[VS] Prime WB vs Prime Garp

[HashiraMadara]

This is to clear the difference between "nearly killed each other", "cornered Roger multiple times" AND "He was the only equal to Roger", "He is the only man clash equally to Roger in the Grandline"

 

[Passerby]

Hype wise Whitebeard>Garp.
Prime WB can destroy the world.

 

[HashiraMadara]

Hype wise Whitebeard>Garp.
Prime WB can destroy the world.

Lmao never take those translations seriously, one even said: "this man can slice all there is in this world" Zeff on Mihawk

 

[Xee Etbrkz]

I think that any of the following scenarios is possible

1) Roger = WB>Garp
Hype:-WB was the only equal to Roger

2) Roger >WB=Garp
Hype:- Garp and Roger almost killing each other several times, so it may be so that the only pirate that could have matched Roger was WB and the only Marine that could match Roger was Garp. They might be very near to Roger's level, but still a little weaker.

3) Roger > WB > Garp
The above two statements maybe pure hype and it maybe possible that Garp was never that great to begin with.

I don't know what is the truth, but I think that whatever it is Roger has to be on the top. (No shit I know, but can't conclusively decide based on hype)

 

[Passerby]

Lmao never take those translations seriously, one even said: "this man can slice all there is in this world" Zeff on Mihawk

Isnt that true though? A bloodlusted Mihawk should be able to cut anything that exisits on earth.

 

[HashiraMadara]

I think that any of the following scenarios is possible

1) Roger = WB>Garp
Hype:-WB was the only equal to Roger

2) Roger >WB=Garp
Hype:- Garp and Roger almost killing each other several times, so it may be so that the only pirate that could have matched Roger was WB and the only Marine that could match Roger was Garp. They might be very near to Roger's level, but still a little weaker.

3) Roger > WB > Garp
The above two statements maybe pure hype and it maybe possible that Garp was never that great to begin with.

I don't know what is the truth, but I think that whatever it is Roger has to be on the top. (No shit I know, but can't conclusively decide based on hype)

Well the only Pirate who was equal to and didn't give a shit about Roger was WB according to Buggy. So Roger is like a Luffy's personality residing in WB's body/power. Whereas the Garp hype is built by Roger in ways of persuading Garp to raise Ace. So it can be either he was cunning and marinating his lies or a genuine acknowledgment. The Garp hype among the Marines seems too high to be just lies though...

 

[WoldOfFingo]

Didnt u knew? On NB everyone and their mother are equal to WB.

 

[YellowFang]

Prime WB...

 

[Vandenre1ch]

Overall WB is stronger but it can go either way. Garp almost killed Roger numerous times.

Everyone keeps simplifying things. When two guys on the same level fight, there is no guarantee that the barely stronger one is going to win all the time.

 

[MasqueradeNX]

I feel like this fight is a draw leaning towards WB. I personalty think WB was stronger then Rodger in his prime. I think Roger was just really strong and extreamly luck just like luffy.

 

[arv993]

Garp and wb have incredible hype but wb has the slight edge but regardless it's an extreme diff fight not a high diff one. Cornering someone in their primes and having death matches where it's a stalemate is what you call an even battle. Garp is also the hero of the marines and the most hyped marine to this date so him being at that level in his prime makes a lot of sense

 

[A v i]

Whitebeard was stronger.

 

[Donald J Trump]

I would say Probably equal or WB has slight edge over him.

 

[Fireplay]

WB wins extreme-diff.

It will be nothing short of Akainu vs Aokiji type fight.

These two are probably damn near equal and if they fight it could go either way but im leaning towards WB.

 

[ToshiZO]

Whitebeard and it's not up for debate.

 

[HashiraMadara]

Whitebeard and it's not up for debate.

Why? Your points

 

[ArabianLuffy]

Prime WB can destroy the world.

They should give the title World Breaker to Whitebeard.

 

[3raser]

Why? Your points

Who do u believe will win? And don't tell me it can go either way, just choose one.

 

[-Akuma-]

Didnt u knew? On NB everyone and their mother are equal to WB.

You mean stronger, because apparently any Admiral or Yonko is beating Old WB. Lmao I know right.

OT: WB wins at very high-dif and that's me being a bit biased towards Garp.

 

[Bogard]

Whitebeard of course. Garp's hype doesn't even hold a candle compared to his own