[Discussion] If blackbeard touched brook....

[BusinessManTeno]

Now we all know brook ate the revive revive no mi. Technically making him immortal. Blackbeard can negate dfs..if blackbeard was to touch brook, do you think hed insta die..?

 

[Guntah]

I don't think the Yami Yami no Mi's power applies to all cases of Devil Fruit.

 

[Joker]

I don't think he would die, I just think he wouldn't be capable of manipulating his soul the way he does.

 

[Punk Hazard]

I think Teach said it'd make it like the fruit was never eaten in the first place. Brook would be dead for as long as Teach touche's him, but once he lets go, Brook would return to normal. Just like how when Teach grabbed Luffy, his body turned to normal flesh and Gear Second turned off, then when he let go, Luffy returned to rubber and Gear Second.

 

[chopstickchakra]

I don't think the Yami Yami no Mi's power applies to all cases of Devil Fruit.

I thought the same thing, I thought it only affected Logia but when BB met Luffy at ID it bypassed his fruit as well iirc

Now we all know brook ate the revive revive no mi. Technically making him immortal. Blackbeard can negate dfs..if blackbeard was to touch brook, do you think hed insta die..?

I'd guess he'd probably only "die" while BB's YYnM was active on him. The minute BB let go I'd assume Brook's soul could go back. Idk though.

 

[Punk Hazard]

I don't think the Yami Yami no Mi's power applies to all cases of Devil Fruit.

It does.

 

[Guntah]

It does.

ALL of them? No exceptions? Has that ever been confirmed?

 

[Punk Hazard]

ALL of them? No exceptions? Has that ever been confirmed?

Yes? By Blackbeard. Where are you getting this idea it doesn't.

 

[Guntah]

Yes? By Blackbeard. Where are you getting this idea it doesn't.

Well, I don't think he said every single one specifically...it leaves the possibilities open for exceptions on a potentially game breaking ability.

I just find it hard to believe that he'd be able to kill Brook with one touch. What would happen if he touched Chopper anyway, also?

 

[Portgas D Xatch]

What would happen if he touched himself...#mindblown

 

[Punk Hazard]

Well, I don't think he said every single one specifically...it leaves the possibilities open for exceptions on a potentially game breaking ability.

I just find it hard to believe that he'd be able to kill Brook with one touch. What would happen if he touched Chopper anyway, also?

I don't think you get how the fruit works. Brook would only be dead for as long as Teach is touching him. As soon as Teach lets go, Brook would go back to normal. It works on every Devil Fruit.

 

[TRE MERCER]

I don't think you get how the fruit works. Brook would only be dead for as long as Teach is touching him. As soon as Teach lets go, Brook would go back to normal. It works on every Devil Fruit.

Nope once Brook gets touched he dies thus his fruit leaves his body. Brook can literally be one shotted by teach.

 

[TRE MERCER]

I don't think the Yami Yami no Mi's power applies to all cases of Devil Fruit.

Where are you getting this it only applies to logia nonsense from it worked on Luffy and it worked on Whitebeard

 

[Punk Hazard]

Nope once Brook gets touched he dies thus his fruit leaves his body. Brook can literally be one shotted by teach.

If Teach destroys his skeleton, yeah. But once Teach lets him go, he'd go back to normal.

 

[Guntah]

Where are you getting this it only applies to logia nonsense from it worked on Luffy and it worked on Whitebeard

I have no idea where you got "Logia only" from "not all devil fruits".

 

[Guntah]

I don't think you get how the fruit works. Brook would only be dead for as long as Teach is touching him. As soon as Teach lets go, Brook would go back to normal. It works on every Devil Fruit.

That would make sense. What do you think happens if he touches Chopper though?

 

[Punk Hazard]

That would make sense. What do you think happens if he touches Chopper though?

He'd turn into a normal reindeer.

 

[TRE MERCER]

If Teach destroys his skeleton, yeah. But once Teach lets him go, he'd go back to normal.

Na he'd just be done for.

 

[Punk Hazard]

Na he'd just be done for.

That's not how it works lmfao. Brook's DF power keeps his soul in this realm and able to inhabit his body. Teach lets go, and the DF power resumes working like normal, so his soul would come back.

 

[TRE MERCER]

That would make sense. What do you think happens if he touches Chopper though?

So you assume it works on every other df except for Zoan that literally makes 0 sense.