakra." What genes did Indra inherit? Answer: genes with powerful chakra.
Did he inherit genes with hagormoo's stamina? Did he inherit genes with hagormoo's bodily chakra? Answer: No
Indra has Six path chakra with six path mental energy.


Keep quite and actually learn what the word fanfic means. You're arguing an enterly different purpose here while calling pages I post a fanfic. You don't call viz manga fanfic, fanfic means everything word for word is not in a manga page in the whole entire series.

Let me break it down for you chakra = stamina (produced by the body by all cells) and spiritual energy.
So now Indra inherits the powerful chakra gene a physical quality therefore he inherits the body to produce this powerful stamina and spiritual energy which is merged into chakra. I don't know how much clearer I need to be it's like I'm beating my head against a wall.
Now more importantly Hogaromo makes no such statement about Ashura. That's the reason he gave Ashura the power up necessary to fight Indra.
Now I'm not going to go over this again.

 

[Rikudou Tobi]

Let me break it down for you chakra = stamina (produced by the body by all cells) and spiritual energy.
So now Indra inherits the powerful chakra gene a physical quality therefore he inherits the body to produce this powerful stamina and spiritual energy which is merged into chakra. I don't know how much clearer I need to be it's like I'm beating my head against a wall.
Now more importantly Hogaromo makes no such statement about Ashura. That's the reason he gave Ashura the power up necessary to fight Indra.
Now I'm not going to go over this again.

Stamina is not chakra, read the manga.
stamina is energy!!! used to create more chakra.

Taijutsu uses stamina Ninjutsu/Genjutsu uses chakra

I should not have to repeat myself to you again. If you keep failing this, then I'm completely ignoring this trolling of yours.

 

[salamander uchiha]

Stamina is not chakra, read the manga.
stamina is energy!!! used to create more chakra.

Taijutsu uses stamina Ninjutsu/Genjutsu uses chakra

I should not have to repeat myself to you again. If you keep failing this, then I'm completely ignoring this trolling of yours.

I think your just ignoring the facts or lack the ability to read. Chakra=stamina +spiritual energy. Now if you don't understand that then I suggest you re-read the manga. Stamina is energy produced by all cells + spiritual energy = chakra.
What your talking about for thaijutsu is endurance and because you can't differentiate between the 2 your confused. The manga makes it clear stamina is energy produced by your cells and 1 of the 2 components of chakra.