Boku no Hero: Class 1-A's Strongest

[Guntah]

In Boku no Hero Academia, Class 1-A has three young heroes in the making who obviously hold the top three positions in the class in terms of strength.

You must be registered for see images

Throughout the series (at least the manga) they have all fought each other at least once, but none of the fights were objectively...fair, except perhaps the Todoroki and Midoriya one. But with all of them having greatly developed since then, who is the strongest and who is the weakest of them?

I propose a battle, have it be a Sports Festival-like scenario, where you are aiming for defeat rather than an outright kill, so all three are in character but all three are also fully equipped with their uniforms and abilities up to the latest chapter of the manga.

So who would win?

 

[Sakura Bunny]

Shigaraki!! He's so damaged, deranged, and cute. <3 :sakubun: but forreal, Shouto!

 

[Yata Mirror]

One For All too OP
Modoriya negs

 

[loj]

Katsuki kills people

 

[Guntah]

One For All too OP
Modoriya negs

Midoriya can't control it though, so in a balanced battle, you gotta wonder how much he would do with it.

 

[Your Creepy Stalker]

One For All too OP
Modoriya negs

OFA is literally just super strength, and not even very good strength at that. Compared to explosions and fire/ice, i dont even know how he got as far as he did.

 

[Im Still Robin]

Deku would blitz both of them with his CONTROLLED One For All

/thread

 

[Guntah]

Deku would blitz both of them with his CONTROLLED One For All

/thread

Nope

You must be registered for see images

Mah boi Todoroki icebergs his ass so fast even him, the kid with superspeed and the teacher are surprised by it.

 

[Im Still Robin]

Nope

You must be registered for see images

Mah boi Todoroki icebergs his ass so fast even him, the kid with superspeed and the teacher are surprised by it.

Lol boy that ish old af XD

 

[Guntah]

Lol boy that ish old af XD

Which only means Shouto's blitz has gotten even stronger since then.

 

[chopstickchakra]

How you gonna leave out Tokoyami. Alright he may not be right with those 3 but he's not far behind either. Bakugo and Shouto are just lucky they have powers that make light because come night time he's a force.

Going by the official character book info Shouto is by far the strongest but that's due to his cooperativeness as far as power and all go he's tied with Bakugo in every stat other than cooperativeness.

The stats are;
Power(P)
Speed(S)
Technique(T)
Intelligence(I)
Cooperativeness(C)

Shouto:
P - 5
S - 4
T - 5
I - 4
C - 3
Total - 21
Avg - 4.2
out of 25 - 84%

Bakugo
P - 5
S - 4
T - 5
I - 4
C - 1
Total - 19
Avg - 3.8
out of 25 - 76%

Tokoyami
P - 2
S - 3
T - 4
I - 3
C - 5
Total - 17
Avg 3.4
Out of 25 - 68%

Midoriya
P - 1
S - 1
T - 4
I - 4
C - 5
Total - 15
Avg - 3
out of 25 - 60%

The percentages can be seen as how ready they are to be a hero. None are ready so none are an A. Shouto is a B, he's clearly the most ready. Bakugo is a C, he's ready physically but not mentally. Tokoyami is less prepared physically but around the same spot or slightly above mentally so he has more of a way to go than Bakugo. And Midoriya is a D who is ready mentally but not at all physically.

Midoriya and Tokoyami lack significantly in the strength however both of their powers supplement their strength. You can argue in OFA Midoriya is a 5 in P and in Black Ankh Tokoyami is a 4 in P and can be a 5 if dark enough. That said Tokoyami would never be able to beat Shouto or Bakugo but he could be comparable in terms of strength and abilities.

 

[Guntah]

How you gonna leave out Tokoyami. Alright he may not be right with those 3 but he's not far behind either. Bakugo and Shouto are just lucky they have powers that make light because come night time he's a force.

Well, he is the fourth, with Iida obviously as fifth. But I don't think his power matches up to the other three in a day scenario. At night, yes, but then we have the same reason where this has to be a restricted battle, that being because Midoriya in a death battle just wrecks his arm and kills everyone in the battlefield, so....

 

[Natsu Shazneel]

All Might is the strongest.

You must be registered for see images